title: Sequence Data, Phylogenetic Inference, and Implications of Downward Causation.
abstract: Framing systematics as a field consistent with scientific inquiry entails that inferences of phylogenetic hypotheses have the goal of producing accounts of past causal events that explain differentially shared characters among organisms. Linking observations of characters to inferences occurs by way of why-questions implied by data matrices. Because of their form, why-questions require the use of common-cause theories. Such theories in phylogenetic inferences include natural selection and genetic drift. Selection or drift can explain 'morphological' characters but selection cannot be causally applied to sequences since fitness differences cannot be directly associated with individual nucleotides or amino acids. The relation of selection to sequence data is by way of downward or top-down causation from those phenotypes upon which selection occurs. The application of phylogenetic inference to explain sequence data is thus restricted to instances where drift is the relevant theory; those nucleotides or amino acids that can be explained via downward causation are precluded from inclusion in the data matrix. The restrictions on the inclusion of sequence data in phylogenetic inferences equally apply to species hypotheses, precluding the more restrictive approach known as DNA barcoding. Not being able to discern drift and selection as relevant causal mechanisms can severely constrain the inclusion and explanations of sequence data. Implications of such exclusion are discussed in relation to the requirement of total evidence.
authors.affiliation: Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County, 900 Exposition Blvd, Los Angeles, CA, 90007, USA. kfitzhug@nhm.org.
authors.forename: Kirk
authors.initials: K
authors.lastname: Fitzhugh
mesh_terms: D000818:Animals; D002965:Classification / Q000379:methods*; D019143:Evolution, Molecular; D006801:Humans; D009711:Nucleotides / Q000235:genetics*; D010802:Phylogeny; D017422:Sequence Analysis, DNA / Q000379:methods*
chemical_list: D009711:Nucleotides
keywords: Abductive reasoning; Cladogram; DNA barcoding; Systematics; Top-down causation