title: A systematic review of randomised control trials assessing mesh fixation in open inguinal hernia repair.
abstract: OBJECTIVE
  The technique for fixation of mesh has been attributed to adverse patient and surgical outcomes. Although this has been the subject of vigorous debate in laparoscopic hernia repair, the several methods of fixation in open, anterior inguinal hernia repair have seldom been reviewed. The aim of this systematic review was to determine whether there is any difference in patient-based (recurrence, post-operative pain, SSI, quality of life) or surgical outcomes (operative time, length of operative stay) with different fixation methods in open anterior inguinal hernioplasty.
  
  
  METHODS
  A literature search was performed in PubMed, EMBASE and the Cochrane Library databases. Randomised clinical trials assessing more than one method of mesh fixation (or fixation versus no fixation) of mesh in adults (>18 years) in open, anterior inguinal hernia repair, with a minimum of 6-month follow-up and including at least one of the primary outcome measures (recurrence, chronic pain, surgical site infection) were included in the review. Secondary outcomes analysed included post-operative pain (within the first week), quality of life, operative time and length of hospital stay.
  
  
  RESULTS
  Twelve randomised clinical trials, which included 1,992 primary inguinal hernia repairs, were eligible for inclusion. Four studies compared n-butyl-2 cyanoacrylate (NB2C) glues to sutures, two compared self-fixing meshes to sutures, four compared fibrin sealant to sutures, one compared tacks to sutures, and one compared absorbable sutures to non-absorbable sutures. The majority of the trials were rated as low or very low-quality studies. There was no significant difference in recurrence or surgical site infection rates between fixation methods. There was significant heterogeneity in the measurement of chronic pain. Three trials reported significantly lower rates of chronic pain with fibrin sealant or glue fixation compared to sutures. A further three studies reported lower pain rates within the first week with non-suture fixation techniques compared to suture fixation. A significant reduction in operative time, ranging form 6 to 17.9 min with non-suture fixation, was reported in five of the studies. Although infrequently measured, there were no significant differences in length of hospital stay or quality of life between fixation methods.
  
