title: The multifactorial role of the 3Rs in shifting the harm-benefit analysis in animal models of disease.
abstract: Ethics on animal use in science in Western society is based on utilitarianism, weighing the harms and benefits to the animals involved against those of the intended human beneficiaries. The 3Rs concept (Replacement, Reduction, Refinement) is both a robust framework for minimizing animal use and suffering (addressing the harms to animals) and a means of supporting high quality science and translation (addressing the benefits). The ambiguity of basic research performed early in the research continuum can sometimes make harm-benefit analysis more difficult since anticipated benefit is often an incremental contribution to a field of knowledge. On the other hand, benefit is much more evident in translational research aimed at developing treatments for direct application in humans or animals suffering from disease. Though benefit may be easier to define, it should certainly not be considered automatic. Issues related to model validity seriously compromise experiments and have been implicated as a major impediment in translation, especially in complex disease models where harms to animals can be intensified. Increased investment and activity in the 3Rs is delivering new research models, tools and approaches with reduced reliance on animal use, improved animal welfare, and improved scientific and predictive value.
authors.affiliation: University of Minnesota, Department of Surgery, St. Paul, MN, USA; University of Minnesota, Veterinary Population Medicine Department, St. Paul, MN, USA. Electronic address: graha066@umn.edu.
authors.forename: Melanie L
authors.initials: ML
authors.lastname: Graham
authors.affiliation: National Centre for the Replacement, Refinement and Reduction of Animals in Research (NC3Rs), London, UK.
authors.forename: Mark J
authors.initials: MJ
authors.lastname: Prescott
mesh_terms: D023401:Animal Use Alternatives; D000827:Animal Welfare; D000818:Animals; D026688:Bioethical Issues; D004195:Disease Models, Animal; D055808:Drug Discovery / Q000941:ethics / Q000379:methods* / Q000592:standards; D006801:Humans; D057170:Translational Research, Biomedical / Q000941:ethics / Q000379:methods* / Q000592:standards
keywords: Animal welfare; Drug development; Reduction; Refinement; Replacement; Utilitarianism
references.citation: Appl Anim Behav Sci. 2001 Apr 26;72(2):145-171
references.pmid: 11278033
references.citation: ILAR J. 2002;43 Suppl:S95-8
references.pmid: 12388859
references.citation: J Agric Environ Ethics. 1999;11:111-29
references.pmid: 14631987
references.citation: Nat Rev Drug Discov. 2004 Aug;3(8):711-5
references.pmid: 15286737
references.citation: J Appl Anim Welf Sci. 1998;1(2):91-102
references.pmid: 16363974
references.citation: Brain. 2006 Aug;129(Pt 8):1940-52
references.pmid: 16636022
references.citation: Lab Anim. 2007 Apr;41(2):143-60
references.pmid: 17430615
references.citation: Stroke. 2008 Mar;39(3):929-34
references.pmid: 18239164
references.citation: Thromb Haemost. 2008 Feb;99(2):435-40
references.pmid: 18278196
references.citation: Regul Toxicol Pharmacol. 2008 Apr;50(3):345-52
references.pmid: 18295384
references.citation: ALTEX. 2008;25(2):103-14
references.pmid: 18551234
references.citation: Nat Rev Drug Discov. 2009 Jan;8(1):15-6
references.pmid: 19008887
references.citation: Br J Pharmacol. 2009 Dec;158(7):1735-42
references.pmid: 19912226
references.citation: PLoS One. 2009 Nov 30;4(11):e7824
references.pmid: 19956596
references.citation: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2010 Apr 6;107(14):6127-33
references.pmid: 20194732
references.citation: PLoS Med. 2010 Mar 30;7(3):e1000245
references.pmid: 20361020
references.citation: PLoS Biol. 2010 Mar 30;8(3):e1000344
references.pmid: 20361022
references.citation: Prog Neurobiol. 2010 Nov;92(3):386-404
references.pmid: 20558237
references.citation: J Am Vet Med Assoc. 1991 Apr 15;198(8):1360-76
references.pmid: 2061152
references.citation: PLoS Biol. 2010 Jun 29;8(6):e1000412
references.pmid: 20613859
references.citation: Nat Methods. 2010 Oct;7(10):825-6
references.pmid: 20835246
