Indoor residual spraying for preventing malaria.
BACKGROUND
Primary malaria prevention on a large scale depends on two vector control interventions: indoor residual spraying (IRS) and insecticide-treated mosquito nets (ITNs). Historically, IRS has reduced malaria transmission in many settings in the world, but the health effects of IRS have never been properly quantified. This is important, and will help compare IRS with other vector control interventions.


OBJECTIVE
To quantify the impact of IRS alone, and to compare the relative impacts of IRS and ITNs, on key malariological parameters.


METHODS
We searched the Cochrane Infectious Diseases Group Specialized Register (September 2009), CENTRAL (The Cochrane Library 2009, Issue 3), MEDLINE (1966 to September 2009), EMBASE (1974 to September 2009), LILACS (1982 to September 2009), mRCT (September 2009), reference lists, and conference abstracts. We also contacted researchers in the field, organizations, and manufacturers of insecticides (June 2007).


METHODS
Cluster randomized controlled trials (RCTs), controlled before-and-after studies (CBA) and interrupted time series (ITS) of IRS compared to no IRS or ITNs. Studies examining the impact of IRS on special groups not representative of the general population, or using insecticides and dosages not recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO) were excluded.


METHODS
Two authors independently reviewed trials for inclusion. Two authors extracted data, assessed risk of bias and analysed the data. Where possible, we adjusted confidence intervals (CIs) for clustering. Studies were grouped into those comparing IRS with no IRS, and IRS compared with ITNs, and then stratified by malaria endemicity.


RESULTS
IRS versus no IRSStable malaria (entomological inoculation rate (EIR) > 1): In one RCT in Tanzania IRS reduced re-infection with malaria parasites detected by active surveillance in children following treatment; protective efficacy (PE) 54%. In the same setting, malaria case incidence assessed by passive surveillance was marginally reduced in children aged one to five years; PE 14%, but not in children older than five years (PE -2%). In the IRS group, malaria prevalence was slightly lower but this was not significant (PE 6%), but mean haemoglobin was higher (mean difference 0.85 g/dL).In one CBA trial in Nigeria, IRS showed protection against malaria prevalence during the wet season (PE 26%; 95% CI 20 to 32%) but not in the dry season (PE 6%; 95% CI -4 to 15%). In one ITS in Mozambique, the prevalence was reduced substantially over a period of 7 years (from 60 to 65% prevalence to 4 to 8% prevalence; the weighted PE before-after was 74% (95% CI 72 to 76%).Unstable malaria (EIR < 1): In two RCTs, IRS reduced the incidence rate of all malaria infections;PE 31% in India, and 88% (95% CI 69 to 96%) in Pakistan. By malaria species, IRS also reduced the incidence of P. falciparum (PE 93%, 95% CI 61 to 98% in Pakistan) and P. vivax (PE 79%, 95% CI 45 to 90% in Pakistan); There were similar impacts on malaria prevalence for any infection: PE 76% in Pakistan; PE 28% in India. When looking separately by parasite species, for P. falciparum there was a PE of 92% in Pakistan and 34% in India; for P. vivax there was a PE of 68% in Pakistan and no impact demonstrated in India (PE of -2%).IRS versus Insecticide Treated Nets (ITNs)Stable malaria (EIR > 1): Only one RCT was done in an area of stable transmission (in Tanzania). When comparing parasitological re-infection by active surveillance after treatment in short-term cohorts, ITNs appeared better, but it was likely not to be significant as the unadjusted CIs approached 1 (risk ratio IRS:ITN = 1.22). When the incidence of malaria episodes was measured by passive case detection, no difference was found in children aged one to five years (risk ratio = 0.88, direction in favour of IRS). No difference was found for malaria prevalence or haemoglobin.Unstable malaria (EIR < 1): Two studies; for incidence and prevalence, the malaria rates were higher in the IRS group compared to the ITN group in one study. Malaria incidence was higher in the IRS arm in India (risk ratio IRS:ITN = 1.48) and in South Africa (risk ratio 1.34 but the cluster unadjusted CIs included 1). For malaria prevalence, ITNs appeared to give better protection against any infection compared to IRS in India (risk ratio IRS:ITN = 1.70) and also for both P. falciparum (risk ratio IRS:ITN = 1.78) and P. vivax (risk ratio IRS:ITN = 1.37).


