Challenging cognitive cases among physician populations: case vignettes and recommendations.
BACKGROUND
Physicians are not immune to cognitive impairment. Because of the risks created by practising doctors with these issues, some have suggested developing objective, population-specific measures of evaluation and screening guidelines to assess dysfunction. However, there is very little published information from which to construct such resources.


OBJECTIVE
To highlight the presentation characteristics and provide evaluation recommendations specific to the needs of physicians with actual or presumed cognitive impairment.


METHODS
A retrospective database and chart review of cognitively impaired doctors who presented to a physician health programme (PHP). Complex cases were highlighted using simple descriptives and clinical vignettes.


RESULTS
A total of 124 cases were included. Clients presented with a variety of issues other than cognitive concerns. We identified four principal domains of impairment: (i) diseases of (or in) the brain (48%); (ii) mood/ anxiety disorders or treatment side effects (28%); (iii) substance use (9%) and (iv) traumatic brain injury (7%). Age was not a good predictor of impairment and brief screening using the Montreal Cognitive Assessment demonstrated a ceiling effect with this cohort. Although many clients underwent some type of professional or personal transition, impairment did not necessarily indicate worse functioning after care.


CONCLUSIONS
Physician cognitive evaluations should consider a variety of secondary sources of information, particularly vocational performance reports. It may take time before cognitive impairment can be diagnosed or ruled-out in this population. Prior assumptions, especially for non-cognitive referrals, can lead to inaccurate diagnosis and referrals. PHPs must manage cognitive cases carefully, not only in their clinical complexity but also in their psychosocial aspects.
Department of Community & Behavioral Health, School of Public Health, University of Colorado Denver, Aurora, CO, USA, elizabeth.brooks@ucdenver.edu.|Colorado Physician Health Program, Denver, CO, USA.
E
E
Brooks
Colorado Physician Health Program, Denver, CO, USA.
M H
MH
Gendel
Colorado Physician Health Program, Denver, CO, USA.
A L
AL
Parry
Colorado Physician Health Program, Denver, CO, USA.
S
S
Humphreys
Colorado Physician Health Program, Denver, CO, USA.
S R
SR
Early
D003072:Cognition Disorders / Q000175:diagnosis*; D006304:Health Status; D006801:Humans; D008403:Mass Screening / Q000379:methods; D010820:Physicians; D012189:Retrospective Studies
Assessment; cognitive impairment; doctors; evaluation; guidelines; incapacity for work; medical profession; medical retirement.