title: Pursuing optimal thresholds to recommend breast biopsy by quantifying the value of tomosynthesis.
abstract: A 2% threshold has been traditionally used to recommend breast biopsy in mammography. We aim to characterize how the biopsy threshold varies to achieve the maximum expected utility (MEU) of tomosynthesis for breast cancer diagnosis. A cohort of 312 patients, imaged with standard full field digital mammography (FFDM) and digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT), was selected for a reader study. Fifteen readers interpreted each patient's images and estimated the probability of malignancy using two modes: FFDM versus FFDM + DBT. We generated receiver operator characteristic (ROC) curves with the probabilities for all readers combined. We found that FFDM+DBT provided improved accuracy and MEU compared with FFDM alone. When DBT was included in the diagnosis along with FFDM, the optimal biopsy threshold increased to 2.7% as compared with the 2% threshold for FFDM alone. While understanding the optimal threshold from a decision analytic standpoint will not help physicians improve their performance without additional guidance (e.g. decision support to reinforce this threshold), the discovery of this level does demonstrate the potential clinical improvements attainable with DBT. Specifically, DBT has the potential to lead to substantial improvements in breast cancer diagnosis since it could reduce the number of patients recommended for biopsy while preserving the maximal expected utility.
authors: Dept. of Radiology, UW Madison, Madison, WI, USA.
authors: Yirong
authors: Y
authors: Wu
authors: Dept. of Industrial and Systems Engineering, UW Madison, WI, USA.
authors: Oguzhan
authors: O
authors: Alagoz
authors: Dept. of Population Health Sciences, UW Madison, WI, USA.
authors: David J
authors: DJ
authors: Vanness
authors: Dept. of Population Health Sciences, UW Madison, WI, USA.
authors: Amy
authors: A
authors: Trentham-Dietz
authors: Dept. of Radiology, UW Madison, Madison, WI, USA.
authors: Elizabeth S
authors: ES
authors: Burnside
keywords: Breast Biopsy; Digital Breast Tomosynthesis; Expected Utility; Mammography; ROC Analysis