CONCLUSIONS
Historical and programme documentation has clearly established the impact of IRS. However, the number of high-quality trials are too few to quantify the size of effect in different transmission settings. The evidence from randomized comparisons of IRS versus no IRS confirms that IRS reduces malaria incidence in unstable malaria settings, but randomized trial data from stable malaria settings is very limited. Some limited data suggest that ITN give better protection than IRS in unstable areas, but more trials are needed to compare the effects of ITNs with IRS, as well as to quantify their combined effects.
Pluess
Bianca
B
Public Health and Epidemiology, Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute, Basel, Switzerland, 4002.
Tanser
Frank C
FC
Lengeler
Christian
C
Sharp
Brian L
BL
D017954:Africa South of the Sahara / Q000453:epidemiology; D000818:Animals; D006801:Humans; D015994:Incidence; D007194:India / Q000453:epidemiology; D007303:Insect Vectors; D057148:Insecticide-Treated Bednets; D007306:Insecticides; D008288:Malaria / Q000453:epidemiology / Q000517:prevention & control*; D009032:Mosquito Control / Q000379:methods*; D010154:Pakistan / Q000453:epidemiology; D010573:Pesticide Residues; D016032:Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic
D007306:Insecticides; D010573:Pesticide Residues
Arch Inst Pasteur Madagascar. 2001;67(1-2):21-6
12471742
Salud Publica Mex. 1993 Jan-Feb;35(1):27-38
8470018
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1981;75(6):811-3
7330942
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1960 Nov;54:523-8
13769878
Trop Med Int Health. 2004 Jan;9(1):125-32
14728616
Ecol Dis. 1982;1(4):243-55
6206995
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1953 Jul;47(4):299-308
13090289
Indian J Malariol. 1951 Mar;5(1):75-124
14917421
S Afr Med J. 2005 Nov;95(11):871-4
16344885
J Commun Dis. 1993 Jun;25(2):47-51
8021425
Arch Inst Pasteur Madagascar. 2001;67(1-2):27-30
12471743
Indian J Malariol. 1986 Jun;23(1):27-38
2428678
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2007 Jan 24;(1):CD003758
17253495
Stat Methods Med Res. 2000 Apr;9(2):95-116
10946429
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2004 Aug;71(2 Suppl):214-23
15331840
Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health. 1993 Dec;24(4):664-71
7939937
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1986;80(4):537-45
3810786
Clin Microbiol Rev. 2002 Apr;15(2):278-93
11932233
Trop Med Int Health. 1998 Aug;3(8):619-31
9735932
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1999 Sep-Oct;93(5):455-6
10696394
J Indian Med Assoc. 1984 Jan;82(1):33-4
6747320
Pak J Health. 1954 Jan;3(4):227-40
13154953
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1999 Sep-Oct;93(5):453-4
10696393
Indian J Malariol. 1950 Dec;4(4):487-503
14880196
Bull Mem Acad R Med Belg. 1991;146(1-2):157-65
1933066
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2008 Feb;78(2):248-50
18256424
Trop Med Int Health. 2006 Oct;11(10):1512-20
17002725
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2001 Jan-Feb;95(1):14-8
11280055
Bull Soc Pathol Exot. 1998;91(1):87-90
9559175
Bull World Health Organ. 1954;11(4-5):525-56
13209313
Trop Doct. 1977 Apr;7(2):81-91
854978
Malar J. 2007 May 22;6:67
17519019
Indian J Malariol. 1990 Mar;27(1):1-13
2384182
Indian J Med Res. 1990 Mar;91:151-8
2345023
J Trop Med Hyg. 1982 Dec;85(6):239-44
7154146
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2007 Jun;76(6):1027-32
17556606
J Vector Borne Dis. 2005 Jun;42(2):54-60
16161701
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1946 Jul;26:383-415
20996626
An Inst Med Trop (Lisb). 1952 Jun;9(2):623-42
13058146
Indian J Malariol. 1995 Sep;32(3):112-8
8936293
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1994 Jul-Aug;88(4):378-9
7570809
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1997 May-Jun;91(3):252-5
9231188
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1998 Mar-Apr;92(2):135-6
9764314
Nature. 2002 Feb 7;415(6872):680-5
11832956
Int J Epidemiol. 2002 Aug;31(4):839-46
12177032
