title: The hourglass and the early conservation models--co-existing patterns of developmental constraints in vertebrates.
abstract: Developmental constraints have been postulated to limit the space of feasible phenotypes and thus shape animal evolution. These constraints have been suggested to be the strongest during either early or mid-embryogenesis, which corresponds to the early conservation model or the hourglass model, respectively. Conflicting results have been reported, but in recent studies of animal transcriptomes the hourglass model has been favored. Studies usually report descriptive statistics calculated for all genes over all developmental time points. This introduces dependencies between the sets of compared genes and may lead to biased results. Here we overcome this problem using an alternative modular analysis. We used the Iterative Signature Algorithm to identify distinct modules of genes co-expressed specifically in consecutive stages of zebrafish development. We then performed a detailed comparison of several gene properties between modules, allowing for a less biased and more powerful analysis. Notably, our analysis corroborated the hourglass pattern at the regulatory level, with sequences of regulatory regions being most conserved for genes expressed in mid-development but not at the level of gene sequence, age, or expression, in contrast to some previous studies. The early conservation model was supported with gene duplication and birth that were the most rare for genes expressed in early development. Finally, for all gene properties, we observed the least conservation for genes expressed in late development or adult, consistent with both models. Overall, with the modular approach, we showed that different levels of molecular evolution follow different patterns of developmental constraints. Thus both models are valid, but with respect to different genomic features.
authors: Department of Ecology and Evolution, University of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland.
authors: Barbara
authors: B
authors: Piasecka
authors: Paweł
authors: P
authors: Lichocki
authors: Sébastien
authors: S
authors: Moretti
authors: Sven
authors: S
authors: Bergmann
authors: Marc
authors: M
authors: Robinson-Rechavi
mesh_terms: D000818:Animals; D005075:Biological Evolution; D019143:Evolution, Molecular; D020440:Gene Duplication; D018507:Gene Expression Regulation, Developmental; D016678:Genome; D010802:Phylogeny; D015027:Zebrafish / Q000235:genetics
references: Nucleic Acids Res. 2002 Jan 1;30(1):207-10
references: 11752295
references: Nature. 2010 Dec 9;468(7325):768-9
references: 21150985
references: Mol Biol Evol. 2007 Aug;24(8):1586-91
references: 17483113
references: Evolution. 2000 Aug;54(4):1079-91
references: 11005278
references: BMC Genomics. 2009 Jan 14;10:22
references: 19144180
references: Trends Ecol Evol. 2012 Jul;27(7):385-93
references: 22520868
references: Nat Rev Genet. 2004 Nov;5(11):850-60
references: 15520794
references: J Exp Zool B Mol Dev Evol. 2005 Mar 15;304(2):150-8
references: 15779077
references: Nature. 2012 Oct 4;490(7418):98-101
references: 22951968
references: PLoS Biol. 2005 Jul;3(7):e245
references: 16000021
references: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2007 Jul 24;104(30):12235-42
references: 17640887
references: BMC Genomics. 2007 Dec 20;8:470
references: 18093339
references: Genome Biol. 2007;8(2):R15
references: 17274809
references: Nature. 2010 Dec 9;468(7325):815-8
references: 21150997
references: Dev Cell. 2004 Jan;6(1):133-44
references: 14723853
references: Evol Dev. 2010 Mar-Apr;12(2):144-56
references: 20433455
references: Nature. 2010 Dec 9;468(7325):811-4
references: 21150996
references: BMC Biol. 2007 Jan 12;5:1
references: 17222327
references: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009 May 5;106(18):7273-80
references: 19351897
references: Dev Suppl. 1994;:135-42
references: 7579514
references: Nat Rev Genet. 2007 Mar;8(3):206-16
references: 17304246
references: PLoS Biol. 2005 Jan;3(1):e7
references: 15630479
references: Science. 1975 Apr 11;188(4184):107-16
references: 1090005
references: PLoS Genet. 2008 Dec;4(12):e1000311
references: 19096706
references: Bioinformatics. 2006 Jul 1;22(13):1600-7
references: 16606683
references: Bioessays. 2009 Jan;31(1):29-39
references: 19153999
references: Bioinformatics. 2004 Sep 1;20(13):1993-2003
references: 15044247
references: Dev Biol. 1996 Feb 1;173(2):408-19
references: 8606001
references: Genome Res. 2009 Feb;19(2):327-35
references: 19029536
references: Genome Res. 2012 Dec;22(12):2356-67
references: 22722344
references: Dev Dyn. 1995 Jul;203(3):253-310
references: 8589427
references: Nucleic Acids Res. 2013 Jan;41(Database issue):D48-55
references: 23203987
references: Nat Commun. 2011;2:248
references: 21427719
references: Nucleic Acids Res. 2009 Jan;37(Database issue):D690-7
references: 19033362
references: Genome Res. 2011 Aug;21(8):1328-38
references: 21555364
references: Dev Dyn. 1996 May;206(1):1-11
references: 9019240
references: PLoS Biol. 2006 Mar;4(3):e52
references: 16464126
references: Cell. 1994 Jul 29;78(2):191-201
references: 7913880
references: Gene. 2005 Jan 17;345(1):119-26
references: 15716085
references: Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys. 2003 Mar;67(3 Pt 1):031902
references: 12689096
references: BMC Genomics. 2004 Dec 21;5(1):99
references: 15613238
references: Genome Biol. 2008;9(2):R34
references: 18279518
references: Am Nat. 2004 Sep;164(3):415-22
references: 15478094
references: BMC Bioinformatics. 2007 Aug 28;8:312
references: 17725821
references: OMICS. 2004 Spring;8(1):15-24
references: 15107234
references: Cell. 2008 Jul 11;134(1):25-36
references: 18614008
references: Mol Biol Evol. 2004 Nov;21(11):2058-70
references: 15282333