title: Partiality and distributive justice in African bioethics.
abstract: African ethical theories tend to hold that moral agents ought to be partial, in the sense that they should favour members of their family or close community. This is considered an advantage over the impartiality of many Western moral theories, which are regarded as having counterintuitive implications, such as the idea that it is unethical to save a family member before a stranger. The partiality of African ethics is thought to be particularly valuable in the context of bioethics. Thaddeus Metz, in particular, argues that his African-derived theory best accounts for a number of plausible intuitions, such as the intuition that health care practitioners ought to be biased towards the patients for whom they are directly responsible. In this article, I claim that the plausible intuitions drawn on in favour of partiality can be satisfactorily explained on the basis of impartial moral theories. Moreover, I argue that blanket acceptance of partiality has problematic consequences for distributive justice in resource allocation in biomedical contexts. By contrast, impartial theories can justify plausible instances of partiality whilst avoiding the pitfalls of fully partial moral theories. Although this provides grounds for abandoning partiality in principle, I claim that this finding should not be seen as damaging to African medical ethics. Instead, it prompts investigation of underexplored possibilities of impartial African moral theories. To demonstrate the value of this direction, I sketch some novel and attractive conceptions that combine impartiality with elements of African ethics.
authors.affiliation: Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics, University of the Witwatersrand, P.V. Tobias Building, Cnr Carse O'Gowrie and York Road, Parktown, Johannesburg, 2193, South Africa. christopher.wareham@wits.ac.za.
authors.forename: Christopher Simon
authors.initials: CS
authors.lastname: Wareham
mesh_terms: D000349:Africa; D001675:Bioethics; D028663:Ethical Theory; D004992:Ethics, Medical; D006801:Humans; D009014:Morals; D012935:Social Justice
keywords: African ethics; African metaethics; Impartiality; Intuitions; Justice; Moral epistemology