title: Life cycle evolution: was the eumetazoan ancestor a holopelagic, planktotrophic gastraea?
abstract: BACKGROUND
  Two theories for the origin of animal life cycles with planktotrophic larvae are now discussed seriously: The terminal addition theory proposes a holopelagic, planktotrophic gastraea as the ancestor of the eumetazoans with addition of benthic adult stages and retention of the planktotrophic stages as larvae, i.e. the ancestral life cycles were indirect. The intercalation theory now proposes a benthic, deposit-feeding gastraea as the bilaterian ancestor with a direct development, and with planktotrophic larvae evolving independently in numerous lineages through specializations of juveniles.
  
  
  RESULTS
  Information from the fossil record, from mapping of developmental types onto known phylogenies, from occurrence of apical organs, and from genetics gives no direct information about the ancestral eumetazoan life cycle; however, there are plenty of examples of evolution from an indirect development to direct development, and no unequivocal example of evolution in the opposite direction. Analyses of scenarios for the two types of evolution are highly informative. The evolution of the indirect spiralian life cycle with a trochophora larva from a planktotrophic gastraea is explained by the trochophora theory as a continuous series of ancestors, where each evolutionary step had an adaptational advantage. The loss of ciliated larvae in the ecdysozoans is associated with the loss of outer ciliated epithelia. A scenario for the intercalation theory shows the origin of the planktotrophic larvae of the spiralians through a series of specializations of the general ciliation of the juvenile. The early steps associated with the enhancement of swimming seem probable, but the following steps which should lead to the complicated downstream-collecting ciliary system are without any advantage, or even seem disadvantageous, until the whole structure is functional. None of the theories account for the origin of the ancestral deuterostome (ambulacrarian) life cycle.
  
  
  CONCLUSIONS
  All the available information is strongly in favor of multiple evolution of non-planktotrophic development, and only the terminal addition theory is in accordance with the Darwinian theory by explaining the evolution through continuous series of adaptational changes. This implies that the ancestor of the eumetazoans was a holopelagic, planktotrophic gastraea, and that the adult stages of cnidarians (sessile) and bilaterians (creeping) were later additions to the life cycle. It further implies that the various larval types are of considerable phylogenetic value.
authors: Zoological Museum, The Natural History Museum of Denmark, University of Copenhagen, Universitetsparken 15, DK-2100, Copenhagen, Denmark. cnielsen@snm.ku.dk
authors: Claus
authors: C
authors: Nielsen
mesh_terms: D000818:Animals; D005075:Biological Evolution; D056890:Eukaryota / Q000145:classification / Q000235:genetics / Q000254:growth & development*; D005580:Fossils; D000069497:Origin of Life; D010802:Phylogeny; D010933:Plankton / Q000145:classification / Q000235:genetics / Q000254:growth & development*
references: Science. 1983 Apr 29;220(4596):501-2
references: 17816221
references: Evol Dev. 2007 Jul-Aug;9(4):313-8
references: 17651353
references: Biol Bull. 2003 Dec;205(3):295-307
references: 14672984
references: Evolution. 2004 Jul;58(7):1488-502
references: 15341151
references: Evol Dev. 2000 May-Jun;2(3):152-6
references: 11252571
references: Science. 2003 Jun 13;300(5626):1703-6
references: 12805537
references: Mol Phylogenet Evol. 2012 Oct;65(1):64-74
references: 22659514
references: Evol Dev. 2003 Sep-Oct;5(5):478-93
references: 12950627
references: Evol Dev. 2007 Jul-Aug;9(4):311-2
references: 17651352
references: Mol Phylogenet Evol. 2012 Jan;62(1):27-34
references: 21945533
references: Nature. 2012 Oct 4;490(7418):94-7
references: 23038472
references: J Morphol. 1993 Dec;218(3):301-321
references: 29865486
references: Proc Biol Sci. 2012 Apr 7;279(1732):1259-68
references: 21976685
references: Evol Dev. 2007 Jul-Aug;9(4):307-10
references: 17651351
references: Dev Genes Evol. 2003 Apr;213(3):149-54
references: 12690454
references: Science. 1996 Nov 15;274(5290):1205-8
references: 8895472
references: Dev Biol. 2007 May 1;305(1):63-76
references: 17346693
references: J Mol Evol. 1995 Apr;40(4):413-27
