title: Chondrogenic differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells: challenges and unfulfilled expectations.
abstract: Articular cartilage repair and regeneration provides a substantial challenge in Regenerative Medicine because of the high degree of morphological and mechanical complexity intrinsic to hyaline cartilage due, in part, to its extracellular matrix. Cartilage remains one of the most difficult tissues to heal; even state-of-the-art regenerative medicine technology cannot yet provide authentic cartilage resurfacing. Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) were once believed to be the panacea for cartilage repair and regeneration, but despite years of research, they have not fulfilled these expectations. It has been observed that MSCs have an intrinsic differentiation program reminiscent of endochondral bone formation, which they follow after exposure to specific reagents as a part of current differentiation protocols. Efforts have been made to avoid the resulting hypertrophic fate of MSCs; however, so far, none of these has recreated a fully functional articular hyaline cartilage without chondrocytes exhibiting a hypertrophic phenotype. We reviewed the current literature in an attempt to understand why MSCs have failed to regenerate articular cartilage. The challenges that must be overcome before MSC-based tissue engineering can become a front-line technology for successful articular cartilage regeneration are highlighted.
authors.affiliation: Department of Biology, Skeletal Research Center, Case Western Reserve University , Cleveland, Ohio.
authors.forename: Rodrigo A
authors.initials: RA
authors.lastname: Somoza
authors.forename: Jean F
authors.initials: JF
authors.lastname: Welter
authors.forename: Diego
authors.initials: D
authors.lastname: Correa
authors.forename: Arnold I
authors.initials: AI
authors.lastname: Caplan
mesh_terms: D000818:Animals; D002358:Cartilage, Articular / Q000166:cytology; D018929:Cell Culture Techniques; D002454:Cell Differentiation; D020219:Chondrogenesis; D006801:Humans; D059630:Mesenchymal Stem Cells / Q000166:cytology*
references.citation: Tissue Eng Part A. 2011 Apr;17(7-8):1137-45
references.pmid: 21142648
references.citation: J Orthop Res. 1997 Nov;15(6):803-7
references.pmid: 9497803
references.citation: Tissue Eng. 2007 Feb;13(2):405-14
references.pmid: 17504064
references.citation: Osteoarthritis Cartilage. 2002 Jul;10(7):564-72
references.pmid: 12127837
references.citation: PLoS One. 2010 Oct 14;5(10):e13246
references.pmid: 20976230
references.citation: Exp Cell Res. 1998 Jan 10;238(1):265-72
references.pmid: 9457080
references.citation: Tissue Eng Part B Rev. 2008 Sep;14(3):235-47
references.pmid: 18601586
references.citation: Tissue Eng. 2002 Oct;8(5):817-26
references.pmid: 12459060
references.citation: Tissue Cell. 1986;18(2):153-74
references.pmid: 3085281
references.citation: J Cell Physiol. 2005 May;203(2):398-409
references.pmid: 15521064
references.citation: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2010 Apr 20;107(16):7251-6
references.pmid: 20406908
references.citation: Rheumatology (Oxford). 2007 Nov;46(11):1676-83
references.pmid: 17901063
references.citation: Tissue Eng Part A. 2010 Feb;16(2):523-33
references.pmid: 19715387
references.citation: Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2007 Jun 22;358(1):99-103
references.pmid: 17482567
references.citation: J Cell Sci. 2004 Jun 15;117(Pt 14):2971-81
references.pmid: 15173316
references.citation: Matrix Biol. 2008 Jan;27(1):12-21
references.pmid: 17689060
references.citation: Vet J. 2012 Jun;192(3):345-51
references.pmid: 21968294
references.citation: Stem Cells Dev. 2010 Feb;19(2):229-38
