title: Intimacy and Family Consent: A Confucian Ideal.
abstract: In the West, mainstream bioethicists tend to appreciate intimate relationships as a hindrance to individual autonomy. Scholars have even argued against approaching a mother to donate a kidney to save the life of her child; the request, they claim, is too manipulative and, thereby, violates her autonomy. For Chinese bioethicists, such a moral analysis is absurd. The intimate relationship between mother and child establishes strong mutual obligations. It creates mutual moral responsibilities that often require sacrifices for each other. This paper argues that while aiding others is a moral duty, helping one's family is a much stronger duty and poses no threat to one's autonomy. For Confucianism, empathetic intimate feelings, the heart and mind of ren, rest at the root of morality. It requires that we, as moral beings, assume duties to relieve the suffering of others. The more intimate the relationship the stronger the obligation to assist. The family is a closely knitted moral community. Family members often share living resources, mutual experiences, and a sense of identity. Family members act as a social unit, and, ordinarily, mutual obligations among members have priority over duties to those outside of the family. For Confucian bioethics, family-based consent to medical treatment is regarded as natural and reasonable. Family-based decision making is a taken-for-granted norm of social life. While close family members have priority, Confucianism extends such obligations outward toward members of the extended family and the society at large. There is a general principle of gradation of love, which reflects different degrees of personal intimacy and, therefore, of moral obligation. In this fashion, Confucianism seeks to treat the whole of society as one extended family. Hence, in bioethics, mutual responsibility and family-based consent are regarded as basic principles. Through a series of case discussions, this paper illustrates that atomistic individual-based autonomy offers but a poor response to bioethical issues.
authors.affiliation: National Central University, Chungli, Taiwan, Republic of China. shuiclee@ncu.edu.tw.
authors.forename: Shui Chuen
authors.initials: SC
authors.lastname: Lee
mesh_terms: D026688:Bioethical Issues; D002681:China; D032903:Confucianism / Q000523:psychology*; D003469:Culture; D003657:Decision Making; D005190:Family / Q000208:ethnology*; D005195:Family Relations; D006801:Humans; D007258:Informed Consent / Q000523:psychology*; D009014:Morals; D026684:Personal Autonomy; D010686:Philosophy, Medical
keywords: Confucianism; autonomy; bioethics; family consent; intimacy