Elective non-therapeutic intensive care and the four principles of medical ethics.
The chronic worldwide lack of organs for transplantation and the continuing improvement of strategies for in situ organ preservation have led to renewed interest in elective non-therapeutic ventilation of potential organ donors. Two types of situation may be eligible for elective intensive care: patients definitely evolving towards brain death and patients suitable as controlled non-heart beating organ donors after life-supporting therapies have been assessed as futile and withdrawn. Assessment of the ethical acceptability and the risks of these strategies is essential. We here offer such an ethical assessment using the four principles of medical ethics of Beauchamp and Childress applying them in their broadest sense so as to include patients and their families, their caregivers, other potential recipients of intensive care, and indeed society as a whole. The main ethical problems emerging are the definition of beneficence for the potential organ donor, the dilemma between the duty to respect a dying patient's autonomy and the duty not to harm him/her, and the possible psychological and social harm for families, caregivers other potential recipients of therapeutic intensive care, and society more generally. Caution is expressed about the ethical acceptability of elective non-therapeutic ventilation, along with some proposals for precautionary measures to be taken if it is to be implemented.
Anesthésie Réanimation Chirurgicale, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Nancy, Nancy 54000, France. a.baumann@chu-nancy.fr
Antoine
A
Baumann
Gérard
G
Audibert
Caroline
C
Guibet Lafaye
Caroline Guibet
CG
Lafaye
Louis
L
Puybasset
Paul-Michel
PM
Mertes
Frédérique
F
Claudot
D026686:Beneficence; D001926:Brain Death; D003422:Critical Care / Q000941:ethics*; D028663:Ethical Theory; D004992:Ethics, Medical; D006323:Heart Arrest; D006801:Humans; D008020:Life Support Care / Q000941:ethics; D018447:Medical Futility; D026684:Personal Autonomy; D028662:Principle-Based Ethics; D012121:Respiration, Artificial / Q000941:ethics*; D012935:Social Justice; D014019:Tissue Donors / Q000600:supply & distribution*; D009927:Tissue and Organ Procurement / Q000941:ethics*; D028761:Withholding Treatment / Q000941:ethics