Life cycle assessment of overhead and underground primary power distribution.
Electrical power can be distributed in overhead or underground systems, both of which generate a variety of environmental impacts at all stages of their life cycles. While there is considerable literature discussing the trade-offs between both systems in terms of aesthetics, safety, cost, and reliability, environmental assessments are relatively rare and limited to power cable production and end-of-life management. This paper assesses environmental impacts from overhead and underground medium voltage power distribution systems as they are currently built and managed by Southern California Edison (SCE). It uses process-based life cycle assessment (LCA) according to ISO 14044 (2006) and SCE-specific primary data to the extent possible. Potential environmental impacts have been calculated using a wide range of midpoint indicators, and robustness of the results has been investigated through sensitivity analysis of the most uncertain and potentially significant parameters. The studied underground system has higher environmental impacts in all indicators and for all parameter values, mostly due to its higher material intensity. For both systems and all indicators the majority of impact occurs during cable production. Promising strategies for impact reduction are thus cable failure rate reduction for overhead and cable lifetime extension for underground systems.
Bumby
Sarah
S
Bren School of Environmental Science and Management, University of California, Santa Barbara, California 93106-5131, USA.
Druzhinina
Ekaterina
E
Feraldi
Rebe
R
Werthmann
Danae
D
Geyer
Roland
R
Sahl
Jack
J
D002140:California; D003247:Conservation of Natural Resources; D011211:Electric Power Supplies; D004777:Environment; D013997:Time Factors