Should we allow organ donation euthanasia? Alternatives for maximizing the number and quality of organs for transplantation.
There are not enough solid organs available to meet the needs of patients with organ failure. Thousands of patients every year die on the waiting lists for transplantation. Yet there is one currently available, underutilized, potential source of organs. Many patients die in intensive care following withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment whose organs could be used to save the lives of others. At present the majority of these organs go to waste. In this paper we consider and evaluate a range of ways to improve the number and quality of organs available from this group of patients. Changes to consent arrangements (for example conscription of organs after death) or changes to organ donation practice could dramatically increase the numbers of organs available, though they would conflict with currently accepted norms governing transplantation. We argue that one alternative, Organ Donation Euthanasia, would be a rational improvement over current practice regarding withdrawal of life support. It would give individuals the greatest chance of being able to help others with their organs after death. It would increase patient autonomy. It would reduce the chance of suffering during the dying process. We argue that patients should be given the choice of whether and how they would like to donate their organs in the event of withdrawal of life support in intensive care. Continuing current transplantation practice comes at the cost of death and prolonged organ failure. We should seriously consider all of the alternatives.
Wilkinson
Dominic
D
University of Oxford University, UK.
Savulescu
Julian
J
D024362:Advance Directive Adherence; D001926:Brain Death; D028601:Euthanasia, Active / Q000941:ethics*; D006801:Humans; D009927:Tissue and Organ Procurement / Q000941:ethics*; D028761:Withholding Treatment
Front Biosci. 1996 Sep 01;1:d248-65
9159232
Br J Anaesth. 2008 Jun;100(6):735-7
18483109
Med Law. 2001;20(3):417-23
11713840
J Clin Ethics. 2003 Spring-Summer;14(1-2):26-36
12953351
Clin Transplant. 2000 Apr;14(2):152-6
10770421
N Engl J Med. 2007 Jul 19;357(3):209-13
17634455
J Trauma. 2005 Jun;58(6):1095-101; discussion 1101-2
15995454
N Engl J Med. 2008 Aug 14;359(7):709-14
18703473
Intensive Care Med. 2006 May;32(5):708-12
16534569
BMJ. 2009 Jan 14;338:a3162
19147479
ASAIO J. 2006 Mar-Apr;52(2):119-22
16557095
BMC Med Ethics. 2008 Apr 25;9:8
18439242
Kennedy Inst Ethics J. 1993 Jun;3(2):131-43
10126526
J Hosp Med. 2007 Sep;2(5):324-34
17935243
Anaesth Intensive Care. 2007 Jun;35(3):387-92
17591134
Soc Sci Med. 2004 Dec;59(11):2325-34
15450707
Am J Transplant. 2006 Feb;6(2):281-91
16426312
Am J Kidney Dis. 2002 Mar;39(3):611-5
11877582
Lancet. 1997 Mar 22;349(9055):867-71
9121275
Transpl Int. 2008 Sep;21(9):915
18537924
J Med Ethics. 2007 Mar;33(3):146-9
17329384
J Med Ethics. 2009 Aug;35(8):508-11
19644010
Philos Ethics Humanit Med. 2007 May 22;2:8
17519030
Hastings Cent Rep. 2008 Jul-Aug;38(4):14-5
18709913
Lancet. 1998 Jun 27;351(9120):1950-2
9654279
Semin Dial. 2005 Nov-Dec;18(6):469-73
16398708
J Health Econ. 2006 Jul;25(4):599-620
16490267
Transplant Rev (Orlando). 2008 Jul;22(3):210-4
18631881
Intensive Care Med. 2001 Nov;27(11):1744-9
11810117
Philos Ethics Humanit Med. 2007 Aug 24;2:18
17718918
Crit Care Med. 2003 Sep;31(9):2391-6
14501972
Philos Ethics Humanit Med. 2007 Nov 25;2:28
18036254
Int J Health Serv. 2008;38(4):641-52
19069285
Lancet. 1998 Dec 5;352(9143):1808-12
9851380
Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2006 Oct;21(10):2900-7
16861245
Methods Mol Biol. 2006;333:1-28
16790845
J Med Ethics. 2008 Apr;34(4):223-4
18375669
Int Anesthesiol Clin. 2001 Summer;39(3):103-16
11524603
Pediatrics. 1998 Jun;101(6):1049-52
9606234
N Engl J Med. 2008 Aug 14;359(7):669-71
18703467
Br J Anaesth. 2008 Jun;100(6):820-6
18456642
Kennedy Inst Ethics J. 1993 Jun;3(2):263-78
10126538
Br J Anaesth. 2005 Nov;95(5):592-5
16183683
Kidney Int. 2003 Apr;63(4):1516-29
12631369
J Med Ethics. 2008 Jul;34(7):526-9
18591287
Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 2003 May;47(5):501-7
12699505
Neurology. 2002 Jan 8;58(1):20-5
11781400
Boston Univ Law Rev. 1989 Jul;68(4):681-728
11650249
Crit Care Med. 1995 Sep;23(9):1567-75
7664560
Hastings Cent Rep. 1999 Nov-Dec;29(6):6-14
10641238
N Engl J Med. 2008 Aug 14;359(7):672-3
18703468
Intern Med J. 2008 Dec;38(12):911-7
19120548
Bioethics. 2009 Oct;23(8):450-9
18554277
Kennedy Inst Ethics J. 2004 Sep;14(3):261-76
15497226