Rethinking responsibility in offenders with acquired paedophilia: punishment or treatment?
This article reviews the current neurobiological literature on the aetiology of developmental and acquired paedophilia and examines what the consequences could be in terms of responsibility and treatment for the latter. Addressing the question of responsibility and punishment of offenders with acquired paedophilia from a neurobiological perspective is controversial. Consequently it is essential to avoid hasty conclusions based strictly on neurobiological abnormality justifications. This study establishes a distinction between developmental and acquired paedophilia. The article investigates whether offenders who fulfil the diagnosis of acquired paedophilia should be held fully responsible, particularly in cases where the offender's conduct appears to result from volitionally controlled behaviour that is seemingly incompatible with a neurological cause. Moreover, the article explores how responsibility can be compromised when offenders with acquired paedophilia have (partially) preserved moral knowledge despite their sexual disorder. The article then examines the option of offering mandatory treatment as an alternative to imprisonment for offenders with acquired paedophilia. Furthermore, the article addresses the ethical issues related to offering any form of quasi-coercive treatment as a condition of release. This study concludes that decisions to fully or partially excuse an individual who fulfil the diagnosis of acquired paedophilia should take all relevant information into account, both neurobiological and other environmental evidence, and should proceed on a careful case by case analysis before sentencing or offering treatment.
Ethics, Policy & Public Engagement (EPPE) ARC Centre of Excellence for Electromaterials Science (ACES), Faculty of Arts, University of Tasmania, Australia. Electronic address: https://sites.google.com/site/fredericgilbertt/home.
Frédéric
F
Gilbert
Bioethics Institute Ghent, Department of Philosophy and Moral Sciences, Ghent University, Belgium. Electronic address: farah.focquaert@ugent.be.
Farah
F
Focquaert
D003417:Criminal Psychology / Q000331:legislation & jurisprudence; D006801:Humans; D010378:Pedophilia / Q000209:etiology / Q000523:psychology / Q000628:therapy*; D012742:Sex Offenses / Q000331:legislation & jurisprudence* / Q000523:psychology
Chemical castration; Criminal behaviour; Paedophilia; Prison; Sexual offender treatment; Treatment effectiveness