Lynn White Jr. and the greening-of-religion hypothesis.
Lynn White Jr.'s "The Historical Roots of Our Ecologic Crisis," which was published in Science in 1967, has played a critical role in precipitating interdisciplinary environmental studies. Although White advances a multifaceted argument, most respondents focus on his claim that the Judeo-Christian tradition, especially Christianity, has promoted anthropocentric attitudes and environmentally destructive behaviors. Decades later, some scholars argue contrarily that Christianity in particular and the world's predominant religions in general are becoming more environmentally friendly, known as the greening-of-religion hypothesis. To test these claims, we conducted a comprehensive review of over 700 articles-historical, qualitative, and quantitative-that are pertinent to them. Although definitive conclusions are difficult, we identified many themes and dynamics that hinder environmental understanding and mobilization, including conservative theological orientations and beliefs about the role of divine agency in preventing or promoting natural events, whether the religion is an Abrahamic tradition or originated in Asia. On balance, we found the thrust of White's thesis is supported, whereas the greening-of-religion hypothesis is not. We also found that indigenous traditions often foster proenvironmental perceptions. This finding suggests that indigenous traditions may be more likely to be proenvironmental than other religious systems and that some nature-based cosmologies and value systems function similarly. Although we conclude White's thesis and subsequent claims are largely born out, additional research is needed to better understand under what circumstances and communication strategies religious or other individuals and groups may be more effectively mobilized to respond to contemporary environmental challenges.
University of Florida, 107 Anderson Hall, PO Box 117410, Gainesville, FL, 32611-7410, U.S.A.
Bron
B
Taylor
Michigan State University, 714 Wells Hall, East Lansing, MI, 48824, U.S.A.
Gretel
G
Van Wieren
University of California, Santa Cruz, PO Box 7579, Santa Cruz, CA, 95061-7579, U.S.A.. dzaleha@ucsc.edu.
Bernard Daley
BD
Zaleha
D001208:Asia; D001290:Attitude; D002835:Christianity; D003142:Communication; D003247:Conservation of Natural Resources; D006801:Humans; D012067:Religion
nature religions; religion and ecology; religiones de la naturaleza; religión y ecología