Diverse patterns of intra-host genetic diversity in chronically infected SARS-CoV-2 patients
In rare individuals with a severely immunocompromised system, chronic infections of SARS-CoV-2 may develop, where the virus replicates in the body for months. Sequencing of some chronic infections has uncovered dramatic adaptive evolution and fixation of mutations reminiscent of lineage-defining mutations of variants of concern (VOCs). This has led to the prevailing hypothesis that VOCs emerged from chronic infections. To examine the mutation dynamics and intra-host genomic diversity of SARS-CoV-2 during chronic infections, we focused on a cohort of nine immunocompromised individuals with chronic infections and performed longitudinal sequencing of viral genomes. We show that sequencing errors may cause erroneous inference of high genetic diversity, and to overcome this we used duplicate sequencing across patients and time-points, allowing us to distinguish errors from low frequency mutations. We further find recurrent low frequency mutations that we flag as most likely sequencing errors. This stringent approach allowed us to reliably infer low frequency mutations and their dynamics across time. We inferred a synonymous divergence rate of the virus of ~2x10-6 mutations/base/day, consistent with the SARS-CoV-2 mutation rate estimated in tissue culture. The rate of non-synonymous divergence varied widely among the different patients. We highlight two patients with opposing patterns: in one patient the rate of divergence was zero, yet this patient harbored multiple presumably defective viruses at low frequencies throughout the infection. Another patient exhibited dramatic adaptive evolution, including clonal competition. Overall, our results suggest that the emergence of highly divergent variants from chronic infections is likely a very rare event and this emphasizes the need to better understand the conditions that allow such emergence events.