title: Specialist pollinators deplete pollen in the spring ephemeral wildflower Claytonia virginica.
abstract: Pollinators that collect pollen - and specifically, pollen-specialist bees - are often considered to be the best pollinators of a (host) plant. Although pollen collectors and pollen specialists often benefit host plants, especially in the pollen that they deliver (their pollination "effectiveness"), they can also exact substantial costs because they are motivated to collect as much pollen as possible, reducing the proportion of pollen removed that is subsequently delivered to stigmas (their pollination "efficiency"). From the plant perspective, pollen grains that do not pollinate conspecific stigmas are "wasted", and potentially costly. We measured costs and benefits of nectar-collecting, pollen-collecting, and pollen-specialist pollinator visitation to the spring ephemeral Claytonia virginica. Visits by the pollen-specialist bee Andrena erigeniae depleted pollen quickly and thoroughly. Although all pollinators delivered roughly the same number of grains, the pollen specialist contributed most to C. virginica pollen delivery because of high visitation rates. However, the pollen specialist also removed a large number of grains; this removal may be especially costly because it resulted in the depletion of pollen grains in C. virginica populations. While C. virginica appears to rely on pollen transfer by the pollen specialist in these populations, nectar-collecting visitors could provide the same benefit at a lower cost if their visitation rates increased. Pollen depletion affects a pollinator's value to plants, but is frequently overlooked. If they lower the effectiveness of future floral visitors, visits by A. erigeniae females to C. virginica may be more detrimental than beneficial compared to other pollinators and may, in some circumstances, reduce plant fitness rather than increase it. Therefore, A. erigeniae and C. virginica may vary in their degree of mutualism depending on the ecological context.
authors.affiliation: University of Toronto 25 Harbord Street Toronto ON M5S 3G5 Canada.
authors.forename: Alison J
authors.initials: AJ
authors.lastname: Parker
authors.affiliation: University of California-Davis 380 Briggs Hall One Shields Ave. Davis California 95616.
authors.forename: Neal M
authors.initials: NM
authors.lastname: Williams
authors.affiliation: University of Toronto 25 Harbord Street Toronto ON M5S 3G5 Canada.
authors.forename: James D
authors.initials: JD
authors.lastname: Thomson
keywords: Fly pollination; oligolectic bees; plant–pollinator specialization and generalization; pollen collectors; pollination