title: Comparison of ribotyping and sequence-based typing for discriminating among isolates of Bordetella bronchiseptica.
abstract: PvuII ribotyping and MLST are each highly discriminatory methods for genotyping Bordetella bronchiseptica, but a direct comparison between these approaches has not been undertaken. The goal of this study was to directly compare the discriminatory power of PvuII ribotyping and MLST, using a single set of geographically and genetically diverse strains, and to determine whether subtyping based on repeat region sequences of the pertactin gene (prn) provides additional resolution. One hundred twenty-two isolates were analyzed, representing 11 mammalian or avian hosts, sourced from the United States, Europe, Israel and Australia. Thirty-two ribotype patterns were identified; one isolate could not be typed. In comparison, all isolates were typeable by MLST and a total of 30 sequence types was identified. An analysis based on Simpson's Index of Diversity (SID) revealed that ribotyping and MLST are nearly equally discriminatory, with SIDs of 0.920 for ribotyping and 0.919 for MLST. Nonetheless, for ten ribotypes and eight MLST sequence types, the alternative method discriminates among isolates that otherwise type identically. Pairing prn repeat region typing with ribotyping yielded 54 genotypes and increased the SID to 0.954. Repeat region typing combined with MLST resulted in 47 genotypes and an SID of 0.944. Given the technical and practical advantages of MLST over ribotyping, and the nominal difference in their SIDs, we conclude MLST is the preferred primary typing tool. We recommend the combination of MLST and prn repeat region typing as a high-resolution, objective and standardized approach valuable for investigating the population structure and epidemiology of B. bronchiseptica.
authors.affiliation: Ruminant Diseases and Immunology Research Unit, USDA/Agricultural Research Service/National Animal Disease Center, 1920 Dayton Avenue, Ames, IA 50010, United States. Electronic address: karen.register@ars.usda.gov.
authors.forename: Karen B
authors.initials: KB
authors.lastname: Register
authors.affiliation: Virus and Prion Research Unit, USDA/Agricultural Research Service/National Animal Disease Center, 1920 Dayton Avenue, Ames, IA 50010, United States.
authors.forename: Tracy L
authors.initials: TL
authors.lastname: Nicholson
authors.affiliation: Food Safety and Enteric Pathogens Research Unit, USDA/Agricultural Research Service/National Animal Disease Center, 1920 Dayton Avenue, Ames, IA 50010, United States.
authors.forename: Brian W
authors.initials: BW
authors.lastname: Brunelle
mesh_terms: D001315:Australia; D001425:Bacterial Outer Membrane Proteins / Q000235:genetics; D001885:Bordetella Infections / Q000382:microbiology; D016950:Bordetella bronchiseptica / Q000145:classification* / Q000235:genetics* / Q000276:immunology / Q000302:isolation & purification; D005060:Europe; D005838:Genotype; D058885:Multilocus Sequence Typing / Q000592:standards*; D010802:Phylogeny; D021521:Ribotyping; D010566:Virulence Factors, Bordetella / Q000235:genetics
chemical_list: D001425:Bacterial Outer Membrane Proteins; D010566:Virulence Factors, Bordetella; C068929:pertactin
keywords: Bordetella bronchiseptica; MLST; Pertactin; Ribotyping; pubMLST