title: Responses of 9 lepidopteran species to Bacillus thuringiensis: How useful is phylogenetic relatedness for selecting surrogate species for nontarget arthropod risk assessment?
abstract: To evaluate phylogenetic relatedness as a proxy for susceptibility to Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) when selecting species to act as surrogates for others in prerelease testing, we examined the responses of 11 laboratory-reared lepidopteran colonies, comprising members of 2 families, 5 genera, and 9 species, to a commercial Bt preparation. Survival, pupal mass, and timing of pupation and adult emergence of 2 noctuids (Spodoptera litura and Helicoverpa armigera) and 7 tortricids (Cnephasia jactatana, Ctenopseustis obliquana, Ctenopseustis herana,Planotortrix octo, Planotortrix notophaea,Planotortrix excessana [2 different laboratory colonies], and Epiphyas postvittana [2 colonies]) were examined after feeding first instar larvae with artificial diet containing 5 μL/100 mL Dipel ES (Bt subsp. kurstaki). Bt caused significant larval mortality in all species except S. litura, in which only pupation was delayed compared with untreated controls. Neither of the noctuid species tested would act as a suitable surrogate for the other in tests of Bt impacts on survival. With the exception of the 2 colonies of E. postvittana, which differed from each other not only in their responses to Bt but also in their development times when not treated with Bt, species within each tortricid genus had similar responses to Bt and thus could act as surrogates for each other. Members of different genera within this family could represent each other only if relatively coarse measurement endpoints (e.g., toxic or not) were considered adequate for assessing risks to nontarget species in the field.
authors.affiliation: The New Zealand Institute for Plant & Food Research Ltd, Private Bag 92 169, Auckland, 1142, New Zealand.
authors.forename: Elisabeth P J
authors.initials: EP
authors.lastname: Burgess
authors.affiliation: The New Zealand Institute for Plant & Food Research Ltd, Private Bag 92 169, Auckland, 1142, New Zealand.
authors.forename: Emma I
authors.initials: EI
authors.lastname: Barraclough
authors.affiliation: The New Zealand Institute for Plant & Food Research Ltd, Private Bag 92 169, Auckland, 1142, New Zealand.
authors.forename: Aliesha M
authors.initials: AM
authors.lastname: Kean
authors.affiliation: The New Zealand Institute for Plant & Food Research Ltd, Private Bag 92 169, Auckland, 1142, New Zealand.
authors.forename: Ngaire P
authors.initials: NP
authors.lastname: Markwick
authors.affiliation: The New Zealand Institute for Plant & Food Research Ltd, Private Bag 92 169, Auckland, 1142, New Zealand.
authors.forename: Louise A
authors.initials: LA
authors.lastname: Malone
mesh_terms: D000818:Animals; D001413:Bacillus thuringiensis; D009036:Moths; D010802:Phylogeny; D018570:Risk Assessment; D018675:Toxicity Tests
keywords: Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) subsp. kurstaki; Lepidoptera; Noctuidae; Tortricidae; nontarget impacts; risk assessment