ena-STUDY-AALBORG UNIVERSITY-09-05-2018-12:40:40:629-200
Investigation of detection limits and the influence of DNA extraction and primer choice on the observed microbial communities in drinking water samples using 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing.
In recent years, 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing has been widely adopted for analyzing the microbial communities in drinking water. However, no comprehensive attempts have been made to illuminate the inherent method biases specifically relating to drinking water communities. In this study, we investigated the impact of DNA extraction and primer choice on the observed microbial community, and furthermore estimated the detection limit of the 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing in these experimental settings. Of the two DNA extraction kits investigated, the PowerWater DNA Isolation Kit resulted in higher yield, better reproducibility, more OTUs identified, and lower limit of detection compared to the FastDNA SPIN Kit for Soil, which is also commonly used within drinking water microbiome research. The use of three separate primer-sets targeting the V1-3, V3-4 and V4 region of the 16S rRNA gene revealed large differences in OTU abundances, with some of the primers unable to detect entire phyla. Estimations of the detection limit were based on bacteria-free water samples (1 L) spiked with Escherichia coli cells in different concentrations [101 – 106 cells/ml]. E. coli could be detected in all samples, however, samples with ~101 cells/ml had several contaminating OTUs constituting between 8.2 to 46.7% of the read abundances. Based on our findings, we recommend using the PowerWater DNA Isolation Kit for DNA extraction in combination with PCR amplification of the V3-4 region for drinking water samples if a broad overview of the microbial community is to be obtained.
In recent years, 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing has been widely adopted for analyzing the microbial communities in drinking water. However, no comprehensive attempts have been made to illuminate the inherent method biases specifically relating to drinking water communities. In this study, we investigated the impact of DNA extraction and primer choice on the observed microbial community, and furthermore estimated the detection limit of the 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing in these experimental settings. Of the two DNA extraction kits investigated, the PowerWater DNA Isolation Kit resulted in higher yield, better reproducibility, more OTUs identified, and lower limit of detection compared to the FastDNA SPIN Kit for Soil, which is also commonly used within drinking water microbiome research. The use of three separate primer-sets targeting the V1-3, V3-4 and V4 region of the 16S rRNA gene revealed large differences in OTU abundances, with some of the primers unable to detect entire phyla. Estimations of the detection limit were based on bacteria-free water samples (1 L) spiked with Escherichia coli cells in different concentrations [101 – 106 cells/ml]. E. coli could be detected in all samples, however, samples with ~101 cells/ml had several contaminating OTUs constituting between 8.2 to 46.7% of the read abundances. Based on our findings, we recommend using the PowerWater DNA Isolation Kit for DNA extraction in combination with PCR amplification of the V3-4 region for drinking water samples if a broad overview of the microbial community is to be obtained.