Effect of clinically discriminating, evidence-based checklist items on the reliability of scores from an Internal Medicine residency OSCE.
Objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs) are used worldwide for summative examinations but often lack acceptable reliability. Research has shown that reliability of scores increases if OSCE checklists for medical students include only clinically relevant items. Also, checklists are often missing evidence-based items that high-achieving learners are more likely to use. The purpose of this study was to determine if limiting checklist items to clinically discriminating items and/or adding missing evidence-based items improved score reliability in an Internal Medicine residency OSCE. Six internists reviewed the traditional checklists of four OSCE stations classifying items as clinically discriminating or non-discriminating. Two independent reviewers augmented checklists with missing evidence-based items. We used generalizability theory to calculate overall reliability of faculty observer checklist scores from 45 first and second-year residents and predict how many 10-item stations would be required to reach a Phi coefficient of 0.8. Removing clinically non-discriminating items from the traditional checklist did not affect the number of stations (15) required to reach a Phi of 0.8 with 10 items. Focusing the checklist on only evidence-based clinically discriminating items increased test score reliability, needing 11 stations instead of 15 to reach 0.8; adding missing evidence-based clinically discriminating items to the traditional checklist modestly improved reliability (needing 14 instead of 15 stations). Checklists composed of evidence-based clinically discriminating items improved the reliability of checklist scores and reduced the number of stations needed for acceptable reliability. Educators should give preference to evidence-based items over non-evidence-based items when developing OSCE checklists.
Department of Medicine, University of Alberta, 5-112 Clinical Sciences Building, 11350-83 Avenue NW, Edmonton, AB, T6G 2G3, Canada, vdaniels@ualberta.ca.
Vijay J
VJ
Daniels
Georges
G
Bordage
Mark J
MJ
Gierl
Rachel
R
Yudkowsky
D002170:Canada; D057189:Checklist; D002983:Clinical Competence / Q000592:standards*; D004503:Education, Medical, Graduate; D004521:Educational Measurement / Q000379:methods; D055317:Evidence-Based Practice / Q000592:standards*; D006801:Humans; D007388:Internal Medicine / Q000592:standards*; D007396:Internship and Residency / Q000592:standards*; D010808:Physical Examination / Q000592:standards*; D015203:Reproducibility of Results; D013337:Students, Medical