[Comparison of academic viewpoints between Yun Tie-qiao and Lu Yuan-lei].
Both Yun Tie-qiao and Lu Yuan-lei are medical professionals coming from the literary field with versatile and in-depth knowledge and extensive experience in medical education and clinical practice, all closely related to modern TCM development. Yun, the elder, insisted on reforming TCM and was early to advocate the academic idea of amalgamating western and traditional Chinese medicine; while Lu, the younger, insisted on the idea of "scientizing TCM" and was the representative of amalgamating western and traditional Chinese medicine in the later stage. They shared many common viewpoints, including venerating Zhang Zhongjing, stressing exogenous cold pathogens, advocating reformation and amalgamation of western medicine and TCM and objecting to the abolishment of TCM. However, there were discrepancies between them, including the relationship between the Inner Canon and the Essay on Exogenous Cold Diseases, warm disease theory, pulse theory, titles of TCM diseases and Japanese Kampo medicine. A comparison of them and noting their valuable contributions will be beneficial for the promotion of the development of TCM.
Shanghai Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicinal Literature, Shanghai, 200020, China.
Zhi-qing
ZQ
Yang
Li-juan
LJ
Bi
Xing-lin
XL
Yang
D002681:China; D049672:History, 19th Century; D049673:History, 20th Century; D008516:Medicine, Chinese Traditional