title: Inter-rater reliability for movement pattern analysis (MPA): measuring patterning of behaviors versus discrete behavior counts as indicators of decision-making style.
abstract: The unique yield of collecting observational data on human movement has received increasing attention in a number of domains, including the study of decision-making style. As such, interest has grown in the nuances of core methodological issues, including the best ways of assessing inter-rater reliability. In this paper we focus on one key topic - the distinction between establishing reliability for the patterning of behaviors as opposed to the computation of raw counts - and suggest that reliability for each be compared empirically rather than determined a priori. We illustrate by assessing inter-rater reliability for key outcome measures derived from movement pattern analysis (MPA), an observational methodology that records body movements as indicators of decision-making style with demonstrated predictive validity. While reliability ranged from moderate to good for raw counts of behaviors reflecting each of two Overall Factors generated within MPA (Assertion and Perspective), inter-rater reliability for patterning (proportional indicators of each factor) was significantly higher and excellent (ICC = 0.89). Furthermore, patterning, as compared to raw counts, provided better prediction of observable decision-making process assessed in the laboratory. These analyses support the utility of using an empirical approach to inform the consideration of measuring patterning versus discrete behavioral counts of behaviors when determining inter-rater reliability of observable behavior. They also speak to the substantial reliability that may be achieved via application of theoretically grounded observational systems such as MPA that reveal thinking and action motivations via visible movement patterns.
authors.affiliation: Chief of Naval Operations Strategic Studies Group, Naval War College Newport, RI, USA.
authors.forename: Brenda L
authors.initials: BL
authors.lastname: Connors
authors.affiliation: Social Behavioral Research Applications South Dartmouth, MA, USA.
authors.forename: Richard
authors.initials: R
authors.lastname: Rende
authors.affiliation: Department of Government, Harvard University Cambridge, MA, USA.
authors.forename: Timothy J
authors.initials: TJ
authors.lastname: Colton
keywords: decision-making; individual differences; inter-rater reliability; movement pattern analysis; observational methods