Hundreds of variants clustered in genomic loci and biological pathways affect human height.
Most common human traits and diseases have a polygenic pattern of inheritance: DNA sequence variants at many genetic loci influence the phenotype. Genome-wide association (GWA) studies have identified more than 600 variants associated with human traits, but these typically explain small fractions of phenotypic variation, raising questions about the use of further studies. Here, using 183,727 individuals, we show that hundreds of genetic variants, in at least 180 loci, influence adult height, a highly heritable and classic polygenic trait. The large number of loci reveals patterns with important implications for genetic studies of common human diseases and traits. First, the 180 loci are not random, but instead are enriched for genes that are connected in biological pathways (P = 0.016) and that underlie skeletal growth defects (P < 0.001). Second, the likely causal gene is often located near the most strongly associated variant: in 13 of 21 loci containing a known skeletal growth gene, that gene was closest to the associated variant. Third, at least 19 loci have multiple independently associated variants, suggesting that allelic heterogeneity is a frequent feature of polygenic traits, that comprehensive explorations of already-discovered loci should discover additional variants and that an appreciable fraction of associated loci may have been identified. Fourth, associated variants are enriched for likely functional effects on genes, being over-represented among variants that alter amino-acid structure of proteins and expression levels of nearby genes. Our data explain approximately 10% of the phenotypic variation in height, and we estimate that unidentified common variants of similar effect sizes would increase this figure to approximately 16% of phenotypic variation (approximately 20% of heritable variation). Although additional approaches are needed to dissect the genetic architecture of polygenic human traits fully, our findings indicate that GWA studies can identify large numbers of loci that implicate biologically relevant genes and pathways.
Lango Allen
Hana
H
Genetics of Complex Traits, Peninsula College of Medicine and Dentistry, University of Exeter, Exeter EX1 2LU, UK.
Estrada
Karol
K
Lettre
Guillaume
G
Berndt
Sonja I
SI
Weedon
Michael N
MN
Rivadeneira
Fernando
F
Willer
Cristen J
CJ
Jackson
Anne U
AU
Vedantam
Sailaja
S
Raychaudhuri
Soumya
S
Ferreira
Teresa
T
Wood
Andrew R
AR
Weyant
Robert J
RJ
Segrè
Ayellet V
AV
Speliotes
Elizabeth K
EK
Wheeler
Eleanor
E
Soranzo
Nicole
N
Park
Ju-Hyun
JH
Yang
Jian
J
Gudbjartsson
Daniel
D
Heard-Costa
Nancy L
NL
Randall
Joshua C
JC
Qi
