title: Do spatially-implicit estimates of neutral migration comply with seed dispersal data in tropical forests?
abstract: Neutral community models have shown that limited migration can have a pervasive influence on the taxonomic composition of local communities even when all individuals are assumed of equivalent ecological fitness. Notably, the spatially implicit neutral theory yields a single parameter I for the immigration-drift equilibrium in a local community. In the case of plants, seed dispersal is considered as a defining moment of the immigration process and has attracted empirical and theoretical work. In this paper, we consider a version of the immigration parameter I depending on dispersal limitation from the neighbourhood of a community. Seed dispersal distance is alternatively modelled using a distribution that decreases quickly in the tails (thin-tailed Gaussian kernel) and another that enhances the chance of dispersal events over very long distances (heavily fat-tailed Cauchy kernel). Our analysis highlights two contrasting situations, where I is either mainly sensitive to community size (related to ecological drift) under the heavily fat-tailed kernel or mainly sensitive to dispersal distance under the thin-tailed kernel. We review dispersal distances of rainforest trees from field studies and assess the consistency between published estimates of I based on spatially-implicit models and the predictions of the kernel-based model in tropical forest plots. Most estimates of I were derived from large plots (10-50 ha) and were too large to be accounted for by a Cauchy kernel. Conversely, a fraction of the estimates based on multiple smaller plots (1 ha) appeared too small to be consistent with reported ranges of dispersal distances in tropical forests. Very large estimates may reflect within-plot habitat heterogeneity or estimation problems, while the smallest estimates likely imply other factors inhibiting migration beyond dispersal limitation. Our study underscores the need for interpreting I as an integrative index of migration limitation which, besides the limited seed dispersal, possibly includes habitat filtering or fragmentation.
authors: Université Montpellier 2, UMR AMAP, Montpellier, France. francois.munoz@univ-montp2.fr
authors: François
authors: F
authors: Munoz
authors: Champak R
authors: CR
authors: Beeravolu
authors: Raphaël
authors: R
authors: Pélissier
authors: Pierre
authors: P
authors: Couteron
mesh_terms: D000465:Algorithms; D008962:Models, Theoretical; D065947:Rainforest; D058614:Seed Dispersal / Q000502:physiology*; D014197:Trees / Q000502:physiology*
references: Trends Ecol Evol. 2011 Jul;26(7):340-8
references: 21561679
references: Science. 2006 Feb 3;311(5761):610
references: 16456064
references: Am J Bot. 2000 Sep;87(9):1217-27
references: 10991892
references: Ecol Lett. 2007 Jul;10(7):608-18
references: 17542939
references: Ecology. 2006 Jun;87(6):1411-23
references: 16869415
references: J Evol Biol. 2007 Nov;20(6):2075-91
references: 17956380
references: Nature. 2003 Aug 28;424(6952):1035-7
references: 12944964
references: Science. 2005 Sep 9;309(5741):1722-5
references: 16151011
references: Nature. 2006 May 4;441(7089):E1; discussion E1-2
references: 16672928
references: Ecol Lett. 2009 Dec;12(12):1385-93
references: 19807774
references: Trends Ecol Evol. 2012 Nov;27(11):600-7
references: 22877982
references: PLoS Biol. 2006 Oct;4(11):e344
references: 17048988
references: Am Nat. 2002 Jan;159(1):1-23
references: 18707398
references: Trends Ecol Evol. 2000 Jul;15(7):278-285
references: 10856948
references: Trends Ecol Evol. 2011 Mar;26(3):124-8
references: 21195505
references: Ecol Lett. 2009 Mar;12(3):239-48
references: 19170729
references: Am Nat. 2008 Dec;172(6):741-50
references: 18954264
references: Science. 2012 Jun 29;336(6089):1639; author reply 1639
references: 22745404
references: Ecology. 2007 Oct;88(10):2482-8
references: 18027751
references: Am Nat. 1998 Aug;152(2):204-24
references: 18811386
references: Theor Popul Biol. 2002 Sep;62(2):153-68
references: 12167354
references: Am Nat. 2004 Jan;163(1):69-83
references: 14767837
references: PLoS One. 2011 Mar 14;6(3):e14717
references: 21423724
references: Bull Math Biol. 2012 Aug;74(8):1754-63
references: 22576454
references: Science. 2008 Oct 24;322(5901):580-2
references: 18948539
references: Am Nat. 2005 Nov;166(5):543-55
references: 16224720
references: J Theor Biol. 2009 Apr 7;257(3):510-4
references: 19168078
references: Am Nat. 2008 Jul;172(1):116-27
references: 18533823