Modeling elephant-mediated cascading effects of water point closure.
Wildlife management to reduce the impact of wildlife on their habitat can be done in several ways, among which removing animals (by either culling or translocation) is most often used. There are, however, alternative ways to control wildlife densities, such as opening or closing water points. The effects of these alternatives are poorly studied. In this paper, we focus on manipulating large herbivores through the closure of water points (WPs). Removal of artificial WPs has been suggested in order to change the distribution of African elephants, which occur in high densities in national parks in Southern Africa and are thought to have a destructive effect on the vegetation. Here, we modeled the long-term effects of different scenarios of WP closure on the spatial distribution of elephants, and consequential effects on the vegetation and other herbivores in Kruger National Park, South Africa. Using a dynamic ecosystem model, SAVANNA, scenarios were evaluated that varied in availability of artificial WPs; levels of natural water; and elephant densities. Our modeling results showed that elephants can indirectly negatively affect the distributions of meso-mixed feeders, meso-browsers, and some meso-grazers under wet conditions. The closure of artificial WPs hardly had any effect during these natural wet conditions. Under dry conditions, the spatial distribution of both elephant bulls and cows changed when the availability of artificial water was severely reduced in the model. These changes in spatial distribution triggered changes in the spatial availability of woody biomass over the simulation period of 80 years, and this led to changes in the rest of the herbivore community, resulting in increased densities of all herbivores, except for giraffe and steenbok, in areas close to rivers. The spatial distributions of elephant bulls and cows showed to be less affected by the closure of WPs than most of the other herbivore species. Our study contributes to ecologically informed decisions in wildlife management. The results from this modeling exercise imply that long-term effects of this intervention strategy should always be investigated at an ecosystem scale.
Jelle P
JP
Hilbers
Frank
F
Van Langevelde
Herbert H T
HH
Prins
C C
CC
Grant
Mike J S
MJ
Peel
Michael B
MB
Coughenour
Henrik J
HJ
De Knegt
Rob
R
Slotow
Izak P J
IP
Smit
Greg A
GA
Kiker
Willem F
WF
De Boer
D000818:Animals; D003198:Computer Simulation; D003247:Conservation of Natural Resources / Q000379:methods*; D017753:Ecosystem; D004606:Elephants; D008954:Models, Biological; D010944:Plants / Q000145:classification; D011156:Population Density; D011157:Population Dynamics; D014867:Water
D014867:Water