Disembodying cognition.
The idea that concepts are embodied by our motor and sensory systems is popular in current theorizing about cognition. Embodied cognition accounts come in different versions and are often contrasted with a purely symbolic amodal view of cognition. Simulation, or the hypothesis that concepts simulate the sensory and motor experience of real world encounters with instances of those concepts, has been prominent in psychology and cognitive neuroscience. Here, with a focus on spatial thought and language, I review some of the evidence cited in support of simulation versions of embodied cognition accounts. While these data are extremely interesting and many of the experiments are elegant, knowing how to best interpret the results is often far from clear. I point out that a quick acceptance of embodied accounts runs the danger of ignoring alternate hypotheses and not scrutinizing neuroscience data critically. I also review recent work from my lab that raises questions about the nature of sensory motor grounding in spatial thought and language. In my view, the question of whether or not cognition is grounded is more fruitfully replaced by questions about gradations in this grounding. A focus on disembodying cognition, or on graded grounding, opens the way to think about how humans abstract. Within neuroscience, I propose that three functional anatomic axes help frame questions about the graded nature of grounded cognition. First, are questions of laterality differences. Do association cortices in both hemispheres instantiate the same kind of sensory or motor information? Second, are questions about ventral dorsal axes. Do neuronal ensembles along this axis shift from conceptual representations of objects to the relationships between objects? Third, are questions about gradients centripetally from sensory and motor cortices towards and within perisylvian cortices. How does sensory and perceptual information become more language-like and then get transformed into language proper?
Chatterjee
Anjan
A
University of Pennsylvania.
Eur J Neurosci. 2005 Feb;21(3):793-7
15733097
J Cogn Neurosci. 1997 Jan;9(1):133-42
23968185
Cereb Cortex. 2005 Aug;15(8):1243-9
15616133
Brain Lang. 1990 Jan;38(1):21-47
2302544
Neurology. 1998 Feb;50(2):324-5
9484344
Neuroimage. 2002 Oct;17(2):812-24
12377156
Brain Lang. 1995 Sep;50(3):325-38
7583193
Brain. 1999 Dec;122 ( Pt 12):2337-44
10581226
Cognition. 1987 Jul;26(2):89-114
3652651
Cereb Cortex. 2007 Aug;17(8):1958-69
17101687
J Cogn Neurosci. 2005 Jun;17(6):905-17
16021798
Trends Cogn Sci. 2001 Feb 1;5(2):55-61
11166635
J Cogn Neurosci. 2006 Sep;18(9):1498-517
16989551
Trends Cogn Sci. 1999 Sep;3(9):345-351
10461197
J Exp Psychol Gen. 2006 Feb;135(1):1-11
16478313
Cognition. 1996 Aug;60(2):173-204
8811744
Q J Exp Psychol (Hove). 2008 Jun;61(6):825-50
18470815
Cogn Neuropsychol. 2003;20(3-6):575-87
16648880
Brain Lang. 1997 Jan;56(1):107-37
8994700
J Cogn Neurosci. 2000 Jan;12(1):48-55
10769305
Neuron. 2008 Oct 23;60(2):235-46
18957216
Brain Lang. 2006 Jun;97(3):306-16
16430949
J Neurosci. 2006 Jul 26;26(30):7942-9
16870739
Neuropsychologia. 2008 Jan 31;46(2):704-13
18023824
J Neurosci. 1999 Nov 1;19(21):9480-96
10531451
Nature. 2008 Dec 18;456(7224):952-6
18946471
Nat Neurosci. 2003 May;6(5):448-50
12704393
Neuropsychologia. 2000;38(7):985-94
10775709
Nat Rev Neurosci. 2007 Aug;8(8):636-48
17643089
Science. 1995 Jun 16;268(5217):1632-4
7777863
Brain Lang. 2008 Oct;107(1):16-43
17977592
J Cogn Neurosci. 2002 Jul 1;14(5):795-805
12167263
Neurology. 1998 Feb;50(2):351-5
9484352
Cognition. 2008 Jan;106(1):27-58
17239839
Neuropsychologia. 1995 May;33(5):643-8
7637858
Brain Lang. 1982 Mar;15(2):249-58
7074344
Brain Lang. 1995 May;49(2):125-39
7648248
Brain Lang. 2008 Dec;107(3):194-202
18692890
Brain. 1996 Feb;119 ( Pt 1):159-79
8624678
Neurology. 2008 Oct 28;71(18):1396-401
18784377
Brain Lang. 1998 Jun 15;63(2):159-83
9654430
