title: Comparing the ecological impacts of wind and oil & gas development: a landscape scale assessment.
abstract: Energy production in the United States is in transition as the demand for clean and domestic power increases. Wind energy offers the benefit of reduced emissions, yet, like oil and natural gas, it also contributes to energy sprawl. We used a diverse set of indicators to quantify the ecological impacts of oil, natural gas, and wind energy development in Colorado and Wyoming. Aerial imagery was supplemented with empirical data to estimate habitat loss, fragmentation, potential for wildlife mortality, susceptibility to invasion, biomass carbon lost, and water resources. To quantify these impacts we digitized the land-use footprint within 375 plots, stratified by energy type. We quantified the change in impacts per unit area and per unit energy produced, compared wind energy to oil and gas, and compared landscapes with and without energy development. We found substantial differences in impacts between energy types for most indicators, although the magnitude and direction of the differences varied. Oil and gas generally resulted in greater impacts per unit area but fewer impacts per unit energy compared with wind. Biologically important and policy-relevant outcomes of this study include: 1) regardless of energy type, underlying land-use matters and development in already disturbed areas resulted in fewer total impacts; 2) the number and source of potential mortality varied between energy types, however, the lack of robust mortality data limits our ability to use this information to estimate and mitigate impacts; and 3) per unit energy produced, oil and gas extraction was less impactful on an annual basis but is likely to have a much larger cumulative footprint than wind energy over time. This rapid evaluation of landscape-scale energy development impacts could be replicated in other regions, and our specific findings can help meet the challenge of balancing land conservation with society's demand for energy.
authors: Department of Fish, Wildlife and Conservation Biology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado, United States of America.
authors: Nathan F
authors: NF
authors: Jones
authors: Liba
authors: L
authors: Pejchar
mesh_terms: D044822:Biodiversity; D002244:Carbon / Q000737:chemistry; D003247:Conservation of Natural Resources; D055669:Ecological and Environmental Phenomena; D059206:Natural Gas; D010578:Petroleum; D014881:Water Supply; D014919:Wind
chemical_list: D059206:Natural Gas; D010578:Petroleum; D002244:Carbon