title: Understanding the errors of SHAPE-directed RNA structure modeling.
abstract: Single-nucleotide-resolution chemical mapping for structured RNA is being rapidly advanced by new chemistries, faster readouts, and coupling to computational algorithms. Recent tests have shown that selective 2'-hydroxyl acylation by primer extension (SHAPE) can give near-zero error rates (0-2%) in modeling the helices of RNA secondary structure. Here, we benchmark the method using six molecules for which crystallographic data are available: tRNA(phe) and 5S rRNA from Escherichia coli, the P4-P6 domain of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme, and ligand-bound domains from riboswitches for adenine, cyclic di-GMP, and glycine. SHAPE-directed modeling of these highly structured RNAs gave an overall false negative rate (FNR) of 17% and a false discovery rate (FDR) of 21%, with at least one helix prediction error in five of the six cases. Extensive variations of data processing, normalization, and modeling parameters did not significantly mitigate modeling errors. Only one varation, filtering out data collected with deoxyinosine triphosphate during primer extension, gave a modest improvement (FNR = 12%, and FDR = 14%). The residual structure modeling errors are explained by the insufficient information content of these RNAs' SHAPE data, as evaluated by a nonparametric bootstrapping analysis. Beyond these benchmark cases, bootstrapping suggests a low level of confidence (<50%) in the majority of helices in a previously proposed SHAPE-directed model for the HIV-1 RNA genome. Thus, SHAPE-directed RNA modeling is not always unambiguous, and helix-by-helix confidence estimates, as described herein, may be critical for interpreting results from this powerful methodology.
authors.affiliation: Department of Biochemistry, Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305, USA.
authors.forename: Wipapat
authors.initials: W
authors.lastname: Kladwang
authors.forename: Christopher C
authors.initials: CC
authors.lastname: VanLang
authors.forename: Pablo
authors.initials: P
authors.lastname: Cordero
authors.forename: Rhiju
authors.initials: R
authors.lastname: Das
mesh_terms: D001483:Base Sequence; D002874:Chromosome Mapping / Q000379:methods; D018360:Crystallography, X-Ray / Q000379:methods; D008957:Models, Genetic; D008969:Molecular Sequence Data; D009690:Nucleic Acid Conformation; D012329:RNA, Bacterial / Q000737:chemistry / Q000235:genetics*; D012341:RNA, Ribosomal, 5S / Q000737:chemistry* / Q000235:genetics; D012343:RNA, Transfer / Q000737:chemistry* / Q000235:genetics
chemical_list: D012329:RNA, Bacterial; D012341:RNA, Ribosomal, 5S; D012343:RNA, Transfer