Cost effectiveness of meniscal allograft for torn discoid lateral meniscus in young women.
OBJECTIVE
A discoid meniscus is more prone to tears than a normal meniscus. Patients with a torn discoid lateral meniscus are at increased risk for early onset osteoarthritis requiring total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Optimal management for this condition is controversial given the up-front cost difference between the two treatment options: the more expensive meniscal allograft transplantation compared with standard partial meniscectomy. We hypothesize that meniscal allograft transplantation following excision of a torn discoid lateral meniscus is more cost-effective compared with partial meniscectomy alone because allografts will extend the time to TKA.


METHODS
A decision analytic Markov model was created to compare the cost effectiveness of two treatments for symptomatic, torn discoid lateral meniscus: meniscal allograft and partial meniscectomy. Probability estimates and event rates were derived from the scientific literature, and costs and benefits were discounted by 3%. One-way sensitivity analyses were performed to test model robustness.


RESULTS
Over 25 years, the partial meniscectomy strategy cost $10,430, whereas meniscal allograft cost on average $4040 more, at $14,470. Partial meniscectomy postponed TKA an average of 12.5 years, compared with 17.30 years for meniscal allograft, an increase of 4.8 years. Allograft cost $842 per-year-gained in time to TKA.


CONCLUSIONS
Meniscal allografts have been shown to reduce pain and improve function in patients with discoid lateral meniscus tears. Though more costly, meniscal allografts may be more effective than partial meniscectomy in delaying TKA in this model. Additional future long term clinical studies will provide more insight into optimal surgical options.
a Department of Orthopaedic Surgery , New York University Hospital for Joint Diseases , New York , NY , USA.
Austin J
AJ
Ramme
a Department of Orthopaedic Surgery , New York University Hospital for Joint Diseases , New York , NY , USA.
Eric J
EJ
Strauss
a Department of Orthopaedic Surgery , New York University Hospital for Joint Diseases , New York , NY , USA.
Laith
L
Jazrawi
a Department of Orthopaedic Surgery , New York University Hospital for Joint Diseases , New York , NY , USA.|b Department of Population Health , New York University School of Medicine , New York , NY , USA.
Heather T
HT
Gold
D000328:Adult; D064591:Allografts; D019645:Arthroplasty, Replacement, Knee / Q000706:statistics & numerical data; D003362:Cost-Benefit Analysis; D005260:Female; D005500:Follow-Up Studies; D006801:Humans; D008297:Male; D008390:Markov Chains; D008592:Menisci, Tibial / Q000601:surgery; D000072600:Meniscus / Q000637:transplantation*; D000070600:Tibial Meniscus Injuries / Q000601:surgery*; D014481:United States
Discoid meniscus; Markov model; cost-effectiveness analysis; meniscal allograft transplantation; partial meniscectomy