title: Scientific knowledge is possible with small-sample classification.
abstract: : A typical small-sample biomarker classification paper discriminates between types of pathology based on, say, 30,000 genes and a small labeled sample of less than 100 points. Some classification rule is used to design the classifier from this data, but we are given no good reason or conditions under which this algorithm should perform well. An error estimation rule is used to estimate the classification error on the population using the same data, but once again we are given no good reason or conditions under which this error estimator should produce a good estimate, and thus we do not know how well the classifier should be expected to perform. In fact, virtually, in all such papers the error estimate is expected to be highly inaccurate. In short, we are given no justification for any claims.Given the ubiquity of vacuous small-sample classification papers in the literature, one could easily conclude that scientific knowledge is impossible in small-sample settings. It is not that thousands of papers overtly claim that scientific knowledge is impossible in regard to their content; rather, it is that they utilize methods that preclude scientific knowledge. In this paper, we argue to the contrary that scientific knowledge in small-sample classification is possible provided there is sufficient prior knowledge. A natural way to proceed, discussed herein, is via a paradigm for pattern recognition in which we incorporate prior knowledge in the whole classification procedure (classifier design and error estimation), optimize each step of the procedure given available information, and obtain theoretical measures of performance for both classifiers and error estimators, the latter being the critical epistemological issue. In sum, we can achieve scientific validation for a proposed small-sample classifier and its error estimate.
authors: Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA. edward@ece.tamu.edu.
authors: Edward R
authors: ER
authors: Dougherty
authors: Lori A
authors: LA
authors: Dalton
references: Curr Genomics. 2011 Aug;12(5):333-41
references: 22294876
references: Bioinformatics. 2011 Jul 1;27(13):1822-31
references: 21551140
references: Curr Genomics. 2008 Apr;9(2):69-79
references: 19440447
references: EURASIP J Bioinform Syst Biol. 2007;:38473
references: 18288255
references: Technol Cancer Res Treat. 2006 Dec;5(6):579-89
references: 17121434
references: Bioessays. 2012 Apr;34(4):277-9
references: 22337590