Measuring effectiveness, efficiency and equity in an experimental Payments for Ecosystem Services trial.
There is currently a considerable effort to evaluate the performance of Payments for Ecosystem Services as an environmental management tool. The research presented here contributes to this work by using an experimental design to evaluate Payments for Ecosystem Services as a tool for supporting biodiversity conservation in the context of an African protected area. The trial employed a 'before and after' and 'with and without' design. We present the results of social and ecological surveys to investigate the impacts of the trial in terms of its effectiveness, efficiency and equity. We find the scheme to be effective at bringing about additional conservation outcomes. However, we also found that increased monitoring is similarly effective in the short term, at lower cost. The major difference - and arguably the significant contribution of the Payments for Ecosystem Services - was that it changed the motives for protecting the park and improved local perceptions both of the park and its authority. We discuss the implications of these results for conservation efficiency, arguing that efficiency should not be defined in terms of short-term cost-effectiveness, but also in terms of the sustainability of behavioral motives in the long term. This insight helps us to resolve the apparent trade-off between goals of equity and efficiency in Payments for Ecosystem Services.
University of East Anglia, School of International Development, Norwich NR4 7TJ, United Kingdom.
Adrian
A
Martin
University of East Anglia, School of International Development, Norwich NR4 7TJ, United Kingdom.
Nicole
N
Gross-Camp
University of East Anglia, School of International Development, Norwich NR4 7TJ, United Kingdom.
Bereket
B
Kebede
University of East Anglia, School of International Development, Norwich NR4 7TJ, United Kingdom.
Shawn
S
McGuire
Conservation effectiveness; Conservation incentives; Ecosystem services; Motivation crowding theory; Rwanda