title: The role of natural selection in the origin of life.
abstract: It is commonly accepted among origin-of-life scientists that the emergence of life was an evolutionary process involving at one stage or other the working of natural selection. Researchers disagree, however, on the nature of the chemical infrastructure that could have formed prebiotically, enabling the evolutionary process. The division of the origin-of-life research community into 'geneticists' and 'metabolists' usually revolves around the issue whether the first to arise prebiotically was a genetic polymer or a primitive metabolic system. In this paper I offer an alternative classification based on the attitude to the onset of natural selection. From this perspective I add to the conventional division between gene-first and metabolism-first groups a position I call "preparatory metabolism". By this line of thought, an RNA or an RNA-like polymer could not have emerged prebiotically. Nevertheless, the onset of natural selection had to wait until such a polymer had arised. This paper examines the RNA-first, RNA-later, metabolism-first and preparatory-metabolism scenarios, assessing the weaknesses and strengths of each. I conclude that despite the recent theoretical advances in all these lines of research, and despite experimental breakthroughs, especially in overcoming several RNA-first hurdles, none of the examined paradigms has yet attained decisive experimental support. Demonstrating the evolvability of a potentially prebiotic infrastructure, whether genetic or metabolic, is a most serious challenge. So is the experimental demonstration of the emergence of such an infrastructure under prebiotic conditions. The current agenda before origin-of-life researchers of all stripes and colors is the search for the experimental means to tackle all these difficulties.
authors.affiliation: Department of Humanities and Arts, Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, Technion City, Haifa, 32000, Israel. iris.fry@gmail.com
authors.forename: Iris
authors.initials: I
authors.lastname: Fry
mesh_terms: D005075:Biological Evolution; D019418:Evolution, Chemical; D000069497:Origin of Life; D011108:Polymers / Q000378:metabolism; D012313:RNA / Q000235:genetics / Q000378:metabolism; D012641:Selection, Genetic
chemical_list: D011108:Polymers; D012313:RNA
references.citation: Astrobiology. 2001 Fall;1(3):271-81
references.pmid: 12448990
references.citation: Nature. 2009 May 14;459(7244):239-42
references.pmid: 19444213
references.citation: Nature. 2008 Jul 3;454(7200):37-8
references.pmid: 18596792
references.citation: Nature. 2006 Jun 1;441(7093):621-3
references.pmid: 16738656
references.citation: J Am Chem Soc. 2002 Jun 19;124(24):6808-9
references.pmid: 12059185
references.citation: Astrobiology. 2008 Apr;8(2):267-72
references.pmid: 18393692
references.citation: Nature. 1996 Aug 8;382(6591):525-8
references.pmid: 8700225
references.citation: Orig Life Evol Biosph. 2004 Jun;34(3):307-21
references.pmid: 15068037
references.citation: Annu Rev Biochem. 2004;73:791-836
references.pmid: 15189159
references.citation: Science. 2009 Feb 27;323(5918):1229-32
references.pmid: 19131595
references.citation: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009 Jun 9;106(23):9144-6
references.pmid: 19478058
references.citation: Microbiol Rev. 1988 Dec;52(4):452-84
references.pmid: 3070320
references.citation: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2004 Sep 7;101(36):13168-73
references.pmid: 15340153
references.citation: Nature. 2009 May 14;459(7244):171-2
references.pmid: 19444196
references.citation: Science. 2004 Sep 3;305(5689):1474-6
references.pmid: 15353806
references.citation: Orig Life Evol Biosph. 1999 Oct;29(5):441-9
references.pmid: 10573686
references.citation: Nature. 2005 Feb 10;433(7026):581-2
references.pmid: 15703726
references.citation: Orig Life Evol Biosph. 1993 Dec;23(5-6):323-7
references.pmid: 8115163
references.citation: Science. 2001 May 18;292(5520):1319-25
references.pmid: 11358999
references.citation: Nature. 2008 Jul 3;454(7200):122-5
references.pmid: 18528332
references.citation: Science. 2006 Oct 27;314(5799):630-2
references.pmid: 17068257
references.citation: Orig Life Evol Biosph. 1995 Dec;25(6):515-30
references.pmid: 7494634
references.citation: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2000 Nov 7;97(23):12503-7
references.pmid: 11058157
references.citation: Orig Life Evol Biosph. 2003 Dec;33(6):559-74
references.pmid: 14601926
references.citation: Trends Biochem Sci. 2004 Jul;29(7):358-63
references.pmid: 15236743
references.citation: Nature. 2001 Jan 18;409(6818):387-90
references.pmid: 11201752
references.citation: Nature. 2009 May 21;459(7245):316-9
references.pmid: 19458689
references.citation: Nature. 1997 Dec 11;390(6660):591-4
references.pmid: 9403686
references.citation: J Mol Biol. 1968 Dec;38(3):381-93
references.pmid: 5718557
references.citation: Orig Life Evol Biosph. 2007 Oct;37(4-5):455-8
references.pmid: 17597420
references.citation: Orig Life Evol Biosph. 2001 Feb-Apr;31(1-2):119-45
references.pmid: 11296516
references.citation: Curr Opin Chem Biol. 2004 Dec;8(6):654-9
references.pmid: 15556411
references.citation: J Biol Chem. 2008 Dec 26;283(52):36494-503
references.pmid: 18977755
references.citation: Orig Life Evol Biosph. 2007 Oct;37(4-5):309-14
references.pmid: 17602311
references.citation: Science. 2003 Aug 15;301(5635):938-40
references.pmid: 12920291
references.citation: Astrobiology. 2006 Apr;6(2):297-8
references.pmid: 16689646
references.citation: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1994 May 10;91(10):4283-7
references.pmid: 8183902
references.citation: Science. 1999 Jun 25;284(5423):2118-24
references.pmid: 10381870
references.citation: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2002 Oct 1;99(20):12733-40
references.pmid: 12239349
references.citation: Science. 1993 Sep 10;261(5127):1411-8
references.pmid: 7690155
references.citation: Orig Life Evol Biosph. 2003 Apr;33(2):211-8
references.pmid: 12967268
references.citation: J Theor Biol. 1986 Mar 7;119(1):1-24
references.pmid: 3713221
references.citation: Science. 2004 Jan 9;303(5655):196
references.pmid: 14716004
references.citation: RNA. 2007 Jul;13(7):1017-26
references.pmid: 17586759
references.citation: Crit Rev Biochem Mol Biol. 2004 Mar-Apr;39(2):99-123
references.pmid: 15217990