title: Recruitment strategies should not be randomly selected: empirically improving recruitment success and diversity in developmental psychology research.
abstract: Psychological and developmental research have been critiqued for the lack of diversity of research samples. Because differences in culture, race, and ethnicity can influence participant behavior, limited diversity limits the generalizability of the findings. These differences may also impact how participants behave in response to recruitment attempts, which suggests that recruitment itself may be leveraged to increase sample diversity. The goal of the current study was to determine what factors, within a recruitment interaction, could be leveraged to increase success and diversity when recruiting families with children for developmental research. Study 1 found three factors influenced success: (1) recruitment was more successful when other potential participants were also interested (i.e., recruiters were busy), (2) recruiters of particular races were more successful than recruiters of other races, and (3) differences in success were related to what the recruiter said to engage the potential participant (i.e., the script). The latter two factors interacted, suggesting some recruiters were using less optimal scripts. To improve success rates, study 2 randomly assigned scripts to recruiters and encouraged them to recruit more vigorously during busy periods. Study 2 found that two factors influenced success: (1) some scripts were more successful than others and (2) we were more successful at recruiting non-White potential participants than White participants. These two interacted, with some scripts being more successful with White and other scripts being more successful with non-White families. This intervention significantly increased recruitment success rate by 8.1% and the overall number of families recruited by 15.3%. These findings reveal that empirically evaluating and tailoring recruitment efforts based on the most successful strategies is effective in boosting diversity through increased participation of children from non-White families.
authors.affiliation: Brain and Early Experiences Laboratory, Department of Psychology, Ryerson University , Toronto, ON, Canada.
authors.forename: Nicole A
authors.initials: NA
authors.lastname: Sugden
authors.affiliation: Brain and Early Experiences Laboratory, Department of Psychology, Ryerson University , Toronto, ON, Canada.
authors.forename: Margaret C
authors.initials: MC
authors.lastname: Moulson
keywords: developmental psychology; diversity; recruitment; research methods; sampling