Which Is Better? "Live" Surgical Broadcasts vs "As-Live" Surgical Broadcasts.
Recently, the role of "live" surgical broadcasts (LSB) as an educational tool to demonstrate surgical techniques at conferences has been challenged, with concerns surrounding the well-being and safety of the patient as well as the surgeon. There have been notions that "as-live" surgical broadcasts (ALSB), prerecorded unedited videos showing either the whole procedure or key features, may be educationally superior. Our study was hence conducted to determine which was deemed better by a diverse group of international urologists.



All participants of the World Congress of Endourology held in October 2015 in London were invited to complete an electronic survey using the conference app regarding LSB demonstrations compared with ASLB, before the congress and again after the congress. Only ALSB videos were used in the congress.



Both pre- and postconference surveys showed that 76.9% and 78.2% of the participants, respectively, perceived that more teaching could be achieved in less time using ASLB. 52.8% and 60.3% of respondents indicated ALSB as being superior to LSB before and after the conference, respectively. Furthermore, 52.8% and 54.5% of respondents regarded ALSB videos as having more educational value than LSB before and after the conference, respectively.



There was little perceived difference between ALSB and LSB, showing that ALSB are at least noninferior as an educational tool. In view of the numerous ethical and logistical issues with LSB, we would advocate ASLB as the educational tool of choice for future surgical demonstration at conferences.
1 Department of Urology, East Surrey Hospital , Redhill, United Kingdom .
Yih Chyn
YC
Phan
1 Department of Urology, East Surrey Hospital , Redhill, United Kingdom .
Surayne
S
Segaran
2 Department of Urology, Addenbrooke's Hospital , Cambridge, United Kingdom .
Oliver
O
Wiseman
1 Department of Urology, East Surrey Hospital , Redhill, United Kingdom .
Philip
P
James
3 Department of Urology, University of California , Orange, California.
Ralph
R
Clayman
4 The Arthur Smith Institute for Urology , New Hyde Park, New York.
Arthur
A
Smith
1 Department of Urology, East Surrey Hospital , Redhill, United Kingdom .
Abhay
A
Rane
D001291:Attitude of Health Personnel; D004502:Education, Medical, Continuing / Q000379:methods*; D006801:Humans; D008131:London; D012449:Safety; D013520:Urologic Surgical Procedures / Q000193:education*; D014572:Urology / Q000193:education*; D014741:Video Recording