Cognition. 1989 Nov;33(1-2):25-62
2691184
Science. 1995 Oct 6;270(5233):102-5
7569934
Acta Psychol (Amst). 2001 Apr;107(1-3):293-321
11388140
J Neurosci. 2008 Mar 19;28(12):3030-41
18354006
Curr Biol. 2008 Apr 8;18(7):R290-1
18397734
Cognition. 2009 Mar;110(3):412-31
19135654
Neuropsychologia. 2006;44(9):1607-21
16516934
Brain. 1965 Jun;88(2):237-94
5318481
Cortex. 2003 Jun;39(3):509-24
12870824
Brain. 1984 Sep;107 ( Pt 3):829-54
6206910
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1995 Aug 29;92(18):8135-9
7667258
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2008 Sep 2;105(35):13111-5
18725635
Cogn Neuropsychol. 2004 Oct;21(7):719-49
21038229
Psychon Bull Rev. 2002 Sep;9(3):558-65
12412897
Hum Brain Mapp. 1999;7(4):225-33
10408766
Neuroimage. 2005 May 15;26(1):221-33
15862222
Psychon Bull Rev. 2002 Dec;9(4):625-36
12613670
Arch Neurol. 2009 May;66(5):557-60
19433654
Cereb Cortex. 1996 Jan-Feb;6(1):1-10
8670633
Trends Cogn Sci. 2004 Feb;8(2):71-8
15588811
Cognition. 1996 Dec;61(3):309-19
8990976
Nature. 1998 Apr 9;392(6676):598-601
9560155
Brain Lang. 1980 Jul;10(2):249-62
7407546
J Cogn Neurosci. 2005 Dec;17(12):1855-70
16356324
J Cogn Neurosci. 2007 Sep;19(9):1542-55
17714015
Brain Lang. 1991 Oct;41(3):402-36
1933265
Brain Lang. 1995 Aug;50(2):151-200
7583186
Cognition. 1995 Apr;55(1):39-84
7758270
J Neurosci. 1997 Jun 1;17(11):4302-11
9151747
Cognition. 2005 Jan;94(3):B79-89
15617669
Exp Brain Res. 2004 Jan;154(1):103-8
14578997
J Cogn Neurosci. 2005 Feb;17(2):273-81
15811239
Brain Lang. 2010 Mar;112(3):214-22
19628276
J Cogn Neurosci. 1994 Spring;6(2):99-116
23962364
Psychol Sci. 2003 Jul;14(4):296-301
12807400
J Int Neuropsychol Soc. 2010 Jan;16(1):1-5
19765354
Curr Biol. 2008 Sep 9;18(17):R732-R733
18786369
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2008 Sep 9;105(36):13269-73
18765806
J Cogn Neurosci. 2004 Jan-Feb;16(1):114-26
15006041
Neuron. 2002 Sep 12;35(6):1167-75
12354405
Cognition. 2002 Feb;83(1):49-79
11814486
Acta Psychol (Amst). 2007 Feb;124(2):238-55
16780783
Annu Rev Neurosci. 2004;27:169-92
15217330
Neuropsychologia. 2003;41(1):53-70
12427565
Nature. 1996 Feb 22;379(6567):725-8
8602218
Brain Res Cogn Brain Res. 2005 Aug;24(3):355-63
16099349
J Cogn Neurosci. 2005 Jun;17(6):847-9
15969903
Brain Cogn. 2002 Mar-Apr;48(2-3):333-6
12030462
Cortex. 1984 Jun;20(2):207-20
6204813
Semin Speech Lang. 2008 Aug;29(3):226-38; quiz C6
18720319
Neuropsychologia. 1999 Apr;37(4):395-402
10215086
J Cogn Neurosci. 2010 Mar;22(3):413-26
19302003
J Neurosci. 2008 Oct 29;28(44):11347-53
18971476
Neuroimage. 2001 Jun;13(6 Pt 1):1053-64
11352611
Cogn Neuropsychol. 2003 May 1;20(3):451-86
20957580
J Cogn Neurosci. 2010 Aug;22(8):1739-53
19642889
Brain Lang. 1980 Jul;10(2):263-80
7407547
Psychol Sci. 2001 Mar;12(2):153-6
11340925
Psychol Sci. 2007 Nov;18(11):1007-13
17958716
Behav Brain Sci. 1999 Aug;22(4):577-609; discussion 610-60
11301525
Brain. 1998 Jun;121 ( Pt 6):1013-52
9648540
Lang Speech. 1988 Apr-Jun;31 ( Pt 2):115-34
3256769
Annu Rev Psychol. 2008;59:617-45
17705682
Neuroimage. 2003 Jul;19(3):613-26
12880792
Cognition. 2002 Jun;84(2):189-219
12175572
Mem Cognit. 2004 Sep;32(6):863-73
15673175
J Physiol Paris. 2008 Jan-May;102(1-3):59-70
18448316
Acta Psychol (Amst). 2004 Jun;116(2):185-203
15158182
Cogn Neuropsychol. 2007 Dec;24(8):795-816
18161497
J Cogn Neurosci. 2010 Nov;22(11):2480-90
19925197
Science. 2005 Apr 29;308(5722):662-7
15860620
Brain Res Cogn Brain Res. 2004 Aug;20(3):395-402
15268917
Brain Lang. 2010 Jan;112(1):54-76
18996582
Brain Lang. 1997 Jan;56(1):68-106
8994699
Neuroimage. 2001 May;13(5):775-85
11304074
Brain Lang. 2005 Mar;92(3):221-33
15721955
Brain. 1997 Oct;120 ( Pt 10):1763-77
9365369
Brain Cogn. 2002 Mar-Apr;48(2-3):597-602
12030514
Brain Lang. 1990 Jul;39(1):14-32
2207618
Mem Cognit. 2004 Dec;32(8):1389-400
15900932
Brain Cogn. 2002 Mar-Apr;48(2-3):484-90
12030493
Brain Lang. 1995 May;49(2):105-24
7648247