The Inclusion of Ethnic Minority Patients and the Role of Language in Telehealth Trials for Type 2 Diabetes: A Systematic Review.
BACKGROUND
Type 2 diabetes is a serious, pervasive metabolic condition that disproportionately affects ethnic minority patients. Telehealth interventions can facilitate type 2 diabetes monitoring and prevent secondary complications. However, trials designed to test the effectiveness of telehealth interventions may underrecruit or exclude ethnic minority patients, with language a potential barrier to recruitment. The underrepresentation of minorities in trials limits the external validity of the findings for this key patient demographic.


OBJECTIVE
This systematic review examines (1) the research reporting practices and prevalence of ethnic minority patients included in telehealth randomized controlled trials (RCTs) targeting type 2 diabetes and the trial characteristics associated with recruiting a high proportion of minority patients, and (2) the proportion of included RCTs that report using English language proficiency as a patient screening criterion and how and why they do so.


METHODS
Telehealth RCTs published in refereed journals targeting type 2 diabetes as a primary condition for adults in Western majority English-speaking countries were included. Ethnically targeted RCTs were excluded from the main review, but were included in a post hoc subgroup analysis. Abstract and full-text screening, risk of bias assessment, and data extraction were independently conducted by two reviewers.


RESULTS
Of 3358 records identified in the search, 79 articles comprising 58 RCTs were included. Nearly two-thirds of the RCTs (38/58) reported on the ethnic composition of participants, with a median proportion of 23.5% patients (range 0%-97.7%). Fourteen studies (24%) that included at least 30% minority patients were all US-based, predominantly recruited from urban areas, and described the target population as underserved, financially deprived, or uninsured. Eight of these 14 studies (57%) offered intervention materials in a language other than English or employed bilingual staff. Half of all identified RCTs (29/58) included language proficiency as a participant-screening criterion. Language proficiency was operationalized using nonstandardized measures (eg, having sufficient "verbal fluency"), with only three studies providing reasons for excluding patients on language grounds.


CONCLUSIONS
There was considerable variability across studies in the inclusion of ethnic minority patients in RCTs, with higher participation rates in countries with legislation to mandate their inclusion (eg, United States) than in those without such legislation (eg, United Kingdom). Less than 25% of the RCTs recruited a sizeable proportion of ethnic minorities, which raises concerns about external validity. The lack of objective measures or common procedures for assessing language proficiency across trials implies that language-related eligibility decisions are often based on trial recruiters' impressionistic judgments, which could be subject to bias. The variability and inconsistent reporting on ethnicity and other socioeconomic factors in descriptions of research participants could be more specifically emphasized in trial reporting guidelines to promote best practice.


