The full spectrum of climate change adaptation: testing an analytical framework in Tyrolean mountain agriculture (Austria).
Our scientific view on climate change adaptation (CCA) is unsatisfying in many ways: It is often dominated by a modernistic perspective of planned pro-active adaptation, with a selective focus on measures directly responding to climate change impacts and thus it is far from real-life conditions of those who are actually affected by climate change. Farmers have to simultaneously adapt to multiple changes. Therefore, also empirical climate change adaptation research needs a more integrative perspective on real-life climate change adaptations. This also has to consider "hidden" adaptations, which are not explicitly and directly motivated by CCA but actually contribute to the sector's adaptability to climate change. The aim of the present study is to develop and test an analytic framework that contributes to a broader understanding of CCA and to bridge the gap between scientific expertise and practical action. The framework distinguishes three types of CCA according to their climate related motivations: explicit adaptations, multi-purpose adaptations, and hidden adaptations. Although agriculture is among the sectors that are most affected by climate change, results from the case study of Tyrolean mountain agriculture show that climate change is ranked behind other more pressing "real-life-challenges" such as changing agricultural policies or market conditions. We identified numerous hidden adaptations which make a valuable contribution when dealing with climate change impacts. We conclude that these hidden adaptations have not only to be considered to get an integrative und more realistic view on CCA; they also provide a great opportunity for linking adaptation strategies to farmers' realities.
Institute for Sustainable Economic Development, University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences, Vienna, Austria ; alpS GmbH, Innsbruck, Austria.
Heidelinde
H
Grüneis
Institute for Sustainable Economic Development, University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences, Vienna, Austria.
Marianne
M
Penker
alpS GmbH, Innsbruck, Austria ; Institute of Geography, University of Innsbruck, Innsbruck, Austria.
Karl-Michael
KM
Höferl
Autonomous adaptation; Climate change adaptation; Mountain agriculture; Regional adaptation