title: Explanations for adaptations, just-so stories, and limitations on evidence in evolutionary biology.
abstract: Explanations of the historical origin of specific individual traits are a key part of the research program in paleontology and evolutionary biology. Why did bipedalism evolve in the human lineage? Why did some dinosaurs and related species have head crests? Why did viviparity evolve in some reptiles? Why did the common ancestor of primates evolve stereoscopic vision, grasping hands and feet, nails instead of claws, and large brains? These are difficult questions. To varying degrees, an explanation must grapple with (1) judgments about changes in fitness that might follow from a change in morphology - without actually observing behavior or measuring reproductive success, (2) the relationship between genes and traits, (3) limitations on doing relevant experiments, (4) the interpretation of causes that are almost certainly contingent, multifactorial, interactive, hierarchical, nonlinear, emergent, and probabilistic rather than deterministic, (5) limited information about variation and ontogeny, (6) a dataset based on the random fortunes of the historical record, including only partial hard-tissue morphology and no soft-tissue morphology, (7) an equally partial and problematic (for example, time-averaged) record of the environment, (8) the compression of all data into a geological time scale that is likely to miss biologically important events or fluctuations, (9) dependence on a process that can only be inferred ("form and even behavior may leave fossil traces, but forces like natural selection do not",1:130) and finally, (10) the assumption of the "adaptationist programme"2that the trait in question is in fact an adaptation rather than a consequence of genetic drift, correlated evolution, pleiotropy, exaptation, or other mechanisms.
authors.forename: Richard J
authors.initials: RJ
authors.lastname: Smith
mesh_terms: D000818:Animals; D000885:Anthropology, Physical; D005075:Biological Evolution; D006801:Humans; D033262:Narration
keywords: adaptationist program; causation; current utility; historical role; inference to the best explanation; narrative explanation; necessary and sufficient conditions; reverse engineering; underdetermination; unique events