Quantitative assessment of evidential weight for a fingerprint comparison I. Generalisation to the comparison of a mark with set of ten prints from a suspect.
The authors have published elsewhere a quantitative method for assessing weight of evidence in the case where a finger mark from a crime scene is compared with a control print taken from a single finger of a suspect. The approach is based on the notion of calculating a likelihood ratio (LR) that addresses a pair of propositions relating to the single finger that was the origin of the crime mark. In practice, things are rather different because the crime mark will not just be compared with a single finger from a suspect but with a set of prints from all of his/her fingers; likewise, when the mark is compared with a database, this will consist of ten print records from random individuals. It is clear that "finger propositions" are not realistic in this situation and we show how our approach may be generalised to address a pair of propositions that relate to the person that made the crime mark. It often is the case that information is present at the crime scene that enables some inference to be drawn relating to which of the offender's ten fingers left a particular mark of interest. This kind of inference may profitably be drawn into the formal analysis. We illustrate our approach with an example.
Forensic Science Service, 2920 Solihull Parkway, Birmingham Business Park, Birmingham B37 7YN, United Kingdom. Cedric.Neumann@me.com
Cedric
C
Neumann
Ian W
IW
Evett
James E
JE
Skerrett
Ismael
I
Mateos-Garcia
D003878:Dermatoglyphics; D006801:Humans; D016013:Likelihood Functions; D015233:Models, Statistical; D011336:Probability