BACKGROUND
PROSPERO International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews: CRD42015024899; http://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/display_record.asp?ID=CRD42015024899 (Archived by WebCite at http://www.webcitation.org/6kQmI2bdF).
University of Bristol, Graduate School of Education, Bristol, United Kingdom. talia.isaacs@bristol.ac.uk.
Talia
http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4302-3379
T
Isaacs
Daniel
http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0755-7015
D
Hunt
Danielle
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-9422-3277
D
Ward
Leila
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-6166-6055
L
Rooshenas
Louisa
http://orcid.org/0000-0001-9371-2805
L
Edwards
English proficiency; diabetes mellitus; ethnic minorities; health communication; language; systematic review; telehealth; telemedicine; trial recruitment; type 2 diabetes
Diabetes Obes Metab. 2009 Oct;11(10):913-30
19531058
J Gen Intern Med. 2006 Feb;21(2):105-10
16390512
J Nutr Health Aging. 2011 Jun;15(6):445-9
21623465
Diabetes Care. 2014 Apr;37(4):1060-8
24550221
Telemed J E Health. 2010 Jan-Feb;16(1):93-5
20043711
Diabetes Care. 2007 May;30(5):1266-8
17325261
Can J Diabetes. 2013 Oct;37(5):305-8
24500556
Telemed J E Health. 2014 Mar;20(3):199-205
24404819
PLoS One. 2013;8(1):e55580
23383233
Trials. 2014 Jan 06;15:5
24393291
Diabetologia. 2010 May;53(5):832-9
20084363
J Am Pharm Assoc (2003). 2012;52(6):753-62
23229961
Arch Intern Med. 2009 Oct 26;169(19):1788-94
19858437
BMC Public Health. 2009 Jan 12;9:12
19138392
J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2009 Jul-Aug;16(4):446-56
19390093
Diabetes Care. 2009 Feb;32(2):234-9
19017773
Chronic Illn. 2013 Dec;9(4):258-67
23585636
Perm J. 2009 Fall;13(4):79-84
20740108
Postgrad Med J. 2005 Mar;81(953):141-7
15749788
J Diabetes Metab Disord. 2015 Jun 03;14:49
26075190
BMC Public Health. 2012 Aug 03;12:602
22857017
CMAJ. 2009 Jul 7;181(1-2):37-44
19581618
Diabetes Care. 2001 Aug;24(8):1328-34
11473065
BMJ. 2013 Sep 18;347:f5272
24048296
Diabetes Technol Ther. 2010 Mar;12(3):213-20
20151772
Diabetes Care. 2010 Aug;33(8):1738-40
20668152
Arch Intern Med. 2011 Dec 12;171(22):2011-7
21986347
Cancer. 2008 Jan 15;112(2):228-42
18008363
Diabetes Educ. 2014 May;40(3):361-372
24676274
Diabetes Care. 2011 Sep;34(9):1934-42
21788632
Ther Clin Risk Manag. 2007 Jun;3(3):485-9
18488079
JMIR Res Protoc. 2016 Mar 11;5(1):e43
26969340
Diabetes Educ. 2014 Jul;40(4):516-525
24742540
J Acad Nutr Diet. 2012 Aug;112(8):1147-57
22818724
J Gen Intern Med. 2010 Dec;25(12):1315-22
20714820
Prev Med. 2014 Mar;60:33-40
24345601
Ethn Health. 2013;18(1):83-96
22762449
Br J Gen Pract. 2014 Aug;64(625):417-9
25071053
J Telemed Telecare. 2009;15(2):95-7
19246610
BMC Health Serv Res. 2015 Sep 10;15:371
26357948
Ann Intern Med. 2012 Mar 20;156(6):416-24
22431674
Diabetes Care. 2008 Mar;31(3):408-14
18096810
BMC Med Res Methodol. 2014 Mar 25;14:42
24669751
J Med Internet Res. 2014 May 08;16(5):e123
24811914
Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2009 Mar 27;6:18
19327141
Ethn Dis. 2006 Autumn;16(4):956-62
17061753
Telemed J E Health. 2015 May;21(5):321-54
25806910
Patient Educ Couns. 2009 Apr;75(1):91-8
19013741
Diabetes Care. 2011 Feb;34(2):274-9
21270184
Ethn Dis. 2007 Summer;17(3):515-21
17985507
Diabetes Ther. 2011 Sep;2(3):178-88
22127826
Mil Med. 2000 Aug;165(8):579-84
10957848
J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2006 Jan-Feb;13(1):40-51
16221935
Am J Community Psychol. 2002 Oct;30(5):637-54
12188054
J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2013 May 1;20(3):526-34
23171659
Int J Behav Med. 2014 Feb;21(1):88-98
23385488
Medsurg Nurs. 2014 Jul-Aug;23(4):231-7
25318336
Age Ageing. 2009 Mar;38(2):219-25
19171951