references.pmid: 19558219
references.citation: Stem Cells. 2005 Mar;23(3):403-11
references.pmid: 15749935
references.citation: Stem Cells Dev. 2013 Oct 1;22(19):2606-18
references.pmid: 23676112
references.citation: J Cell Physiol. 2010 Sep;224(3):664-71
references.pmid: 20432462
references.citation: J Bone Miner Res. 2003 Apr;18(4):696-704
references.pmid: 12674330
references.citation: Int J Clin Exp Med. 2011;4(1):81-90
references.pmid: 21394289
references.citation: Cell. 2006 Aug 25;126(4):663-76
references.pmid: 16904174
references.citation: J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2014 Jan 15;96(2):90-8
references.pmid: 24430407
references.citation: Exp Hematol. 1976 Sep;4(5):267-74
references.pmid: 976387
references.citation: Matrix Biol. 2008 Jul;27(6):526-34
references.pmid: 18534835
references.citation: J Cell Biochem. 2010 Nov 1;111(4):834-45
references.pmid: 20665538
references.citation: Methods Mol Biol. 2006;330:161-70
references.pmid: 16846024
references.citation: Eur Cell Mater. 2010 Oct 05;20:245-59
references.pmid: 20925023
references.citation: Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2009 Feb 20;379(4):1114-9
references.pmid: 19161980
references.citation: Nature. 2002 Jul 4;418(6893):41-9
references.pmid: 12077603
references.citation: Stem Cells. 2007 Sep;25(9):2183-90
references.pmid: 17540854
references.citation: Congest Heart Fail. 2005 Mar-Apr;11(2):87-91; quiz 92-3
references.pmid: 15860974
references.citation: Dev Biol. 1993 Aug;158(2):414-29
references.pmid: 8344460
references.citation: Exp Cell Res. 1998 Apr 10;240(1):58-65
references.pmid: 9570921
references.citation: J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1998 Dec;80(12):1745-57
references.pmid: 9875932
references.citation: Open Rheumatol J. 2010 Feb 11;4:10-4
references.pmid: 20352028
references.citation: J Cell Biochem. 2013 Feb;114(2):480-90
references.pmid: 22961870
references.citation: Exp Cell Res. 1999 Sep 15;251(2):257-63
references.pmid: 10471311
references.citation: Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1999 Oct;(367 Suppl):S156-62
references.pmid: 10546644
references.citation: Arthritis Rheum. 2009 Dec;60(12):3686-92
references.pmid: 19950276
references.citation: Arthroscopy. 2003 May-Jun;19(5):477-84
references.pmid: 12724676
references.citation: Tissue Eng Part A. 2010 Dec;16(12):3709-18
references.pmid: 20673022
references.citation: J Orthop Res. 2006 Aug;24(8):1791-8
references.pmid: 16779832
references.citation: Haematologica. 2012 Feb;97(2):179-83
references.pmid: 21993672
references.citation: Connect Tissue Res. 1988;18(3):223-34
references.pmid: 3219851
references.citation: Tissue Eng Part A. 2010 Feb;16(2):643-51
references.pmid: 19754222
references.citation: Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1992 Feb;(275):280-6
references.pmid: 1735226
references.citation: PLoS One. 2012;7(3):e33225
references.pmid: 22457746
references.citation: Stem Cells. 2001;19(3):180-92
references.pmid: 11359943
references.citation: Biomaterials. 2002 Mar;23(6):1511-7
references.pmid: 11833491
references.citation: J Cell Physiol. 2010 Apr;223(1):84-93
references.pmid: 20049852
references.citation: Arthritis Rheum. 2010 Sep;62(9):2696-706
references.pmid: 20496422
references.citation: Cell Physiol Biochem. 2007;20(5):665-78
references.pmid: 17762193
references.citation: Arthritis Rheum. 2006 Oct;54(10):3254-66
references.pmid: 17009260
references.citation: Stem Cells Dev. 2009 Sep;18(7):969-78
references.pmid: 19049404
references.citation: Sports Health. 2009 Nov;1(6):461-8
references.pmid: 23015907
references.citation: Arthritis Rheum. 2003 Mar;48(3):709-18
references.pmid: 12632424
