title: Cost-Benefit Analysis for Optimization of Risk Protection Under Budget Constraints.
abstract: Cost-benefit analysis (CBA) is commonly applied as a tool for deciding on risk protection. With CBA, one can identify risk mitigation strategies that lead to an optimal tradeoff between the costs of the mitigation measures and the achieved risk reduction. In practical applications of CBA, the strategies are typically evaluated through efficiency indicators such as the benefit-cost ratio (BCR) and the marginal cost (MC) criterion. In many of these applications, the BCR is not consistently defined, which, as we demonstrate in this article, can lead to the identification of suboptimal solutions. This is of particular relevance when the overall budget for risk reduction measures is limited and an optimal allocation of resources among different subsystems is necessary. We show that this problem can be formulated as a hierarchical decision problem, where the general rules and decisions on the available budget are made at a central level (e.g., central government agency, top management), whereas the decisions on the specific measures are made at the subsystem level (e.g., local communities, company division). It is shown that the MC criterion provides optimal solutions in such hierarchical optimization. Since most practical applications only include a discrete set of possible risk protection measures, the MC criterion is extended to this situation. The findings are illustrated through a hypothetical numerical example. This study was prepared as part of our work on the optimal management of natural hazard risks, but its conclusions also apply to other fields of risk management.
authors: Engineering Risk Analysis Group, Faculty of Civil, Geo and Environmental Engineering, Technische Universität München, Munich, Germany.
authors: Olga
authors: O
authors: Špačková
authors: Engineering Risk Analysis Group, Faculty of Civil, Geo and Environmental Engineering, Technische Universität München, Munich, Germany.
authors: Daniel
authors: D
authors: Straub
keywords: Benefit-cost ratio; cost-benefit analysis; marginal cost criterion; natural hazards; risk protection optimization; risk-based decision making