title: Delayed Recognition of Thoracic and Lumbar Vertebral Compression Fractures in Minor Accident Cases.
abstract: Osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures (VCFs) in the elderly are commonly diagnosed after a minor fall or trauma; however, the majority of these patients have either been previously evaluated for osteoporosis or are already under some form of medical treatment for osteoporosis at the time of the fall. Although accidents are a known cause of VCFs, these fractures are too often undiagnosed. In reviewing a group of patients seen after minor falls or automobile accidents who were complaining of general spine pain, we found a smaller subgroup with previously undiagnosed VCFs. These fractures were also the initial signs of a previously unrecognized osteoporotic process. Initial diagnosis, treatment, and therapy were usually focused on other spinal segments (i.e. mainly the lumbar spine) until both the VCF and the osteoporosis were identified. The purpose of this report is to raise awareness and discuss the steps for improved diagnosis of osteoporotic VCFs. A retrospective analysis was conducted on a large group of patients from one pain/accident clinic in a 24 month period. These patients were diagnosed with VCFs subsequent to the initial evaluation due to either persistent pain after conservative therapy or complaints of pain beyond the original injured area (i.e. typically the lumbar spine). At this point, a more detailed history was taken, including any past treatment for osteoporosis, or previous falls or injury to exclude the possibility of pre-existing fractures. A more focused examination of the painful area was completed, consisting of percussion at the fracture site identified on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) or computed tomography (CT) scan. If possible, a bone scan was ordered to separate acute and subacute traumatic fractures from old/chronic fractures. Additionally, we surveyed two other similar pain/accident clinics who saw a comparable number and population of patients diagnosed with VCFs within a 24 month period to make a comparison of the number of VCFs they identified. Ten out of approximately 2700 patients seen over a 24 month period sustained acute thoracic or lumbar VCFs during a minor accident and were not previously diagnosed with osteoporosis. Since approximately 30% of the 2,700 patients had new accidents, 10 out of 800 new patients (1.25%) were found to have VCFs without a known history of osteoporosis. Two other surveyed pain/accident, clinics saw a similar number and population of patients in the same time period; however, each only diagnosed two or three VCFs while examining a similar number of patients in the clinic. In these two other clinics, a much lower percentage (0.3%) of patients were diagnosed with new VCFs. Awareness of the possibility of osteoporotic VCFs is the first step in detecting them. This study reveals the presence of a small but real risk of overlooking osteoporotic VCFs in minor trauma cases. When necessary, repeat or obtain better quality imaging in spinal segments affected by persistent pain. The thoracolumbar junction (i.e. T12 & L1 vertebrae) is especially at risk for sustaining VCFs. The delayed recognition of these VCFs and the patient's underlying osteoporosis after minor accident cases could present a major problem, as the critical time for patients to receive the proper medical or surgical treatments responsible for correcting and preventing further spinal deformity and pain has been reduced.
authors.affiliation: Larkin Hospital, Nova Southeastern University School of Osteopathic Medicine.
authors.forename: Jesse
authors.initials: J
authors.lastname: Hatgis
authors.affiliation: Miami Neurosurgical Center, University of Miami Hospital.
authors.forename: Michelle
authors.initials: M
authors.lastname: Granville
authors.affiliation: Miami Neurosurgical Center, University of Miami Hospital.
authors.forename: Robert E
authors.initials: RE
authors.lastname: Jacobson
keywords: accident clinic; compression fracture; motor vehicle accident; vertebral compression fracture