Should anthropology be part of cognitive science?
Anthropology and the other cognitive science (CS) subdisciplines currently maintain a troubled relationship. With a debate in topiCS we aim at exploring the prospects for improving this relationship, and our introduction is intended as a catalyst for this debate. In order to encourage a frank sharing of perspectives, our comments will be deliberately provocative. Several challenges for a successful rapprochement are identified, encompassing the diverging paths that CS and anthropology have taken in the past, the degree of compatibility between (1) CS and (2) anthropology with regard to methodology and (3) research strategies, (4) the importance of anthropology for CS, and (5) the need for disciplinary diversity. Given this set of challenges, a reconciliation seems unlikely to follow on the heels of good intentions alone.
Department of Psychology, University of Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany.
Sieghard
S
Beller
Andrea
A
Bender
Douglas L
DL
Medin
D000883:Anthropology; D019336:Cognitive Science; D006801:Humans; D012107:Research Design