The certifying examination of the american board of surgery: the effect of improving communication and professional competency: twenty-year results.
OBJECTIVE
In 1985, a small research group identified variables affecting applicant success on the oral Certifying Examination (CE) of the American Board of Surgery (ABS). This led to the design of an oral examination course first taught in 1991. The success of and need for this program led to its continuation. The results from the first 10 years were presented at the 2001 Association of Program Directors in Surgery annual meeting.(1) We now report the outcomes for the course of the second 10 years as measured by success on the CE.


METHODS
Thirty-six courses were held over 20 years. There were 57 invited faculty from 27 general surgery programs throughout the United States and Canada. The participant-to-faculty ratio ranged from 16:7 to 5:1 in the newer 3-day format (2007). Courses were offered at sites that replicated the actual examination setting. Each course included (1) pretest and posttest examinations, (2) analysis of case presentation skills, (3) measurement of communication apprehension, (4) 1:1 faculty feedback, (5) small-group practice sessions, (6) individual videotaping, (7) didactic review of specific behaviors on examinations, (8) a debrief session with two faculty members, and (9) a written evaluative summary that included an improvement strategy.


RESULTS
There were 36 courses with 326 participants (30-54 years). Follow-up data are available for 225 participants. Trends were analyzed between 1991-2001 and 2002-2011. As resident performance on the CE increased in importance, applicant profiles changed from those who had previously failed (1991-2001) to residents identified by program directors as needing assistance (52%). Since 2002, most course participants (69%) who had failed the CE had completed at least 1 other review course. Participants reported more significant stressors (2002-2011) 9%, but communication apprehension remained the same. As a result, individual counseling for anger and family stressors was integrated into the course. The perception of knowledge deficits was associated with those who enrolled in fellowship training and delayed their examination. The recent groups exhibited more professionalism and articulation issues related to performance. Five surgeons (2002-2011) were asked not to return to the course because of severe knowledge deficiencies or ethical/behavioral issues based on faculty evaluations. Although complete follow-up of all participants was not possible (only 225/326), the success rate among those providing follow-up was 97% for those who followed their remediation plan, giving 218/326, a worse-case pass rate of 67%.


CONCLUSIONS
Communication and professionalism deficits are still common in those struggling with the CE, Early identification of those at risk of failing by program directors who are documenting the competencies may promote earlier interventions and thus lead to success. This program continues to be effective at identifying behaviors that interfere with success on the CE of the ABS.
Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, New Hampshire, USA. Pamela_rowland@med.unc.edu
Pamela A
PA
Rowland
Thadeus L
TL
Trus
Nicholas P
NP
Lang
Horace
H
Henriques
William P
WP
Reed
Parvis J
PJ
Sadighi
John E
JE
Sutton
Adnan A
AA
Alseidi
Michael J
MJ
Cahalane
Jeffrey M
JM
Gauvin
Walter E
WE
Pofahl
Kennith H
KH
Sartorelli
Steven B
SB
Goldin
A Gerson
AG
Greenburg
D000328:Adult; D002568:Certification; D002983:Clinical Competence; D003142:Communication; D005260:Female; D013502:General Surgery / Q000592:standards*; D006801:Humans; D008297:Male; D008875:Middle Aged; D013044:Specialty Boards; D011795:Surveys and Questionnaires; D013997:Time Factors; D014481:United States