Health Educ Behav. 2008 Oct;35(5):664-82
17513690
Diabetes Care. 2010 Mar;33(3):478-84
20009091
Telemed J E Health. 2011 May;17(4):254-61
21476945
BMC Public Health. 2013 Mar 21;13:252
23517376
Health Soc Care Community. 2012 Jan;20(1):1-19
21749529
Health Technol Assess. 2005 Oct;9(38):iii-iv, ix-x, 1-152
16181564
Patient Educ Couns. 2014 Apr;95(1):111-7
24468198
PLoS Med. 2009 Jul 21;6(7):e1000100
19621070
Am J Manag Care. 2006 Mar;12(3):137-45
16524346
PLoS One. 2013 Nov 08;8(11):e79246
24250826
Patient Educ Couns. 2002 Oct -Nov;48(2):115-22
12401414
Trials. 2015 Jun 05;16:258
26044763
Prev Med. 2003 Apr;36(4):410-9
12649049
Diabetes Care. 2014 Jun;37(6):1759-66
24855158
ANS Adv Nurs Sci. 2009 Jul-Sep;32(3):E42-57
19707086
J Diabetes Sci Technol. 2013 Jan 01;7(1):123-34
23439168
J Med Internet Res. 2015 Apr 29;17(4):e106
25925943
Health Commun. 2011 Sep;26(6):560-70
21512923
Diabetes Care. 2006 Apr;29(4):830-5
16567823
J Hum Nutr Diet. 2010 Aug;23(4):353-9
20497292
Diabetes Care. 2005 Feb;28(2):278-82
15677779
Age Ageing. 2011 Jan;40(1):98-105
21081539
J Eval Clin Pract. 2008 Jun;14(3):465-9
18373577
BMJ. 2015 Feb 24;350:h1026
25712067
Telemed J E Health. 2013 Aug;19(8):643-5
23758078
Am J Public Health. 2013 Oct;103(10):1888-94
23488491
Chronic Illn. 2006 Mar;2(1):27-38
17175680
Diabetes Care. 2012 Jan;35(1):32-8
22100963
Am Heart J. 2013 Jul;166(1):179-86
23816038
J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2012 Nov-Dec;19(6):973-9
22610495
Trials. 2016 May 26;17(1):263
27229153
J Med Internet Res. 2005 Oct 04;7(5):e50
16403714
Diabetes Technol Ther. 2008 Jun;10(3):160-8
18473689
J Med Internet Res. 2010 Feb 10;12(1):e3
20147006
Med Care. 2011 Jul;49(7):641-8
21478777
Health Expect. 2015 Oct;18(5):625-42
23710892
PLoS One. 2013 Dec 16;8(12):e83292
24358273
Health Policy. 2006 Jul;77(2):149-65
16216378
Medicine (Baltimore). 2014 Dec;93(28):e312
25526482
Perspect Health Inf Manag. 2011 Jan 01;8:1b
21307985
Trials. 2014 Aug 13;15:323
25115160
Diabetes Technol Ther. 2012 Nov;14(11):1060-7
22953754
BMC Public Health. 2014 Jan 23;14:71
24450992
J Diabetes Complications. 2014 Mar-Apr;28(2):243-51
24332469
Public Health Rep. 2006 May-Jun;121(3):331-6
16640158
Intern Med J. 2014 Sep;44(9):890-7
24963611
Ann Behav Med. 2006 Apr;31(2):128-37
16542127
Arch Intern Med. 2008 Sep 8;168(16):1776-82
18779465
J Behav Med. 2009 Aug;32(4):349-59
19365719
Diabetes Care. 2010 Aug;33(8):1712-7
20484125
Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2007 Nov 16;4:59
18021411
Diabetes Res Clin Pract. 2012 Jan;95(1):62-7
21992869
Trans Am Clin Climatol Assoc. 2007;118:289-304
18528511
Patient Educ Couns. 2012 Apr;87(1):81-92
21924576
Diabetes Care. 2011 Jan;34(1):2-7
21193619
Diabetes Res Clin Pract. 2014 Dec;106(3):481-6
25458333
Ann Intern Med. 2014 Nov 18;161(10 Suppl):S13-22
25402398
Diabetes Res Clin Pract. 2014 Nov;106(2):200-11
25043399
Int J Methods Psychiatr Res. 2014 Mar;23(1):36-48
24474683
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2013 Dec 03;(12):MR000032
24297482
Ann Intern Med. 2010 Jun 1;152(11):726-32
20335313
BMJ. 2011 Oct 18;343:d5928
22008217
J Med Internet Res. 2012 May 10;14(3):e71
22576226
Med Care. 2000 Nov;38(11):1062-73
11078048
BMJ Open. 2015 Jun 05;5(6):e007599
26048210
Diabetes Care. 2010 Jun;33(6):1275-81
20299481
Chronic Illn. 2011 Dec;7(4):267-78
21840915
Syst Rev. 2013 May 07;2:26
23647654
West J Nurs Res. 2014 Oct;36(9):1052-73
24569698
Ann Behav Med. 2013 Oct;46(2):193-203
23609340
Telemed J E Health. 2012 Oct;18(8):575-9
22873700
Eur J Endocrinol. 2015 Mar;172(3):R93-101
25227131
J Gen Intern Med. 2010 Oct;25(10):1116-22
20556536
Telemed J E Health. 2014 Feb;20(2):109-14
24404816
Ann Emerg Med. 2014 Jun;63(6):745-54.e6
24225332
Am J Med. 2004 Jun 1;116(11):732-9
15144909
Diabetes Care. 2005 Feb;28(2):283-9
15677780