references.citation: Stem Cells. 2007 Apr;25(4):950-60
references.pmid: 17218402
references.citation: Cell Transplant. 2004;13(5):595-600
references.pmid: 15565871
references.citation: Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2000 Mar 5;269(1):172-8
references.pmid: 10694496
references.citation: Cells Tissues Organs. 2010;191(1):12-20
references.pmid: 19546516
references.citation: Cell. 2007 Jun 29;129(7):1377-88
references.pmid: 17604725
references.citation: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2002 Apr 2;99(7):4397-402
references.pmid: 11917104
references.citation: Dev Cell. 2002 Apr;2(4):389-406
references.pmid: 11970890
references.citation: J Cell Biochem. 1998 Dec 1;71(3):313-27
references.pmid: 9831069
references.citation: Development. 2009 Feb;136(4):509-23
references.pmid: 19168672
references.citation: Open Orthop J. 2011;5 Suppl 2:242-8
references.pmid: 21886689
references.citation: Stem Cells Dev. 2010 Apr;19(4):469-80
references.pmid: 19795982
references.citation: Biotechnol Lett. 2010 Sep;32(9):1339-46
references.pmid: 20464452
references.citation: PLoS One. 2013 Oct 16;8(10):e77365
references.pmid: 24146984
references.citation: Methods Mol Biol. 2011;698:253-78
references.pmid: 21431525
references.citation: Arthritis Rheum. 2005 Aug;52(8):2521-9
references.pmid: 16052568
references.citation: Tissue Eng Part B Rev. 2009 Dec;15(4):381-94
references.pmid: 19505199
references.citation: Mol Cells. 2008 Feb 29;25(1):1-6
references.pmid: 18319608
references.citation: Stem Cell Rev Rep. 2011 Mar;7(1):64-76
references.pmid: 20396979
references.citation: Circulation. 2004 Oct 12;110(15):2226-32
references.pmid: 15466630
references.citation: Blood. 2011 May 12;117(19):5067-77
references.pmid: 21415267
references.citation: Bioessays. 1987 Apr;6(4):171-5
references.pmid: 3593327
references.citation: Cell Stem Cell. 2008 Sep 11;3(3):301-13
references.pmid: 18786417
references.citation: Arthritis Rheum. 2006 Jan;54(1):226-9
references.pmid: 16385518
references.citation: Stem Cells Dev. 2012 Sep 20;21(14):2724-52
references.pmid: 22468918
references.citation: Tissue Eng Part A. 2010 Mar;16(3):1009-19
references.pmid: 19842915
references.citation: Calcif Tissue Int. 2000 Sep;67(3):230-40
references.pmid: 10954778
references.citation: Science. 1999 Apr 2;284(5411):143-7
references.pmid: 10102814
references.citation: J Cell Mol Med. 2009 Sep;13(9B):3570-90
references.pmid: 19426158
references.citation: PLoS One. 2011 Mar 11;6(3):e17610
references.pmid: 21412425
references.citation: Cell Prolif. 2013 Aug;46(4):396-407
references.pmid: 23869761
references.citation: Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2004 Jun;(423):17-26
references.pmid: 15232421
references.citation: Clin Exp Pharmacol Physiol. 2005 Jul;32(7):561-70
references.pmid: 16026516
references.citation: Arthritis Rheum. 2001 Aug;44(8):1928-42
references.pmid: 11508446
references.citation: Arthritis Rheum. 2008 May;58(5):1377-88
references.pmid: 18438858
references.citation: Osteoarthritis Cartilage. 2003 Sep;11(9):653-64
references.pmid: 12954236
references.citation: Arthritis Rheum. 2007 Jul;56(7):2312-21
references.pmid: 17599751
references.citation: Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1990 Oct;(259):223-32
references.pmid: 2208860
references.citation: Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2008 Nov 7;376(1):148-53
references.pmid: 18774772
references.citation: Stem Cell Res Ther. 2010 Mar 15;1(1):2
references.pmid: 20504283
references.citation: Stem Cell Reports. 2013 Dec 12;1(6):575-89
references.pmid: 24371811
references.citation: Tissue Eng Part A. 2011 May;17(9-10):1425-36
references.pmid: 21247341
references.citation: J Cell Biochem. 2001 Jun 26-Jul 25;83(1):121-8
