title: Changes in latent fingerprint examiners' markup between analysis and comparison.
abstract: After the initial analysis of a latent print, an examiner will sometimes revise the assessment during comparison with an exemplar. Changes between analysis and comparison may indicate that the initial analysis of the latent was inadequate, or that confirmation bias may have affected the comparison. 170 volunteer latent print examiners, each randomly assigned 22 pairs of prints from a pool of 320 total pairs, provided detailed markup documenting their interpretations of the prints and the bases for their comparison conclusions. We describe changes in value assessments and markup of features and clarity. When examiners individualized, they almost always added or deleted minutiae (90.3% of individualizations); every examiner revised at least some markups. For inconclusive and exclusion determinations, changes were less common, and features were added more frequently when the image pair was mated (same source). Even when individualizations were based on eight or fewer corresponding minutiae, in most cases some of those minutiae had been added during comparison. One erroneous individualization was observed: the markup changes were notably extreme, and almost all of the corresponding minutiae had been added during comparison. Latents assessed to be of value for exclusion only (VEO) during analysis were often individualized when compared to a mated exemplar (26%); in our previous work, where examiners were not required to provide markup of features, VEO individualizations were much less common (1.8%).
authors.affiliation: Noblis, Falls Church, VA, USA.
authors.forename: Bradford T
authors.initials: BT
authors.lastname: Ulery
authors.affiliation: Noblis, Falls Church, VA, USA.
authors.forename: R Austin
authors.initials: RA
authors.lastname: Hicklin
authors.affiliation: Latent Print Support Unit, Federal Bureau of Investigation Laboratory Division, Quantico, VA, USA.
authors.forename: Maria Antonia
authors.initials: MA
authors.lastname: Roberts
authors.affiliation: Counterterrorism and Forensic Science Research Unit, Federal Bureau of Investigation Laboratory Division, Quantico, VA, USA. Electronic address: joann.buscaglia@ic.fbi.gov.
authors.forename: JoAnn
authors.initials: J
authors.lastname: Buscaglia
mesh_terms: D003657:Decision Making; D003878:Dermatoglyphics; D006801:Humans; D011340:Problem Solving; D011786:Quality Control
keywords: Biometrics; Decision; Fingerprints; Forensic science; Identification; Quality assurance