Neural imaginaries and clinical epistemology: Rhetorically mapping the adolescent brain in the clinical encounter.
The social work of brain images has taken center stage in recent theorizing of the intersections between neuroscience and society. However, neuroimaging is only one of the discursive modes through which public representations of neurobiology travel. This article adopts an expanded view toward the social implications of neuroscientific thinking to examine how neural imaginaries are constructed in the absence of visual evidence. Drawing on ethnographic fieldwork conducted over 18 months (2008-2009) in a United States multidisciplinary pediatric pain clinic, I examine the pragmatic clinical work undertaken to represent ambiguous symptoms in neurobiological form. Focusing on one physician, I illustrate how, by rhetorically mapping the brain as a therapeutic tool, she engaged in a distinctive form of representation that I call neural imagining. In shifting my focus away from the purely material dimensions of brain images, I juxtapose the cultural work of brain scanning technologies with clinical neural imaginaries in which the teenage brain becomes a space of possibility, not to map things as they are, but rather, things as we hope they might be. These neural imaginaries rely upon a distinctive clinical epistemology that privileges the creative work of the imagination over visualization technologies in revealing the truths of the body. By creating a therapeutic space for adolescents to exercise their imaginative faculties and a discursive template for doing so, neural imagining relocates adolescents' agency with respect to epistemologies of bodily knowledge and the role of visualization practices therein. In doing so, it provides a more hopeful alternative to the dominant popular and scientific representations of the teenage brain that view it primarily through the lens of pathology.
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Department of Social Medicine, 333 S. Columbia Street, 341A MacNider Hall CB# 7240, Chapel Hill, NC 27599, USA. Electronic address: mara.buchbinder@gmail.com.
Mara
M
Buchbinder
D000293:Adolescent; D000884:Anthropology, Cultural; D001921:Brain; D002648:Child; D059350:Chronic Pain / Q000175:diagnosis / Q000503:physiopathology*; D006801:Humans; D007092:Imagination; D059906:Neuroimaging; D000297:Psychology, Adolescent; D014481:United States
Adolescence; Bodily epistemologies; Chronic pain; Clinical ethnography; Neuroimaging; United States