What is good governance in the context of drug policy?
The concept of governance is applied in a wide range of contexts, but this paper focuses on governance in relation to public administration, i.e. states and how they take action, and specifically governance of particular policy areas. In the current context of financial austerity and an era of globalisation, policy-makers face pressures and challenges from a growing range of interests and local, national and supranational actors. Drug policy is an example of a particularly contentious and polarised area in which governance-related challenges abound. In response to these challenges, interest has grown in developing agreed policy governance standards and processes and articulating policy-making guidelines, including the use of available evidence to inform policy-making. Attempts have been made to identify 'policy fundamentals' - factors or aspects of policy-making apparently associated with successful policy development and implementation (Hallsworth & Rutter, 2011; Laughrin, 2011) and, in the drug policy field, Hughes et al. (2010) reflecting on the co-ordination of Australian drug policy highlighted some of what they considered principles of good governance. But how useful is the concept of 'good governance'; how well can it be defined, and to what purpose? As part of a wider project considering the governance of drug policy, RAND Europe and the UK Drug Policy Commission undertook a targeted review of other research and sought expert views, from within and beyond drug policy, on principles, processes, structures and stakeholders associated with good drug policy governance. From this emerged some perceived characteristics of good governance that were then used by the UK Drug Policy Commission to assess the extent to which drug policy making in the UK fits with these perceived good governance characteristics, and to suggest possible improvements. Particular consideration was given to the range of interests at stake, the overarching aims of drug policy and the development and inclusion of an evidence base where possible. This paper draws on findings of the study to highlight challenges associated with defining good governance, provides an example of a framework for assessing drug policy governance and discusses the feasibility, transferability and potential benefits of such an undertaking.
UK Drug Policy Commission, Kings Place, 90 York Way, London N1 9AG, United Kingdom. Electronic address: nicolasingleton22@gmail.com.
Nicola
N
Singleton
RAND Europe, Westbrook Centre, Milton Road, Cambridge CB4 1YG, United Kingdom. Electronic address: jkrubin@rand.org.
Jennifer
J
Rubin
D004335:Drug and Narcotic Control / Q000331:legislation & jurisprudence*; D006076:Government; D017408:Guidelines as Topic; D006291:Health Policy / Q000331:legislation & jurisprudence*; D006801:Humans; D011050:Policy Making; D006113:United Kingdom
Drug policy; Evidence; Expert consultation; Good governance; Governance framework; Policy processes