Are asymmetric metal markings on the cone surface of ceramic femoral heads an indication of entrapped debris?
BACKGROUND
The probability of in vivo failure of ceramic hip joint implants is very low (0.004-0.05%). In addition to material flaws and overloading, improper handling during implantation can induce fractures of the ceramic ball head in the long term. Identifying the causes of an in vivo fracture contributes to improved understanding and potentially to further reduction of the fracture probability for patients. Asymmetric metal markings on the cone surface of in vivo ball head fractures have been reported. The question, therefore, is whether asymmetric loading is the sole cause or whether additional factors, specifically contamination entrapped in the taper fit, also contribute or are even the main cause.


METHODS
The influence of the asymmetric physiological load configuration on resulting metal markings in the cone surface of an alumina femoral ball head with and without biological contaminants was investigated. Static and cyclic tests on ball heads were carried out in a load configuration of 0° (axisymmetric) and 40° in a physiological environment. The analysis of the metal marking was carried out to gain a better understanding of the processes that contribute to the generation of metal marking. Fractography was carried out to determine the fracture initiation of failed ball heads.


RESULTS
Different types and sizes of residuals entrapped in the conical surface are shown to yield strongly asymmetric metal marking patterns. All heads tested without contaminants exhibited an almost homogenous distribution of residual metal markings around the circumference of the ceramic cone surface at the proximal end of the bore hole. The failure of ball heads that contained entrapped contaminants revealed a common fracture pattern. The site of fracture initiation on two of the failed heads was in the entrance region of the bore hole on the superior half of the head.


CONCLUSIONS
Asymmetric metal markings observed on the ball heads tested in this investigation are most probably caused by the presence of contaminants entrapped in the taper fit. Homogenous metal mark distributions around the circumference indicate proper assembly of the ball head without entrapped contaminants. It should, however, be noted that different taper designs may possibly result in different marking patterns.
Empa, Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology, Mechanical Systems Engineering, Duebendorf CH-8600, Switzerland. sebastian.valet@empa.ch.
Sebastian
S
Valet
Bernhard
B
Weisse
Jakob
J
Kuebler
Martin
M
Zimmermann
Christian
C
Affolter
Giovanni Pietro
GP
Terrasi
D002516:Ceramics; D005270:Femur Head; D008422:Materials Testing; D055595:Mechanical Phenomena; D008670:Metals; D011475:Prosthesis Failure; D013499:Surface Properties
D008670:Metals