  
  CONCLUSIONS
  There is insufficient evidence to promote fibrin sealant, self-fixing meshes or NB2C glues ahead of suture fixation. However, these products have been shown to be at least substantially equivalent, and moderate-quality RCTs have suggested that both fibrin sealant and NB2C glues may have a beneficial effect on reducing immediate post-operative pain and chronic pain in at-risk populations, such as younger active patients. It will ultimately be up to surgeons and health-care policy makers to decide whether based on the limited evidence these products represent a worthwhile cost for their patients.
authors: Department of Upper GI Surgery, Royal Cornwall Hospital, Treliske, Truro, TR1 3LJ, UK, dsanders@doctors.org.uk.
authors: D L
authors: DL
authors: Sanders
authors: S
authors: S
authors: Waydia
mesh_terms: D000328:Adult; D006552:Hernia, Inguinal / Q000601:surgery*; D059685:Herniorrhaphy / Q000379:methods*; D006801:Humans; D007902:Length of Stay / Q000706:statistics & numerical data; D061646:Operative Time; D010149:Postoperative Pain / Q000517:prevention & control; D011788:Quality of Life; D016032:Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic; D012008:Recurrence; D013526:Surgical Mesh
references: Cir Esp. 2009 Oct;86(4):242-8
references: 19660740
references: BMJ. 2009 Jul 21;339:b2700
references: 19622552
references: Lancet. 2001 Oct 6;358(9288):1124-8
references: 11597665
references: Hernia. 2012 Feb;16(1):1-7
references: 21861164
references: Am J Surg. 2007 Sep;194(3):394-400
references: 17693290
references: Surg Clin North Am. 2003 Oct;83(5):1045-51, v-vi
references: 14533902
references: Arch Surg. 2004 Dec;139(12):1297-8
references: 15611452
references: Hernia. 2012 Jun;16(3):287-94
references: 22453675
references: Br J Surg. 2002 Nov;89(11):1476-9
references: 12390395
references: Br J Surg. 2006 Jan;93(1):33-9
references: 16329082
references: Am J Surg. 1984 Feb;147(2):197-204
references: 6364858
references: Hernia. 2009 Feb;13(1):49-52
references: 18726066
references: Clin J Pain. 2003 Jan-Feb;19(1):48-54
references: 12514456
references: Br J Surg. 2005 Feb;92(2):166-70
references: 15584057
references: Br J Surg. 2002 Aug;89(8):1043-8
references: 12153633
references: Surg Endosc. 2010 Jun;24(6):1318-24
references: 20033724
references: Ann Surg. 2012 Apr;255(4):650-7
references: 22395092
references: Br J Surg. 2003 Sep;90(9):1152-4
references: 12945086
references: Br J Surg. 2012 May;99(5):630-6
references: 22362035
references: Hernia. 2008 Dec;12(6):603-7
references: 18528744
references: JSLS. 2003 Oct-Dec;7(4):383-7
references: 14626408
references: Hernia. 2002 Mar;6(1):26-8
references: 12090577
references: J Surg Res. 2010 Oct;163(2):e53-8
references: 20691995
references: Hernia. 2011 Aug;15(4):361-9
references: 21452012
references: Hernia. 2005 Dec;9(4):322-9
references: 16075158
references: Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2005 Apr;49(4):1613-6
references: 15793153
references: Surg Endosc. 2008 Mar;22(3):731-8
references: 17623239
references: Am J Surg. 2011 Jul;202(1):34-8
references: 21601822
references: J Am Coll Surg. 2005 Mar;200(3):393-7; discussion 397-8
references: 15737849
references: World J Gastroenterol. 2011 Apr 14;17(14):1791-6
references: 21528050
references: Hernia. 2010 Dec;14(6):623-7
references: 20835908
references: Ann Surg. 2001 Jan;233(1):18-25
references: 11141220
references: J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A. 2000 Apr;10(2):71-3
references: 10794209
references: Hernia. 2002 Sep;6(3):99-101
references: 12209296
references: J Am Coll Surg. 2006 Oct;203(4):481-9
references: 17000391
references: Br J Surg. 2007 Jan;94(1):36-41
references: 17094166
references: Hernia. 2004 Feb;8(1):20-2
references: 14505238
references: World J Surg. 1989 Sep-Oct;13(5):545-54
references: 2683400
references: Surg Endosc. 2003 Nov;17(11):1778-80
references: 12958679
references: Langenbecks Arch Surg. 2010 Apr;395(4):317-22
references: 20174819
references: Hernia. 2008 Oct;12(5):483-91
references: 18483783
references: Acta Chir Scand. 1979;145(7):431-4
references: 539325
references: Surgery. 2012 Apr;151(4):550-5
references: 22088820
references: J Surg Educ. 2011 Mar-Apr;68(2):101-4
references: 21338964
references: Hernia. 2012 Feb;16(1):21-7
references: 21789654
references: Surg Endosc. 2005 Jun;19(6):780-5
references: 15776210
references: Surg Endosc. 2012 Jul;26(7):1803-12
references: 22278103
references: Surg Innov. 2005 Sep;12(3):203-13
references: 16224640
references: J Invest Surg. 2010 Oct;23(5):262-6
references: 20874481
references: Br J Surg. 1996 Aug;83(8):1100
references: 8869313
references: Hernia. 2007 Apr;11(2):139-45
references: 17252181
references: BMJ. 2004 Jun 19;328(7454):1490
references: 15205295
references: Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech. 2007 Dec;17(6):514-6
references: 18097312
references: Hernia. 2012 Apr;16(2):127-31
references: 21833849
references: Br J Surg. 2011 Sep;98(9):1245-51
references: 21710480
references: J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater. 2005 Jul;74(1):627-35
references: 15889436
references: Ann Surg. 2001 Jan;233(1):26-33
references: 11141221
references: Ann Surg. 2006 Aug;244(2):212-9
references: 16858183
references: Hernia. 2005 Oct;9(3):242-4
references: 15891811
references: Ann Surg. 1981 Jul;194(1):35-41
references: 7018429
references: Br J Surg. 2006 Jan;93(1):5-10
references: 16252314
references: Eur Surg Res. 2004 Nov-Dec;36(6):367-70
references: 15591746
references: Hernia. 2009 Aug;13(4):343-403
references: 19636493
references: FEMS Immunol Med Microbiol. 2010 Aug;59(3):405-9
references: 20528925
references: Hernia. 2004 Dec;8(4):323-31
references: 15235939
references: Surg Endosc. 1999 Sep;13(9):878-81
references: 10449843
references: Eur J Pain. 2008 Feb;12(2):214-25
references: 17606392
references: Surg Endosc. 2011 Mar;25(3):737-48
references: 20680350