Lu
L
Vernon Smith
Albert
A
Mägi
Reedik
R
Pastinen
Tomi
T
Liang
Liming
L
Heid
Iris M
IM
Luan
Jian'an
J
Thorleifsson
Gudmar
G
Winkler
Thomas W
TW
Goddard
Michael E
ME
Sin Lo
Ken
K
Palmer
Cameron
C
Workalemahu
Tsegaselassie
T
Aulchenko
Yurii S
YS
Johansson
Asa
A
Zillikens
M Carola
MC
Feitosa
Mary F
MF
Esko
Tõnu
T
Johnson
Toby
T
Ketkar
Shamika
S
Kraft
Peter
P
Mangino
Massimo
M
Prokopenko
Inga
I
Absher
Devin
D
Albrecht
Eva
E
Ernst
Florian
F
Glazer
Nicole L
NL
Hayward
Caroline
C
Hottenga
Jouke-Jan
JJ
Jacobs
Kevin B
KB
Knowles
Joshua W
JW
Kutalik
Zoltán
Z
Monda
Keri L
KL
Polasek
Ozren
O
Preuss
Michael
M
Rayner
Nigel W
NW
Robertson
Neil R
NR
Steinthorsdottir
Valgerdur
V
Tyrer
Jonathan P
JP
Voight
Benjamin F
BF
Wiklund
Fredrik
F
Xu
Jianfeng
J
Zhao
Jing Hua
JH
Nyholt
Dale R
DR
Pellikka
Niina
N
Perola
Markus
M
Perry
John R B
JR
Surakka
Ida
I
Tammesoo
Mari-Liis
ML
Altmaier
Elizabeth L
EL
Amin
Najaf
N
Aspelund
Thor
T
Bhangale
Tushar
T
Boucher
Gabrielle
G
Chasman
Daniel I
DI
Chen
Constance
C
Coin
Lachlan
L
Cooper
Matthew N
MN
Dixon
Anna L
AL
Gibson
Quince
Q
Grundberg
Elin
E
Hao
Ke
K
Juhani Junttila
M
M
Kaplan
Lee M
LM
Kettunen
Johannes
J
König
Inke R
IR
Kwan
Tony
T
Lawrence
Robert W
RW
Levinson
Douglas F
DF
Lorentzon
Mattias
M
McKnight
Barbara
B
Morris
Andrew P
AP
Müller
Martina
M
Suh Ngwa
Julius
J
Purcell
Shaun
S
Rafelt
Suzanne
S
Salem
Rany M
RM
Salvi
Erika
E
Sanna
Serena
S
Shi
Jianxin
J
Sovio
Ulla
U
Thompson
John R
JR
Turchin
Michael C
MC
Vandenput
Liesbeth
L
Verlaan
Dominique J
DJ
Vitart
Veronique
V
White
Charles C
CC
Ziegler
Andreas
A
Almgren
Peter
P
Balmforth
Anthony J
AJ
Campbell
Harry
H
Citterio
Lorena
L
De Grandi
Alessandro
A
Dominiczak
Anna
A
Duan
Jubao
J
Elliott
Paul
P
Elosua
Roberto
R
Eriksson
Johan G
JG
Freimer
Nelson B
NB
Geus
Eco J C
EJ
Glorioso
Nicola
N
Haiqing
Shen
S
Hartikainen
Anna-Liisa
AL
Havulinna
Aki S
AS
Hicks
Andrew A
AA
Hui
Jennie
J
Igl
Wilmar
W
Illig
Thomas
T
Jula
Antti
A
Kajantie
Eero
E
Kilpeläinen
Tuomas O
TO
Koiranen
Markku
M
Kolcic
Ivana
I
Koskinen
Seppo
S
Kovacs
Peter
P
Laitinen
Jaana
J
Liu
Jianjun
J
Lokki
Marja-Liisa
ML
Marusic
Ana
A
Maschio
Andrea
A
Meitinger
Thomas
T
Mulas
Antonella
A
Paré
Guillaume
G
Parker
Alex N
AN
Peden
John F
JF
Petersmann
Astrid
A
Pichler
Irene
I
Pietiläinen
Kirsi H
KH
Pouta
Anneli
A
Ridderstråle
Martin
M
Rotter
Jerome I
JI
Sambrook
Jennifer G
JG
Sanders
Alan R
AR
Schmidt
Carsten Oliver
CO
Sinisalo
Juha
J
Smit
Jan H
JH
Stringham
Heather M
HM
Bragi Walters
G
G
Widen
Elisabeth
E
Wild
Sarah H
SH
Willemsen
Gonneke
G
Zagato
Laura
L
Zgaga
Lina
L
Zitting
Paavo
P
Alavere
Helene
H
Farrall
Martin
M
McArdle
Wendy L
WL
Nelis
Mari
M
Peters
Marjolein J
MJ
Ripatti
Samuli
S
van Meurs
Joyce B J
JB
Aben
Katja K
KK
Ardlie
Kristin G
KG
Beckmann
