title: Individuals and groups in evolution: Darwinian pluralism and the multilevel selection debate.
abstract: Outlined here is an updated review of the long-standing 'kin selection vs group selection' debate. Group selection is a highly contentious concept, scientifically and philosophically. In 2012, Dawkins' attack against Wilson's latest book about eusociality concentrated all the attention on group selection and its mutual exclusivity with respect to inclusive fitness theory. Both opponents seem to be wrong, facing the general consensus in the field, which favours a pluralistic approach. Historically, despite some misunderstandings in current literature, such a perspective is clearly rooted in Darwin's writings, which suggested a plurality of levels of selection and a general view that we propose to call 'imperfect selfishness'. Today, the mathematically updated hypothesis of group selection has little to do with earlier versions of 'group selection'. It does not imply ontologically unmanageable notions of 'groups'. We propose here population structure as the main criterion of compatibility between kin selection and group selection. The latter is now evidently a pattern among others within a more general 'multilevel selection' theory. Different explanations and patterns are not mutually exclusive. Such a Darwinian pluralism is not a piece of the past, but a path into the future. A challenge in philosophy of biology will be to figure out the logical structure of this emerging pluralistic theory of evolution in such contentious debates.
authors.affiliation: Department of Biology, University of Padua, Padova, Italy, dietelmo.pievani@unipd.it.
authors.forename: Telmo
authors.initials: T
authors.lastname: Pievani
mesh_terms: D000818:Animals; D005075:Biological Evolution; D018864:Cultural Diversity; D006801:Humans; D008954:Models, Biological; D012641:Selection, Genetic; D012919:Social Behavior
references.citation: Nature. 2011 Mar 24;471(7339):E1-4; author reply E9-10
references.pmid: 21430721
references.citation: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1975 Jan;72(1):143-6
references.pmid: 1054490
references.citation: Q Rev Biol. 2007 Dec;82(4):327-48
references.pmid: 18217526
references.citation: Am Nat. 1997 Jul;150 Suppl 1:S59-79
references.pmid: 18811313
references.citation: Science. 2006 Dec 8;314(5805):1560-3
references.pmid: 17158317
references.citation: Nature. 2008 Nov 20;456(7220):326-7
references.pmid: 19020603
references.citation: Evolution. 1987 Sep;41(5):1059-1070
references.pmid: 28563418
references.citation: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009 May 26;106(21):8601-4
references.pmid: 19433793
references.citation: Science. 2010 Jun 25;328(5986):1700-3
references.pmid: 20576891
references.citation: Nature. 2010 Aug 26;466(7310):1057-62
references.pmid: 20740005