title: The Right and Wrong of Growing Old: Assessing the Argument from Evolution.
abstract: One argument which is frequently levelled against the enhancement of human biology is that we do not understand the evolved function of our bodies well enough to meddle in our biology without producing unintended and potentially catastrophic effects. In particular, this argument is levelled against attempts to slow or eliminate the processes of human ageing, or 'senescence', which cause us to grow decrepit before we die. In this article, I claim that even if this argument could usefully be applied against attempts to enhance other human traits, it cannot be valid in the case of attempts to enhance the various processes that constitute senescence. I begin by reviewing the biology of ageing to show how it consists of a number of unrelated traits. Then, following the arguments of a number of evolutionary biologists, I explain that every one of these traits is a product of evolutionary 'neglect' rather than 'intent'. Finally, I consider the strongest version of the argument against enhancing senescence, which acknowledges these facts about the evolution of ageing but insists that we have nevertheless have prudential reasons to avoid enhancement wherever there is some uncertainty about the genetics or evolutionary function of a trait. I provide two reasons for rejecting this version of the argument as well, even in the case of human senescence, where such uncertainty is currently significant.
authors: Institute for Science & Ethics, University of Oxford, Suite 8, Littlegate House, 16-17 St. Ebbes St, Oxford, OX1 1PT UK.
authors: Bennett
authors: B
authors: Foddy
keywords: Ageing; Ethics; Evolution; Genetics; Human enhancement; Senescence
references: J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2011 Jul;66(7):741-50
references: 21486920
references: Nat Immunol. 2001 Oct;2(10):907-16
references: 11577346
references: Bull N Y Acad Med. 1995 Summer;72(1):95-117
references: 7581318
references: Free Radic Res. 2008 May;42(5):474-80
references: 18484411
references: Biogerontology. 2010 Feb;11(1):17-30
references: 19350411
references: Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 2005 Apr;6(4):298-305
references: 15768047
references: J Law Med Ethics. 1995 Summer;23(2):173-6
references: 7647886
references: Mech Ageing Dev. 2002 Apr;123(7):737-45
references: 11869731
references: J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2004 Jun;59(6):B515-22
references: 15215256
references: Science. 1999 Aug 27;285(5432):1390-3
references: 10464095
references: Int J Cancer. 2007 Dec 1;121(11):2381-6
references: 17893868
references: Langenbecks Arch Surg. 2006 Sep;391(5):499-510
references: 16909291
references: Cell Mol Life Sci. 2010 Jan;67(1):1-8
references: 19730800
references: Nature. 2010 Mar 25;464(7288):536-42
references: 20336136
references: Sci Aging Knowledge Environ. 2006 Jun 28;2006(10):nf16
references: 16807477
references: Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 1997 Dec 29;352(1363):1793-7
references: 9460062
references: Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2006 May;1067:10-21
references: 16803965
references: Evolution. 2000 Jun;54(3):740-50
references: 10937249
references: J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2002 Aug;57(8):B292-7
references: 12145354
references: EMBO Rep. 2005 Jul;6 Spec No:S72-5
references: 15995668
references: Med Hypotheses. 1996 Aug;47(2):137-44
references: 8869930
references: Science. 1993 Aug 13;261(5123):921-3
references: 8346443
references: Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2004 Jun;1019:191-4
references: 15247012
references: EMBO Rep. 2005 Jul;6 Spec No:S67-71
references: 15995667
references: Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2006 May;1067:56-65
references: 16803971
references: Cell. 2008 Nov 14;135(4):609-22
references: 19013273
references: J Med Philos. 2011 Feb;36(1):6-27
references: 21228084
references: Mutat Res. 2009 Mar 31;674(1-2):45-54
references: 19013537
references: JAMA. 1998 Jun 3;279(21):1732-5
references: 9624027
references: Exp Gerontol. 2009 Aug;44(8):477-84
references: 19454313
references: Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2006 May;1067:252-63
references: 16803995
references: Curr Opin Neurobiol. 1996 Oct;6(5):661-6
references: 8937831
references: Exp Gerontol. 2007 Mar;42(3):160-5
references: 17084574
references: Aging Cell. 2004 Feb;3(1):41-4
references: 14965355