references: 7646666
references: Biol Bull. 2007 Apr;212(2):93-103
references: 17438202
references: Biol Bull. 2007 Apr;212(2):83-92
references: 17438201
references: Development. 1999 May;126(9):1937-45
references: 10101127
references: Evol Dev. 2008 Jul-Aug;10(4):493-503
references: 18638326
references: Biol Bull. 2009 Dec;217(3):253-68
references: 20040750
references: Dev Genes Evol. 2013 Jul;223(4):225-35
references: 23592252
references: Science. 2006 Oct 13;314(5797):291-4
references: 17038620
references: Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2008 Apr 27;363(1496):1473-9
references: 18192188
references: Biol Bull. 1999 Feb;196(1):70-9
references: 25575388
references: Evol Dev. 2000 Jul-Aug;2(4):222-33
references: 11252565
references: Izv Akad Nauk Ser Biol. 2012 Sep-Oct;(5):469-77
references: 23136734
references: Geobiology. 2009 Jan;7(1):8-20
references: 19200142
references: Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2008 Apr 27;363(1496):1425-34
references: 18192192
references: Heredity (Edinb). 2006 Sep;97(3):244-52
references: 16850040
references: Front Zool. 2010 Nov 09;7:29
references: 21062451
references: Biol Bull. 1999 Aug;197(1):14-25
references: 28296496
references: J Exp Zool B Mol Dev Evol. 2004 Jan 15;302(1):35-68
references: 14760653
references: Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2010 Feb 27;365(1540):653-69
references: 20083640
references: Int J Dev Biol. 2003;47(7-8):623-32
references: 14756338
references: Mol Phylogenet Evol. 2012 Feb;62(2):718-35
references: 22126903
references: Front Zool. 2006 Oct 10;3:16
references: 17032451
references: Evol Dev. 2002 Nov-Dec;4(6):459-99
references: 12492146
references: J Morphol. 2010 Sep;271(9):1094-109
references: 20730922
references: J Morphol. 2000 Jan;243(1):35-74
references: 10629096
references: Nature. 2011 Mar 3;471(7336):95-8
references: 21368831
references: Biol Bull. 1993 Jun;184(3):255-268
references: 29300539
references: Dev Biol. 2000 Mar 1;219(1):1-17
references: 10677251
references: Evol Dev. 2012 Sep-Oct;14(5):421-7
references: 22947315
references: Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2008 Apr 27;363(1496):1493-501
references: 18192185
references: Dev Genes Evol. 2009 Dec;219(11-12):565-76
references: 20099068
references: Integr Comp Biol. 2006 Dec;46(6):683-90
references: 21672778
references: Nature. 2007 Jan 11;445(7124):198-201
references: 17183268
references: Science. 2011 Dec 23;334(6063):1696-9
references: 22194575
references: Biol Lett. 2009 Oct 23;5(5):647-50
references: 19515650
references: Rev Suisse Zool. 1966 Dec;73(4):621-876
references: 5974455
references: Biol Bull. 2006 Apr;210(2):109-20
references: 16641516
references: BMC Evol Biol. 2013 Jan 09;13:5
references: 23302374
references: J Parasitol. 1994 Feb;80(1):1-22
references: 7905920
references: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2000 Apr 25;97(9):4457-62
references: 10781044
references: Evol Dev. 2008 Jan-Feb;10(1):74-88
references: 18184359
references: Nature. 2003 Jan 9;421(6919):158-60
references: 12520300
references: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1999 Aug 31;96(18):10272-7
references: 10468598
references: Evol Dev. 2003 Sep-Oct;5(5):508-21
references: 12950629
references: Bioessays. 2009 Jul;31(7):758-68
references: 19472368
references: J Morphol. 2013 Apr;274(4):412-28
references: 23192866
references: J Exp Zool B Mol Dev Evol. 2005 Sep 15;304(5):401-47
references: 15915468
references: Biol Bull. 2011 Jun;220(3):186-98
references: 21712227
references: Evol Dev. 2007 Sep-Oct;9(5):432-45
references: 17845515
references: Science. 2004 Jul 9;305(5681):218-22
references: 15178752
references: Evol Dev. 2010 Mar-Apr;12(2):201-9
references: 20433459
references: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009 Nov 10;106(45):19056-60
references: 19858483
references: Integr Comp Biol. 2007 Dec;47(6):865-71
references: 21669765
references: Proc Biol Sci. 2013 Feb 27;280(1757):20130071
references: 23446532
references: J Morphol. 2013 Jan;274(1):11-23
references: 22965540
references: Dev Genes Evol. 2007 Jan;217(1):39-54
references: 17180685
references: J Morphol. 2007 Jul;268(7):551-70
references: 17469131
references: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2000 Apr 25;97(9):4430-3
references: 10781037
references: Evol Dev. 2008 Mar-Apr;10(2):241-57
references: 18315817