title: Uncertainty of measurement and clinical value of semen analysis: has standardisation through professional guidelines helped or hindered progress?
abstract: This article suggests that diagnostic semen analysis has no more clinical value today than it had 25-30 years ago, and both the confusion surrounding its evidence base (in terms of relationship with conception) and the low level of confidence in the clinical setting is attributable to an associated high level of 'uncertainty'. Consideration of the concept of measurement uncertainty is mandatory for medical laboratories applying for the ISO15189 standard. It is evident that the entire semen analysis process is prone to error every step from specimen collection to the reporting of results and serves to compound uncertainty associated with diagnosis or prognosis. Perceived adherence to published guidelines for the assessment of sperm concentration, motility and morphology does not guarantee a reliable and reproducible test result. Moreover, the high level of uncertainty associated with manual sperm motility and morphology can be attributed to subjectivity and lack a traceable standard. This article describes where and why uncertainty exists and suggests that semen analysis will continue to be of limited value until it is more adequately considered and addressed. Although professional guidelines for good practice have provided the foundations for testing procedures for many years, the risk in following rather prescriptive guidance to the letter is that unless they are based on an overwhelmingly firm evidence base, the quality of semen analysis will remain poor and the progress towards the development of more innovative methods for investigating male infertility will be slow.
authors.affiliation: Fertility Unit, Nottingham University Hospital, Nottingham, UK.
authors.forename: M J
authors.initials: MJ
authors.lastname: Tomlinson
mesh_terms: D048430:Cell Shape; D017408:Guidelines as Topic; D006801:Humans; D007248:Infertility, Male / Q000175:diagnosis*; D008297:Male; D055101:Semen Analysis / Q000592:standards*; D013076:Sperm Count; D013081:Sperm Motility; D013094:Spermatozoa / Q000166:cytology*
keywords: accreditation; infertility; semen analysis; sperm quality parameters; uncertainty