Performance comparison of LUR and OK in PM2.5 concentration mapping: a multidimensional perspective.
Methods of Land Use Regression (LUR) modeling and Ordinary Kriging (OK) interpolation have been widely used to offset the shortcomings of PM2.5 data observed at sparse monitoring sites. However, traditional point-based performance evaluation strategy for these methods remains stagnant, which could cause unreasonable mapping results. To address this challenge, this study employs 'information entropy', an area-based statistic, along with traditional point-based statistics (e.g. error rate, RMSE) to evaluate the performance of LUR model and OK interpolation in mapping PM2.5 concentrations in Houston from a multidimensional perspective. The point-based validation reveals significant differences between LUR and OK at different test sites despite the similar end-result accuracy (e.g. error rate 6.13% vs. 7.01%). Meanwhile, the area-based validation demonstrates that the PM2.5 concentrations simulated by the LUR model exhibits more detailed variations than those interpolated by the OK method (i.e. information entropy, 7.79 vs. 3.63). Results suggest that LUR modeling could better refine the spatial distribution scenario of PM2.5 concentrations compared to OK interpolation. The significance of this study primarily lies in promoting the integration of point- and area-based statistics for model performance evaluation in air pollution mapping.
1] School of Geosciences and Info-Physics, Central South University, Changsha. 410083, China [2] Shanghai Key Laboratory of Atmospheric Particle Pollution and Prevention (LAP3), Shanghai, 200433. China.
Bin
B
Zou
School of Geosciences and Info-Physics, Central South University, Changsha. 410083, China.
Yanqing
Y
Luo
Department of Geography, University of Utah, Salt Lake City. UT 84112, USA.
Neng
N
Wan
School of Geosciences and Info-Physics, Central South University, Changsha. 410083, China.
Zhong
Z
Zheng
School of Geography and Environment, Oxford University, Oxford, UK.
Troy
T
Sternberg
State Key Laboratory of Resources and Environmental Information System, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing. 100001, China.
Yilan
Y
Liao