Bias versus bias: harnessing hindsight to reveal paranormal belief change beyond demand characteristics.
Psychological change is difficult to assess, in part because self-reported beliefs and attitudes may be biased or distorted. The present study probed belief change, in an educational context, by using the hindsight bias to counter another bias that generally plagues assessment of subjective change. Although research has indicated that skepticism courses reduce paranormal beliefs, those findings may reflect demand characteristics (biases toward desired, skeptical responses). Our hindsight-bias procedure circumvented demand by asking students, following semester-long skepticism (and control) courses, to recall their precourse levels of paranormal belief. People typically remember themselves as previously thinking, believing, and acting as they do now, so current skepticism should provoke false recollections of previous skepticism. Given true belief change, therefore, skepticism students should have remembered themselves as having been more skeptical than they were. They did, at least about paranormal topics that were covered most extensively in the course. Our findings thus show hindsight to be useful in evaluating cognitive change beyond demand characteristics.
Kane
Michael J
MJ
Department of Psychology, University of North Carolina, Greensboro, North Carolina 27412, USA. mjkane@uncg.edu
Core
Tammy J
TJ
Hunt
R Reed
RR
D001290:Attitude; D003071:Cognition; D003469:Culture; D004522:Educational Status; D006801:Humans; D010268:Parapsychology; D011287:Prejudice
Psychol Res. 2008 Jul;72(4):362-75
17676336
J Pers Soc Psychol. 1986 Oct;51(4):858-66
3783430
Memory. 2006 Apr;14(3):297-306
16574586
Psychol Bull. 1994 Jul;116(1):117-42
8078969
Qual Saf Health Care. 2003 Aug;12(4):304-11; discussion 311-2
12897366
Psychol Bull. 1967 Nov;68(5):304-5
6062585
J Pers Soc Psychol. 1987 Mar;52(3):611-9
3572729
J Pers Soc Psychol. 1970 Jan;14(1):23-31
5435536
Psychol Aging. 2003 Dec;18(4):639-57
14692854
Pain. 1982 Jul;13(3):281-285
7122113