references.pmid: 11500960
references.citation: Tissue Eng Part A. 2010 Jan;16(1):317-25
references.pmid: 19702511
references.citation: J Orthop Res. 2001 Jul;19(4):738-49
references.pmid: 11518286
references.citation: Braz J Med Biol Res. 2011 Apr;44(4):303-10
references.pmid: 21487642
references.citation: Tissue Eng Part A. 2011 Jul;17(13-14):1809-18
references.pmid: 21366427
references.citation: Nature. 2011 May 13;474(7350):212-5
references.pmid: 21572395
references.citation: Cell Transplant. 2013;22(7):1201-11
references.pmid: 23044363
references.citation: Osteoarthritis Cartilage. 2003 Aug;11(8):595-602
references.pmid: 12880582
references.citation: Int J Exp Pathol. 2012 Dec;93(6):389-400
references.pmid: 23075006
references.citation: J Histochem Cytochem. 2002 Aug;50(8):1049-58
references.pmid: 12133908
references.citation: Arthritis Res Ther. 2012 Apr 10;14(2):R72
references.pmid: 22490392
references.citation: Regen Med. 2013 Mar;8(2):125-44
references.pmid: 23249126
references.citation: J Cell Biochem. 2003 Apr 1;88(5):873-84
references.pmid: 12616527
references.citation: Stem Cells. 2008 Sep;26(9):2287-99
references.pmid: 18566331
references.citation: J Cell Sci. 2004 Feb 29;117(Pt 6):889-97
references.pmid: 14762107
references.citation: Tissue Eng. 2006 Sep;12(9):2639-47
references.pmid: 16995797
references.citation: J Bone Miner Res. 1998 May;13(5):828-38
references.pmid: 9610747
references.citation: Stem Cells Dev. 2011 Jun;20(6):1099-112
references.pmid: 20846027
references.citation: N Engl J Med. 1989 May 18;320(20):1322-30
references.pmid: 2654632
references.citation: Tissue Eng Part B Rev. 2009 Jun;15(2):143-57
references.pmid: 19203206
references.citation: Arthritis Rheum. 2008 Jan;58(1):15-25
references.pmid: 18163481
references.citation: J Cell Physiol. 2012 Jan;227(1):88-97
references.pmid: 22025108
references.citation: Stem Cells Transl Med. 2012 Nov;1(11):771-82
references.pmid: 23197689
references.citation: Tissue Eng. 1998 Winter;4(4):415-28
references.pmid: 9916173
references.citation: J Cell Biol. 1997 Oct 20;139(2):541-52
references.pmid: 9334355
references.citation: J Cell Sci. 1990 Nov;97 ( Pt 3):449-61
references.pmid: 2074265
references.citation: Stem Cells Dev. 2013 Jan 1;22(1):102-13
references.pmid: 22817676
references.citation: Knee. 2012 Dec;19(6):902-7
references.pmid: 22583627
references.citation: J Gene Med. 2006 Jan;8(1):112-25
references.pmid: 16142704
references.citation: Arthritis Rheum. 2003 Feb;48(2):418-29
references.pmid: 12571852
references.citation: Rheumatol Int. 2013 Feb;33(2):401-11
references.pmid: 22453523
references.citation: J Anat. 2009 Sep;215(3):355-63
references.pmid: 19563472
references.citation: Stem Cells Int. 2013;2013:312501
references.pmid: 23766767
references.citation: Arthritis Res Ther. 2008;10(4):R74
references.pmid: 18598346
references.citation: Science. 1965 Nov 12;150(3698):893-9
references.pmid: 5319761
references.citation: Stem Cells Int. 2013;2013:983059
references.pmid: 24023546
references.citation: J Cell Physiol. 2007 Aug;212(2):281-4
references.pmid: 17520697
references.citation: J Cell Biochem. 2006 Jan 1;97(1):84-97
references.pmid: 16088956
references.citation: J Clin Invest. 2011 Feb;121(2):640-57
references.pmid: 21293062
references.citation: Exp Cell Res. 2001 Aug 15;268(2):189-200
references.pmid: 11478845
references.citation: PLoS One. 2008 Jun 25;3(6):e2498
references.pmid: 18575581
references.citation: Osteoarthritis Cartilage. 2005 Aug;13(8):672-8
references.pmid: 15970445
references.citation: Osteoarthritis Cartilage. 2008 Feb;16(2):204-11
references.pmid: 17681804
references.citation: Regen Med. 2012 Jul;7(4):481-501
references.pmid: 22519755