title: What I make up when I wake up: anti-experience views and narrative fabrication of dreams.
abstract: I propose a narrative fabrication thesis of dream reports, according to which dream reports are often not accurate representations of experiences that occur during sleep. I begin with an overview of anti-experience theses of Norman Malcolm and Daniel Dennett who reject the received view of dreams, that dreams are experiences we have during sleep which are reported upon waking. Although rejection of the first claim of the received view, that dreams are experiences that occur during sleep, is implausible, I evaluate in more detail the second assumption of the received view, that dream reports are generally accurate. I then propose a "narrative fabrication" view of dreams as an alternative to the received view. Dream reports are often confabulated or fabricated because of poor memory, bizarre dream content, and cognitive deficits. It is well documented that narratives can be altered between initial rapid eye movement sleep awakenings and subsequent reports. I argue that we have reason to suspect that initial reports are prone to inaccuracy. Experiments demonstrate that subjects rationalize strange elements in narratives, leaving out supernatural or bizarre components when reporting waking memories of stories. Inaccuracies in dream reports are exacerbated by rapid memory loss and bizarre dream content. Waking memory is a process of reconstruction and blending of elements, but unlike waking memory, we cannot reality-test for dream memories. Dream experiences involve imaginative elements, and dream content cannot be verified with external evidence. Some dreams may involve wake-like higher cognitive functions, such as lucid dreams. Such dreams are more likely to elicit accurate reports than cognitively deficient dreams. However, dream reports are generally less accurate than waking reports. I then propose methods which could verify the narrative fabrication view, and argue that although the theory cannot be tested with current methods, new techniques and technologies may be able to do so in the future.
authors: Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence in Cognition and its Disorders, Macquarie University Sydney, NSW, Australia.
authors: Melanie G
authors: MG
authors: Rosen
keywords: dreaming; epistemology; fabrication; memory; philosophy; skepticism
references: J Nerv Ment Dis. 1966 Apr;142(4):293-309
references: 5946044
references: Psychon Bull Rev. 1996 Jun;3(2):208-14
references: 24213869
references: J Consult Psychol. 1965 Oct;29(5):468-74
references: 5318262
references: J Exp Psychol. 1957 May;53(5):339-46
references: 13428941
references: J Nerv Ment Dis. 1970 Dec;151(6):369-74
references: 4320643
references: Behav Brain Sci. 2000 Dec;23(6):793-842; discussion 904-1121
references: 11515143
references: Neurology. 1981 Sep;31(9):1070-6
references: 7196527
references: N Engl J Med. 2010 Feb 18;362(7):579-89
references: 20130250
references: Cogn Neuropsychiatry. 2010 Jan;15(1):64-94
references: 19736594
references: Percept Mot Skills. 1983 Jun;56(3):875-8
references: 6877973
references: Exp Brain Res. 2007 Apr;178(4):450-61
references: 17091297
references: J Nerv Ment Dis. 1970 Dec;151(6):375-93
references: 4320644
references: Conscious Cogn. 2009 Dec;18(4):877-90
references: 19692271
references: Cortex. 2006 Apr;42(3):323-31
references: 16771037
references: JAMA. 1987 Apr 3;257(13):1786-9
references: 3820495
references: Curr Neurol Neurosci Rep. 2005 Mar;5(2):153-8
references: 15743554
references: Int J Clin Exp Hypn. 1992 Jul;40(3):125-56
references: 1399152
references: Br J Psychiatry. 1972 Jan;120(554):31-9
references: 5041518
references: Conscious Cogn. 2011 Sep;20(3):494-514
references: 20933437
references: J Exp Psychol Gen. 1984 Sep;113(3):329-44
references: 6237167
references: Sleep. 1996 Oct;19(8):609-24
references: 8958631
references: Psychiatr Prax. 1998 Mar;25(2):87-8
references: 9577853
references: Brain. 1960 Dec;83:648-53
references: 13784970
references: Percept Mot Skills. 1990 Oct;71(2):627-44
references: 2251094
references: Trends Cogn Sci. 2002 Jan 1;6(1):23-30
references: 11849612
references: Cogn Neuropsychol. 2004 Feb 1;21(1):3-16
references: 21038182
references: Psychon Bull Rev. 1999 Jun;6(2):313-8
references: 12199217
references: Sleep. 2012 Jul 01;35(7):1017-20
references: 22754049
references: Sleep. 1982;5(2):169-87
references: 6179144
references: Sleep. 1979;2(2):233-51
references: 232567
references: Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol. 1957 Nov;9(4):673-90
references: 13480240