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2002 Jan;66(1):2-6
12135262
Bull World Health Organ. 1999;77(8):624-40
10516785
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2009 Sep;81(3):519-24
19706925
Acta Trop. 1978 Mar;35(1):69-82
25000
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1999 Sep-Oct;93(5):456-7
10696395
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1996 Mar-Apr;90(2):100-2
8761560
Trop Med Int Health. 2000 Jul;5(7):472-81
10964269
Emerg Infect Dis. 2004 Jun;10(6):1170-1; author reply 1171-2
15224677
Ji Sheng Chong Xue Yu Ji Sheng Chong Bing Za Zhi. 1984;2(4):220-3
6394169
S Afr Med J. 2001 Nov;91(11):978-83
11847921
Bull World Health Organ. 1967;36(6):913-35
5299860
Bull World Health Organ. 2001;79(7):687
11477975
Trop Med Int Health. 2001 Apr;6(4):280-95
11348519
J Commun Dis. 1985 Mar;17(1):77-86
4031446
Trop Geogr Med. 1977 Mar;29(1):1-7
578040
Gac Med Mex. 1994 Sep-Oct;130(5):313-9
7607360
Trop Med Int Health. 2002 Apr;7(4):298-303
11952944
Med Vet Entomol. 1993 Oct;7(4):333-8
8268487
Trop Med Int Health. 2002 Jul;7(7):565-72
12100438
J Trop Med Hyg. 1980 Oct;83(5):211-21
7431465
Med Vet Entomol. 1987 Jul;1(3):289-95
2979544
Indian J Malariol. 1961 Sep;15:233-8
14497388
Malar J. 2006 Feb 06;5:10
16460558
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2004;(2):CD000363
15106149
Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health. 1997 Dec;28(4):851-6
9656414
J Commun Dis. 2000 Sep;32(3):190-200
11407005
Malar J. 2006 Apr 24;5:33
16635265
Indian J Malariol. 1947 Jun;1(2):279-87
18901450
Bull World Health Organ. 1976;54(4):369-77
1088350
Med Vet Entomol. 2000 Jun;14(2):181-9
10872862
Health Educ Res. 1996 Jun;11(2):133-45
10163407
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2009 Jan;80(1):133-40
19141851
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2001 Oct;65(4):279-84
11693869
J Commun Dis. 1996 Mar;28(1):38-44
8778179
Acta Trop. 1975;32(3):206-31
1984
Med Trop (Mars). 1978 Nov-Dec;38(6):679-84
85235
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2007 Jan;76(1):42-7
17255227
Indian J Malariol. 1986 Dec;23(2):127-31
3569620
Indian J Malariol. 1997 Dec;34(4):173-87
9699421
Bull World Health Organ. 1978;56(3):445-52
308409
Trop Med Int Health. 2002 Sep;7(9):732-6
12225502
Bull World Health Organ. 1951;4(3):443-61
14886722
J Am Mosq Control Assoc. 2004 Dec;20(4):418-23
15669384
J Am Mosq Control Assoc. 2004 Dec;20(4):424-8
15669385
Ann Soc Belg Med Trop. 1992 Jun;72(2):103-12
1417157
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1961 May;10:327-34
13769879
Indian J Malariol. 1951 Mar;5(1):1-73
14917420
Malar J. 2008 Dec 17;7:258
19091114
J Am Mosq Control Assoc. 1993 Jun;9(2):210-20
8350078
Acta Trop. 1993 Aug;54(2):141-51
7902649
Zhongguo Ji Sheng Chong Xue Yu Ji Sheng Chong Bing Za Zhi. 2002;20(4):238-41
12568035
Bull World Health Organ. 2000;78(12):1389-400
11196486
Bull World Health Organ. 1954;11(4-5):765-83
13209319
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2006 Apr 19;(2):CD003755
16625591
J Natl Malar Soc. 1951 Jun;10(2):99-123
14850971
Trop Med Int Health. 2005 Feb;10(2):160-8
15679559
Acta Trop. 1995 Sep;60(1):3-13
8546036
Trop Med Int Health. 2004 Aug;9(8):846-56
15303988
Parasite. 2001 Dec;8(4):309-16
11802267
East Afr Med J. 1951 Feb;28(2):67-74
14840362
Rev Bras Malariol Doencas Trop. 1966 Jul-Dec;18(3):763-79
5998448
Acta Trop. 1974;31(2):129-64
4153083
Med Trop (Mars). 1961 Nov-Dec;21:846-69
13877440
Med J Malaya. 1957 Sep;12(1):319-47
13492806
East Afr Med J. 1961 Jan;38:1-26
13720940
Ann Soc Belg Med Trop. 1991;71 Suppl 1:113-25
1793263
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1989;83 Suppl:97-8
2623758
J Med Entomol. 1993 Jul;30(4):664-82
8360891
Acta Leiden. 1957;27:1-128
13443838
Bull World Health Organ. 1984;62(5):783-94
6391717
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2006 Jun;74(6):972-8
16760506
Sante. 1996 Mar-Apr;6(2):97-101
8705136
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2008 Jul;79(1):12-8
18606758
Soc Sci Med. 2004 Aug;59(3):525-39
15144762
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1975;69(2):236-42
1172640