Jacques S
JS
Beilby
John P
JP
Bergman
Richard N
RN
Bergmann
Sven
S
Collins
Francis S
FS
Cusi
Daniele
D
den Heijer
Martin
M
Eiriksdottir
Gudny
G
Gejman
Pablo V
PV
Hall
Alistair S
AS
Hamsten
Anders
A
Huikuri
Heikki V
HV
Iribarren
Carlos
C
Kähönen
Mika
M
Kaprio
Jaakko
J
Kathiresan
Sekar
S
Kiemeney
Lambertus
L
Kocher
Thomas
T
Launer
Lenore J
LJ
Lehtimäki
Terho
T
Melander
Olle
O
Mosley
Tom H
TH
Musk
Arthur W
AW
Nieminen
Markku S
MS
O'Donnell
Christopher J
CJ
Ohlsson
Claes
C
Oostra
Ben
B
Palmer
Lyle J
LJ
Raitakari
Olli
O
Ridker
Paul M
PM
Rioux
John D
JD
Rissanen
Aila
A
Rivolta
Carlo
C
Schunkert
Heribert
H
Shuldiner
Alan R
AR
Siscovick
David S
DS
Stumvoll
Michael
M
Tönjes
Anke
A
Tuomilehto
Jaakko
J
van Ommen
Gert-Jan
GJ
Viikari
Jorma
J
Heath
Andrew C
AC
Martin
Nicholas G
NG
Montgomery
Grant W
GW
Province
Michael A
MA
Kayser
Manfred
M
Arnold
Alice M
AM
Atwood
Larry D
LD
Boerwinkle
Eric
E
Chanock
Stephen J
SJ
Deloukas
Panos
P
Gieger
Christian
C
Grönberg
Henrik
H
Hall
Per
P
Hattersley
Andrew T
AT
Hengstenberg
Christian
C
Hoffman
Wolfgang
W
Lathrop
G Mark
GM
Salomaa
Veikko
V
Schreiber
Stefan
S
Uda
Manuela
M
Waterworth
Dawn
D
Wright
Alan F
AF
Assimes
Themistocles L
TL
Barroso
Inês
I
Hofman
Albert
A
Mohlke
Karen L
KL
Boomsma
Dorret I
DI
Caulfield
Mark J
MJ
Cupples
L Adrienne
LA
Erdmann
Jeanette
J
Fox
Caroline S
CS
Gudnason
Vilmundur
V
Gyllensten
Ulf
U
Harris
Tamara B
TB
Hayes
Richard B
RB
Jarvelin
Marjo-Riitta
MR
Mooser
Vincent
V
Munroe
Patricia B
PB
Ouwehand
Willem H
WH
Penninx
Brenda W
BW
Pramstaller
Peter P
PP
Quertermous
Thomas
T
Rudan
Igor
I
Samani
Nilesh J
NJ
Spector
Timothy D
TD
Völzke
Henry
H
Watkins
Hugh
H
Wilson
James F
JF
Groop
Leif C
LC
Haritunians
Talin
T
Hu
Frank B
FB
Kaplan
Robert C
RC
Metspalu
Andres
A
North
Kari E
KE
Schlessinger
David
D
Wareham
Nicholas J
NJ
Hunter
David J
DJ
O'Connell
Jeffrey R
JR
Strachan
David P
DP
Wichmann
H-Erich
HE
Borecki
Ingrid B
IB
van Duijn
Cornelia M
CM
Schadt
Eric E
EE
Thorsteinsdottir
Unnur
U
Peltonen
Leena
L
Uitterlinden
André G
AG
Visscher
Peter M
PM
Chatterjee
Nilanjan
N
Loos
Ruth J F
RJ
Boehnke
Michael
M
McCarthy
Mark I
MI
Ingelsson
Erik
E
Lindgren
Cecilia M
CM
Abecasis
Gonçalo R
GR
Stefansson
Kari
K
Frayling
Timothy M
TM
Hirschhorn
Joel N
JN
D001827:Body Height / Q000235:genetics*; D002893:Chromosomes, Human, Pair 3 / Q000235:genetics; D056426:Genetic Loci / Q000235:genetics*; D020022:Genetic Predisposition to Disease / Q000235:genetics; D015894:Genome, Human / Q000235:genetics*; D055106:Genome-Wide Association Study; D006801:Humans; D053858:Metabolic Networks and Pathways / Q000235:genetics*; D020412:Multifactorial Inheritance / Q000235:genetics; D010641:Phenotype; D020641:Polymorphism, Single Nucleotide / Q000235:genetics*