references.citation: Br J Pharmacol. 2010 Oct;161(4):749-54
references.pmid: 20860657
references.citation: J Neurosci Methods. 2010 Nov 30;193(2):167-88
references.pmid: 20868708
references.citation: Nature. 2010 Sep 30;467(7315):543-9
references.pmid: 20882008
references.citation: Br J Pharmacol. 2011 Mar;162(6):1259-60
references.pmid: 21091655
references.citation: Islets. 2010 Jul-Aug;2(4):236-9
references.pmid: 21137597
references.citation: Prog Neuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry. 2011 Aug 1;35(6):1376-82
references.pmid: 21168465
references.citation: Comp Med. 2010 Dec;60(6):479-85
references.pmid: 21262135
references.citation: Seizure. 2011 Jun;20(5):359-68
references.pmid: 21292505
references.citation: Mult Scler. 2011 Jun;17(6):647-57
references.pmid: 21372117
references.citation: Curr Opin Neurol. 2011 Jun;24(3):291-9
references.pmid: 21519255
references.citation: J Cell Sci. 2011 Jul 1;124(Pt 13):2267-76
references.pmid: 21652627
references.citation: Vet J. 2012 Apr;192(1):13-9
references.pmid: 21703888
references.citation: Drug Discov Today. 2011 Aug;16(15-16):659-70
references.pmid: 21723955
references.citation: Dis Model Mech. 2012 Jan;5(1):115-24
references.pmid: 21876211
references.citation: Br J Pharmacol. 2012 Mar;165(6):1848-1867
references.pmid: 21913900
references.citation: Exp Biol Med (Maywood). 2011 Oct;236(10):1218-30
references.pmid: 21917592
references.citation: Methods Mol Biol. 2012;788:21-8
references.pmid: 22130697
references.citation: Methods Mol Biol. 2012;817:231-50
references.pmid: 22147576
references.citation: J Med Primatol. 2012 Apr;41(2):89-106
references.pmid: 22150842
references.citation: Comp Med. 2011 Aug;61(4):356-60
references.pmid: 22330251
references.citation: BMC Biol. 2012 Mar 22;10:29
references.pmid: 22439642
references.citation: Nature. 2012 Mar 28;483(7391):531-3
references.pmid: 22460880
references.citation: PLoS One. 2012;7(4):e35656
references.pmid: 22558191
references.citation: Lab Anim. 2012 Jul;46(3):178-92
references.pmid: 22577153
references.citation: Dev Biol (Basel). 2012;134:45-50
references.pmid: 22888594
references.citation: PLoS One. 2012;7(9):e44437
references.pmid: 22970216
references.citation: Dis Model Mech. 2012 Nov;5(6):718-25
references.pmid: 23115201
references.citation: Xenotransplantation. 2013 Jan-Feb;20(1):5-17
references.pmid: 23190260
references.citation: Xenotransplantation. 2013 Jan-Feb;20(1):2-4
references.pmid: 23297811
references.citation: Expert Opin Drug Discov. 2013 Apr;8(4):363-8
references.pmid: 23373702
references.citation: Bull Exp Biol Med. 2013 Feb;154(4):497-500
references.pmid: 23486590
references.citation: Regul Toxicol Pharmacol. 2013 Jun;66(1):88-103
references.pmid: 23524271
references.citation: J Med Primatol. 2013 Jun;42(3):165-8
references.pmid: 23802316
references.citation: Biochem Pharmacol. 2014 Jan 1;87(1):121-30
references.pmid: 23811309
references.citation: Biochem Pharmacol. 2014 Jan 1;87(1):140-9
references.pmid: 23811310
references.citation: Biochem Pharmacol. 2014 Jan 1;87(1):150-61
references.pmid: 23817077
references.citation: Biochem Pharmacol. 2014 Jan 1;87(1):131-9
references.pmid: 23831953
references.citation: Biochem Pharmacol. 2014 Jan 1;87(1):162-71
references.pmid: 23954708
references.citation: PLoS One. 2013 Nov 04;8(11):e79188
references.pmid: 24223903
references.citation: Nat Rev Neurol. 2014 Jan;10(1):37-43
references.pmid: 24247324
references.citation: J Inflamm (Lond). 2012 Sep 06;10 Suppl 1:I1-P41
references.pmid: 24507418
references.citation: Br J Pharmacol. 2014 Jun;171(12):2951-63
references.pmid: 24527763
references.citation: Rev Sci Tech. 2014 Apr;33(1):265-72
references.pmid: 25000799
references.citation: Rev Sci Tech. 2014 Apr;33(1):273-80
references.pmid: 25000800
references.citation: Altern Lab Anim. 2014 Jun;42(3):181-99
references.pmid: 25068930
references.citation: Clin Sci (Lond). 2015 Feb;128(4):235-56
references.pmid: 25328010
references.citation: Br Vet J. 1986 Nov-Dec;142(6):524-6
references.pmid: 3594185
references.citation: Lab Anim. 1980 Jul;14(3):267-74
references.pmid: 7191933
references.citation: Environ Health Perspect. 1996 Aug;104(8):878-80
references.pmid: 8875163