Validation of RNAi Silencing Efficiency Using Gene Array Data shows 18.5% Failure Rate across 429 Independent Experiments.
No independent cross-validation of success rate for studies utilizing small interfering RNA (siRNA) for gene silencing has been completed before. To assess the influence of experimental parameters like cell line, transfection technique, validation method, and type of control, we have to validate these in a large set of studies. We utilized gene chip data published for siRNA experiments to assess success rate and to compare methods used in these experiments. We searched NCBI GEO for samples with whole transcriptome analysis before and after gene silencing and evaluated the efficiency for the target and off-target genes using the array-based expression data. Wilcoxon signed-rank test was used to assess silencing efficacy and Kruskal-Wallis tests and Spearman rank correlation were used to evaluate study parameters. All together 1,643 samples representing 429 experiments published in 207 studies were evaluated. The fold change (FC) of down-regulation of the target gene was above 0.7 in 18.5% and was above 0.5 in 38.7% of experiments. Silencing efficiency was lowest in MCF7 and highest in SW480 cells (FC = 0.59 and FC = 0.30, respectively, P = 9.3E-06). Studies utilizing Western blot for validation performed better than those with quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) or microarray (FC = 0.43, FC = 0.47, and FC = 0.55, respectively, P = 2.8E-04). There was no correlation between type of control, transfection method, publication year, and silencing efficiency. Although gene silencing is a robust feature successfully cross-validated in the majority of experiments, efficiency remained insufficient in a significant proportion of studies. Selection of cell line model and validation method had the highest influence on silencing proficiency.
MTA TTK Lendület Cancer Biomarker Research Group, Budapest, Hungary.|MTA-SE Pediatrics and Nephrology Research Group, Budapest, Hungary.
Gyöngyi
G
Munkácsy
Second Department of Pediatrics, Semmelweis University, Budapest, Hungary.
Zsófia
Z
Sztupinszki
MTA TTK Lendület Cancer Biomarker Research Group, Budapest, Hungary.
Péter
P
Herman
Second Department of Pediatrics, Semmelweis University, Budapest, Hungary.
Bence
B
Bán
MTA TTK Lendület Cancer Biomarker Research Group, Budapest, Hungary.
Zsófia
Z
Pénzváltó
MTA TTK Lendület Cancer Biomarker Research Group, Budapest, Hungary.
Nóra
N
Szarvas
MTA TTK Lendület Cancer Biomarker Research Group, Budapest, Hungary.|Second Department of Pediatrics, Semmelweis University, Budapest, Hungary.
Balázs
B
Győrffy
Nucleic Acids Res. 2002 Apr 15;30(8):1757-66
11937629
Nature. 2010 Apr 15;464(7291):1067-70
20305636
Silence. 2010 Jul 08;1(1):14
20615220
BMC Bioinformatics. 2009 Nov 30;10:392
19948054
Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2012 Apr;132(3):1025-34
21773767
Nat Biotechnol. 2006 Sep;24(9):1151-61
16964229
Cell. 2000 Mar 31;101(1):25-33
10778853
Nucleic Acids Res. 2011 Jan;39(Database issue):D685-90
21071392
RNA. 2006 Jul;12(7):1197-205
16682562
Nat Biotechnol. 2005 Nov;23(11):1440-4
16258545
BMC Bioinformatics. 2011 Dec 15;12:474
22172014
Mol Med Rep. 2015 Oct;12(4):5601
26238072
EMBO Rep. 2001 Nov;2(11):986-91
11713189
Genome Res. 2009 Jan;19(1):92-105
18955434
Gene Ther. 2006 Feb;13(3):225-34
16195704
Cell. 2005 Aug 26;122(4):553-63
16122423
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011 Sep 6;108(36):15010
21821790
Orv Hetil. 2007 Nov 25;148(47):2235-40
18003582
Nucleic Acids Res. 2013 Jan 7;41(1):e9
22941647
Cancer Discov. 2013 Apr;3(4):406-17
23358650
Br J Cancer. 2011 Jan 4;104(1):227
21206499
BMC Genomics. 2016 Jan 05;17 :20
26728506
Nat Rev Drug Discov. 2010 Jan;9(1):57-67
20043028
Br J Cancer. 2010 Jan 19;102(2):361-8
20010949
Nat Biotechnol. 2003 Jun;21(6):635-7
12754523
Oncotarget. 2015 Aug 28;6(25):21603-13
26057633
PLoS One. 2009 May 21;4(5):e5645
19461970
Curr Genomics. 2010 May;11(3):162-7
21037854
Methods Mol Biol. 2013;942:57-68
23027045
Nature. 2010 Nov 25;468(7323):487
21107398
Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol. 2012 May 1;302(9):L976
22549970