An auditory analog of the picture superiority effect.
Previous research has found that pictures (e.g., a picture of an elephant) are remembered better than words (e.g., the word "elephant"), an empirical finding called the picture superiority effect (Paivio & Csapo. Cognitive Psychology 5(2):176-206, 1973). However, very little research has investigated such memory differences for other types of sensory stimuli (e.g. sounds or odors) and their verbal labels. Four experiments compared recall of environmental sounds (e.g., ringing) and spoken verbal labels of those sounds (e.g., "ringing"). In contrast to earlier studies that have shown no difference in recall of sounds and spoken verbal labels (Philipchalk & Rowe. Journal of Experimental Psychology 91(2):341-343, 1971; Paivio, Philipchalk, & Rowe. Memory & Cognition 3(6):586-590, 1975), the experiments reported here yielded clear evidence for an auditory analog of the picture superiority effect. Experiments 1 and 2 showed that sounds were recalled better than the verbal labels of those sounds. Experiment 2 also showed that verbal labels are recalled as well as sounds when participants imagine the sound that the word labels. Experiments 3 and 4 extended these findings to incidental-processing task paradigms and showed that the advantage of sounds over words is enhanced when participants are induced to label the sounds.
Department of Psychology, University of Dayton, 300 College Park, Dayton, OH 45469-1430, USA. crutcher@udayton.edu
Robert J
RJ
Crutcher
Jenay M
JM
Beer
D001288:Attention; D001307:Auditory Perception; D006801:Humans; D007092:Imagination; D011939:Mental Recall; D010364:Pattern Recognition, Visual; D011571:Psychoacoustics; D012660:Semantics; D013067:Speech Perception; D014706:Verbal Learning
Psychol Bull. 1989 May;105(3):352-60
2660177
J Exp Psychol Hum Learn. 1977 Jan;3(1):52-9
845551
J Exp Psychol. 1973 Oct;100(2):221-7
4745452
J Exp Psychol. 1971 Dec;91(2):341-3
5134677
Mem Cognit. 1989 Jan;17(1):95-105
2913461
Mem Cognit. 1987 Jul;15(4):269-80
3670049
Mem Cognit. 1975 Nov;3(6):586-90
24203897
J Exp Psychol Hum Learn. 1976 Sep;2(5):523-8
1003125
J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn. 1984 Apr;10(2):316-25
6242742
J Gen Psychol. 1996 Oct;123(4):277-87
9042739
Conscious Cogn. 2002 Sep;11(3):423-60
12435377
Mem Cognit. 2007 Jan;35(1):113-23
17533886