A retrospective comparison of proton therapy and carbon ion therapy for stage I non-small cell lung cancer.
OBJECTIVE
This retrospective study aimed to compare the clinical outcomes and late toxicities of proton therapy (PT) with those of carbon ion therapy (CIT) for stage I non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC).


METHODS
A total of 111 patients who underwent particle therapy for stage I NSCLC between April 2003 and December 2009 were enrolled in this study. PT (n=70) and CIT (n=41) were delivered to total doses of 52.8-80 GyE in 4-26 fractions and 52.8-70.2 GyE in 4-26 fractions, respectively. The median follow-up time was 41 months.


RESULTS
Differences in outcome between the PT and CIT groups regarding 3-year overall survival (72% and 76%, respectively), progression-free survival (44% and 53%, respectively), and local control (81% and 78%, respectively) were not statistically significant. In multivariate analysis, the type of treatment beam did not correlate with overall survival. The severity of late toxicities was comparable between the two groups.


CONCLUSIONS
Clinical results in the PT group were comparable to those in the CIT group. However, this study was a retrospective analysis of a highly heterogeneous population. Consequently, more homogeneous prospective data, large multicentric databases and, ideally, randomized trials are warranted.
Department of Radiology, Hyogo Ion Beam Medical Center, Tatsuno, Japan. Electronic address: osfujii@aa.cyberhome.ne.jp.
Osamu
O
Fujii
Yusuke
Y
Demizu
Naoki
N
Hashimoto
Masayuki
M
Araya
Masaru
M
Takagi
Kazuki
K
Terashima
Masayuki
M
Mima
Hiromitsu
H
Iwata
Yasue
Y
Niwa
Dongcun
D
Jin
Takashi
T
Daimon
Ryohei
R
Sasaki
Yoshio
Y
Hishikawa
Mitsuyuki
M
Abe
Masao
M
Murakami
Nobukazu
N
Fuwa
D000328:Adult; D000368:Aged; D000369:Aged, 80 and over; D002289:Carcinoma, Non-Small-Cell Lung / Q000401:mortality / Q000473:pathology / Q000532:radiotherapy*; D005260:Female; D063193:Heavy Ion Radiotherapy; D006801:Humans; D008175:Lung Neoplasms / Q000401:mortality / Q000473:pathology / Q000532:radiotherapy*; D008297:Male; D008875:Middle Aged; D009367:Neoplasm Staging; D061766:Proton Therapy; D012189:Retrospective Studies
Carbon-ion therapy; Non-small cell lung cancer; Particle therapy; Proton therapy