[The role of bioethics committees in the systems protecting scientific biomedical research participants in France and in Poland].
Bioethics committees are along with ethic regulations and rules of law one of three main pillars in the system of protection of scientific biomedical research participants. Although principal directives for bioethics committees are established by international guidelines, detailed regulations may differ in particular states. The aim of this article was to compare two bioethic committees systems: French and Polish one. Historical beginnings of the bioethics committees system in France and in Poland are briefly mentioned, Subsequently, the networks of bioethics committees in both countries are compared. Although the number of bioethics committees (Research Ethic Committees) in both countries is comparable, the procedure of their establishment varies. French committees are based on administrative division of the country and divide on regional and interregional committees. In Poland, bioethics committees are established by medical universities, medical research and development units or regional chambers of physicians and dentists. In France there is no equivalent of Appeal Bioethics Committee, however one could appeal from the negative bioethics committee's opinion. The composition of French bioethics committees is more diverse and half of the members are not related to medical professions. Members of French committees are named on indefinite term by headmaster of Regional Health Agency after having been chosen in competition for the post. In Poland members are called on three-year-term but the rotation of members is not overwhelming since there is no limit of terms for one member. French legal solutions seems more secure for scientific bioethics research participants. For this reason, a detailed research on legislation in other countries is necessary before introducing any new regulations in Polish law.
Warszawski Uniwersytet Medyczny, w Warszawie, Klinika Chorób Wewnetrznych i Endokrynologii. mczark@gmail.com
Marek
M
Czarkowski
Alicja
A
Sieczych
D001675:Bioethics; D035843:Biomedical Research / Q000941:ethics*; D028744:Ethics Committees, Research / Q000458:organization & administration*; D032984:Ethics, Research; D005602:France; D006805:Human Experimentation / Q000941:ethics*; D006801:Humans; D011044:Poland